Re:Will the Last Startup Leaving Dodd's America Please Turn ...
by anigbrowl on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @01:31AM
(#1215050)
I can't help feel you're responding to individual bits of my reply rather than the whole thing. As for the rational basis of such rules, I invite you to consider why the securities act of 1933 was created in the first place, and the circumstances which led up to that.
Re:Will the Last Startup Leaving Dodd's America Please Turn ...
by gojomo on Wednesday March 24, 2010 @07:18AM
(#1215428)
Whatever good was in the depression-era securities regulations, other parts were an overreaction, just like SarbOx has been. Now, much of their paternalism is obsolete. Non-millionaires of 2010 have knowledge and resources far beyond that of depression-era barons.
And irrational exuberance, not fraud, is how the masses lost the bulk of their money -- then and now.
We just lost trillions in real estate value. Should non-millionaires be prohibited from buying real estate, by law, because circumstances have shown they're just too feeble-minded to make such investments? That would be a modern equivalent to 'accredited investor' rules originating from depression-era biases.
...which limits them to a tiny fraction of the private investment opportunities available to millionaires. Why make things harder on the wise-but-poor? Or those who have wise-but-poor friends-and-family?
...to turn your argument on its head, why not get rid of the limits altogether...
That's not the argument on its head -- that's the argument itself! Net-worth-based discrimination has no place in securities regulation.
If an unwise or gullible person can throw their entire net worth -- and then some, via leverage -- into a single risky real-estate transaction, or risky options trade, or risky loan to an unreliable acquaintance, or risky superbowl wager -- then there's no rational basis for preventing them from buying private securities.
Some will be burned, and learn (and teach others via their example). They'll do better the next time -- as with all the other expensive failures we let people experience with their own money.
Fraud can be prosecuted under existing fraud laws. And the majority of honest entrepreneurs and wise-but-poor investors will have many, many more opportunities to explore the small-business solution-space with angel capital.