Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by pdkl95 on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:38AM
(#12127791)
This is the hubris of "NOBUS"[1].
Believing that "NObody But US" has secret knowledge tends to create a false-confidence trap. It doesn't matter if your are a small criminal organization or a large and well-funded government agency; assuming your adversary is ignorant or stupid is terrible security.
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by sseveran on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @01:33PM
(#12130845)
While not perfect it may not have 0 value. I work in a somewhat esoteric part of finance and it is very easy to distinguish experts from people with a medium amount of knowledge. It forces your adversary to become far more committed and use far more resources than they otherwise would. Although I could imagine using a watson like technology to obviate the need for a human to memorize all the required information.
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by jiiam on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:52AM
(#12127831)
It's still better than letting anyone with just basic knowledge in. I mean, if a cop can learn to pass those tests, surely a committed pedophile can, with the twist that the pedophile would not find the whole process disgusting.
In a way, the test could be taken to be a deterrent to police forces, who presumably will be challenged by the prospect of having to learn the minutiae involved in child abuse.
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by zdkl on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @05:58AM
(#12127860)
If you can't beat em, make them more like you, right?
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @07:43AM
(#12128250)
I'll take "effects of terrorism in the united states since 1990" for $400, Alex.
Re:Usenet Tradecraft: Survival in an Extremely Adversarial E...
by jimmytidey on Wednesday July 20, 2016 @03:51AM
(#12127462)
This stood out to me too. Seems like it's a subculture with social norms like any other- not just a prosaic file sharing system.
This part seems strange to me. Police officers working in...this area, look at a lot of the relevant material and are probably intimately familiar with the details of famous cases. If anybody can be expected to pass such a test, it's a cop.