News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Training Computers to Find Future Criminals by pc86 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:39AM (#12122036)
> It is ethically imperative to aim to eliminate disparities and social inequalities between races

Agreed 100%

> even if...judgments become less accurate in the process.

Absolutely not. You are actually advocating that because someone may come from a "marginalized higher-crime group" that they not be punished accurately should they commit a crime?

> If you accept that government should want to avoid a segregated society, where some groups of people form a permanent underclass

I agree that society should want that, but I don't agree that the government should act as a force to impose social justice upon society.

> you should avoid any algorithm that results in an increased differential arrest rate for those groups, even if that arrest rate is warranted by actual crimes committed.

Literally saying that someone from a "marginalized higher-crime group" should get away with criminal activity.

Re:Training Computers to Find Future Criminals by pdkl95 on Tuesday July 19, 2016 @10:56AM (#12122137)
> punished accurately

How is it "accurate" to punish someone not based on their own actions, but because they share traits with a particular group of people?

Prejudice doesn't become acceptable just because it's based on a complicated algorithm and a lot of data. Judge people for what they did instead of pre-judging them because they seem similar to a group you don't like.