News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by pdq on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:30PM (#12134207)
I still don't understand the SolarCity part. Tesla is atop the best rated electric cars, and has a good trajectory toward that product line future, with lots of innovation ahead. Successful companies like Apple focus on best-in-class products, so Tesla is smart to continue focusing their resources into those product lines.

Meanwhile SolarCity has been burning cash on a consistent basis [1], and is sitting in a hyper competitive solar panel industry, where I don't see their competitive advantage. It seems foolish to bring that business inside of Tesla, as if it failed, the debt risk would now affect Tesla's future. As many others have mentioned, a long term licensing deal or partnership avoids those risks.

[1] http://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/musk-says-solarcity...

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by maratd on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:00AM (#12134548)
> I still don't understand the SolarCity part.

People who buy electric cars are far more likely to buy solar panels. And storage batteries. And wiring they would need for the electric car. It's all directly related.

So when I buy a Tesla ... I have to hire a 3rd party to install the wiring to charge it. I can buy the storage battery from Tesla, but again, need to hire someone else to install it. And if I want solar panels for that storage battery, again 3rd party.

SolarCity has a fleet of professionals ready to do all of that. They also have a plant to manufacture their own panels, which hopefully they'll be able to differentiate on. Combining the two companies will enable Tesla to service that whole loop with the equipment and installation.

Now, you can argue that Tesla may have been better off starting their own division from scratch or buying someone else ... but from what I heard, they're getting a hell of a bargain for SolarCity.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by snowwrestler on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:20AM (#12134627)
> People who buy electric cars are far more likely to buy solar panels. And storage batteries. And wiring they would need for the electric car. It's all directly related.

Is this true? I'd be interested in learning more about the data behind this.

Anyway, for the sake of discussion let's say it is. Does that mean there is a correlation that scales to the whole population?

Or is it just that electric cars and solar panels appeal to the same small segment of the population? That would show a strong correlation, but not scale well.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by ne0n on Friday July 22, 2016 @03:58PM (#12146337)
Generally, having an electric car would push your electric bill into much higher usage tiers where the power is most expensive. Solar panels make the most sense for people who use the most electricity and pay the most for it. I've seen first hand that people who drive electric cars like to talk about clean energy and if they've got solar panels on their roof, it refutes the argument about burning coal to generate the electricity. As solar panels continue to drop in price, it starts to make more sense for the rest of the population, too.
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by maratd on Thursday July 21, 2016 @01:09PM (#12138331)
> Or is it just that electric cars and solar panels appeal to the same small segment of the population? That would show a strong correlation, but not scale well.

Tesla is a luxury product company. All of their products are either luxury or commercial. Their strategy scales well in that segment.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by robszumski on Thursday July 21, 2016 @01:55AM (#12135034)
This is a huge problem and you're right, Tesla is set up well to solve this. Think of a buying experience where you stick a pack on the roof, and only have to run two cables, one for the house and one for your garage. The roof unit could contain the batteries, panels, inverter hardware, and cooling system. Not exactly unboxing a Mac, but with some creative thinking I bet they could find a way to sidestep enough of the painful parts.
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by OliverJones on Thursday July 21, 2016 @08:31AM (#12136370)
I'm doing business (in my household) with both Tesla and Solar City. I can tell you this about Solar City: They're doing with roofing and power meters what Tesla is doing with vehicles. They're promoting a location-aware distributed electric-distribution grid.

We're lucky right now that the government's promotion of PV is putting the burden of power storage on the power-grid operators. Without net metering, this stage of PV would never happen. But net metering is essentially bad for the grid operators; they get paid nothing for storing power or sending it from a net producer to a net consumer. They will eventually prevail like they tried to do in Nevada earlier this year and buy power cheaper than they sell it.

But in the meantime the power grid companies haven't got a chance without competition. My home electric meter is as dumb as a box of hammers, even though I spend a lot of money with it and rely on it to keep my family safe in the winter. If that meter were capable of telling me when the power I used was coming from a peak-load diesel generator, I would happily turn off my electric stuff. But they can't do that now.

PV needs to use this window of opportunity to get going, and to get other power-storage solutions working. A Model S is one of those solutions: a gigantic battery with wheels and cruise control. To my way of thinking, systemwide integration is an electropolitical move worth making.

From a personal point of view, I can say that Solar City's sales and engineering teams are smarter and more committed than the people at other PV companies I spoke to. They are trying to build a scalable business rather than bopping from town to town installing stuff and moving on.

Will this work long term? Who knows? But it's worth trying.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by slouch on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:12PM (#12137804)
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by vadym909 on Thursday July 21, 2016 @10:31AM (#12137075)
whats PV
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by Snowdax on Thursday July 21, 2016 @11:22AM (#12137442)
Photovoltaics. AKA Solar panels
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by davidz on Thursday July 21, 2016 @01:39AM (#12134976)
The product isn't solar panels, it's energy. With a huge fleet of electric cars needing to be charged in major metros, where is the electricity coming from?

What if you also have a massive deployment of solar panels on top of existing real estate, that you essentially don't have to pay rent for?

When Teslas are autonomous, and owners are using them to make money by giving other people rides. How are these cars getting charged? And that energy doesn't come for free. Tesla will have their hand in every piece of transportation.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by pfranz on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:46AM (#12134722)
I thought SolarCity's competitive advantage was solar leasing [1]. Which would mean they're sacrificing upfront profits for longer term gains and any dollar spent now would very likely mean profits in the future. I haven't paid enough attention to see how well that's going.

Oh, and I've heard Tesla described as "a battery company that makes cars." Solar is also tightly coupled with battery tech since without it they're a lot less useful. Maybe that's the synergy?

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SolarCity#Solar_leasing

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by furyg3 on Thursday July 21, 2016 @07:06AM (#12136047)
Solar leasing is not going to be profitable, very soon.

Solar panels (+ installation) is now pretty cheap and getting cheaper. Subsidies are being removed, financing is available. It's becoming a no-brainer. So they're winning there, but this creates a problem. When a significant portion of homes have solar panels, the power companies can no longer act as a free-ish battery for day/night or summer/winter. They will have to massively adjust their pricing... charging solar homes for storage, paying them a crap daily rate, and charging higher rates a night and in the winter. Regulators will be forced to let them do this because otherwise they will go bankrupt.

This screws with the solar leasing model. Tesla makes big batteries that happen to have wheels on them, which gives a lot of room to innovate here. They can smooth out the day/night cycle; car/home owners can profit from the low energy price instead of be punished by it (especially if you're uber-ing out your car); used car batteries that aren't ideal for continued usage in cars (say 70% capacity or slower charge/discharge rates) are fine for power smoothing in your basement, etc.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by parasdpain on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @11:07PM (#12134342)
Agreed but I feel Musk is not here to do a business; he is here to fix humanity. Normal logic does not apply on him, just like when he used all his earnings from selling Paypal and decided to start a roket company (SpaceX)! Other enterpreneurs literally laughed at him and called him crazy.
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by gkya on Thursday July 21, 2016 @12:22AM (#12134637)
Oh he is the SV Messiah? Honestly enterprise is enterprise. Look what Google have become.
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 21, 2016 @04:36AM (#12135550)
He's not SV Messiah, he seems to be simply the lucky combination of right perspective on the world and enough money to make it happen. The only bad thing about this is that it is so rare.

> Honestly enterprise is enterprise.

What I like about Tesla and SpaceX is that they're honest, plain companies. They exist as means to an end. Vehicles to achieve material goals - in this case, sustainable transport and making humanity multiplanetary. This is how all companies should work, and yet somehow we got lost on the way and most companies exist to make money, without giving much shit about how exactly they're making this money.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by gkya on Thursday July 21, 2016 @10:58AM (#12137266)
Companies are in the business of selling things for profit. That's essential to them, because they have to pay taxes, create capital and produce, which are all results of commerce. For this they need to maintain an image. And with the first danger to its image, we've seen how Tesla reacted: statistics manipulation and aggression, instead of admitting its their fault and promising to work for better. So we can't bet on companies' honesty, ever.

Elon Musk as a person, is a person. A single person. You say that he "seems to be simply the lucky combination of right perspective on the world and enough money to make it happen." According to whom? Interplanetary travel's possibility and practicality is questionable, let alone human chance of extraterrestrial survival. Some may well think that this is a waste of resources. Sustainable transport is nice -- and I love Tesla cars for being seemingly practical non-fossil cars -- but self-driving cars are a big change and actually requires moral adaptations. Would being killed by a self-operating machine equal to being killed by a manual car? Who is to blame if an accident happens? What do I do if my spouse goes under a self-driving car and it is not her fault? Do I sue the car? What happens if it is found guilty (i.e. it's AI is mistaken)? Do we jail the car? Is Tesla to pay me in indemnity? If my self-driving car hits another car's rear bumper, am I liable? Do I recompensate the other driver? Who is liable if an automatic vehicle breaks some traffic rule? What if it passes when it's red?

If all cars are electric, how we'll be affected by increased electric demand? This will mean increased CO2 production with geothermal production, and increased nuclear waste to be disposed off with nuclear production. Will we have to build more dams? Will we instead use the same dinosaur oil to to produce electricity, canceling out the gain?

We should think on these, and Musk being a SV angel figure is not an answer to these questions. We did not question anything till the end of the past century, and we are at the edge of a climate disaster. This tech (self-driving) means a great, big change to our daily lives, and it cannot happen because someone who "seems to be simply the lucky combination of right perspective on the world and enough money" wanted it to.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by TeMPOraL on Thursday July 21, 2016 @11:32AM (#12137505)
> If all cars are electric, how we'll be affected by increased electric demand? This will mean increased CO2 production with geothermal production, and increased nuclear waste to be disposed off with nuclear production. Will we have to build more dams? Will we instead use the same dinosaur oil to to produce electricity, canceling out the gain?

The answers to those questions are simple if you care to look for them - or even listen to the "SV messiah". Sure increased electricity demand may mean upgrades to infrastructure, but this happens anyway as peoples' dependence on electrically-powered devices grow. Nuclear waste is an utter non-problem, it only seems so because of unfounded fears. The fact is we can manage it. As for using fossil fuels, even that outcome would be a huge win - power plants are more efficient than internal combustion engines in cars, so even by just centralizing the burning of that oil you're saving lots of energy.

I'm not going to take a position on "statistics manipulation" - I haven't seen anything besides few HNers jumping to conclusions, and I recall that the actual outcome turned out to favour Tesla's position even more. But maybe I'm missing something, I'll happily read up if you could point me to a good source.

Circling back to the point about companies - what you described is the mechanism how companies work. What I was talking about is the reason to found them. As it is today, most companies are what I fondly call "toilet-paper companies" - ones that couldn't care less about what they're actually doing as long as it turns in profit, and would gladly switch to selling toilet paper if it was more profitable than their current operations. Tesla and SpaceX are the rare kind of companies for which their stated goal is the terminal value, not an instrumental one. That's why their decisions keep baffling people - because we're not used to see businesses actually driven by ideas (as opposed to saying so for PR benefit) very often.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by Symmetry on Thursday July 21, 2016 @11:28AM (#12137483)
You can think of a Tesla, to a gross approximation, as a giant battery with some wheels strapped on. Giant batteries are more than anything else crucial to their business and what they spend a lot of time figuring out how to manufacture well. That's why they've gone into the business of selling batteries for temporarily powering homes or letting people store solar energy.

And once you're in the business of selling solar storage batteries it makes some sense to integrate with a solar provider.

But I think you're right in your second paragraph and it might make more sense for Solar City to just be a re-seller of Tesla batteries without Tesla buying them.

Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by tim333 on Saturday July 23, 2016 @07:31AM (#12149173)
The proposed SolarCity acquisition is probably bad for Tesla shareholders but good for Musk personally as he was the largest shareholder of SolarCity and the deal will kind of bail it out. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-06-21/tesla-anno...
Re:Master Plan, Part Deux by mtgx on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @10:55PM (#12134293)
I think time will tell if the movement proves "foolish". However, there is one reason why this makes sense. Storage batteries and solar panels will go hand in hand for the vast majority of sales. So it makes sense for Tesla to want to control that half of the "solution" for renewable energy generation.