Compare this with an established early 20th century neighborhood in the central part of a city. You have classic Craftsman architecture and homes built by people with real carpentry skills, using hardwoods, brick, stone, and other durable materials. These homes, properly maintained, will last another hundred years. Chances are (in 2016, anyway), it's a gentrified or gentrifying neighborhood. If you can pick up a home in this neighborhood, you've probably made a good investment.
Now, in X years when it's dated and some things needing repairing, you've got cashflow to cover that, factored into your money model. Multiply that by a few properties, and even if the "investment" hasn't budged a dime in value, you're making money. At a scale where you can hire a management company to take care of the details for you, it's even simpler.
I also think you gloss over the difficulties of being a landlord. Great tenants are the exception, not the rule. There is good money to be made in the rentals game but the markets in which you can do this are limited and strongly favor the landlord who has owned for decades and bought in at 1970s prices (SF, LA, etc.). For most people in average American cities, the best you can hope for is to cover expenses and build a little equity. It's no slam-dunk for the average Middle America landlord.
Heck, subtract out all the interest you paid on your mortgage, and you're nearly guaranteed to be in the red, if you're not buying places for cash.
The only way to look at a house as a monetary investment is to actually seek to make money directly off of it; namely flip it or rent it. Don't sit on it and think it's going to be a significant financial positive for you. Value it as your home, and as an expense you deem worth it.
It really depends. In Australia, tax concessions and negative gearing often mean making an operating loss on your rental is preferable, as you can deduct those losses from any other taxable income sources.
In fact modern architects and builders here have a really negative attitude towards Craftsmen and similar styles: as far as they're concerned it's all old and boring. The result is predictable; neighborhoods are razed flat for profitable high density dwellings which frankly are one notch above Soviet Brutalist style, usually clad in the least durable and cheapest exterior possible.
Houston has incredibly low urban density and I'm not above improving that in places. But it should done with an eye towards a beautiful legacy. The only thing beautiful about block upon block of stucco and aluminum siding townhomes is the builder's bank balance.
What neighborhoods are you talking about? I don't see anything near the Brutalist style anywhere in the city. A lot of the older parts of Houston have those three story townhomes, but they all look pretty nice. A lot of the homes that those places are replacing were pretty rough.
But I'm not exactly alone in criticizing the recent architecture found in Houston townhomes and condos. Check out this graffiti http://i.imgur.com/AxxvkU1.jpg and the discussion of it on the Houston sub-reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/houston/comments/4td1y7/found_this_...
This is the major factor that makes rents so insane in prewar parts of cities, where the few remaining dense old neighborhoods in city cores are targets for gentrification. People want to live there -- and demand is rising as large numbers of millenials reject the suburbs -- but there cannot be any new supply built due to zoning laws.
For example, almost all of the expensive dense old Boston inner suburb of Somerville would be illegal to build today under its present zoning laws: http://cityobservatory.org/the-illegal-city-of-somerville/
You realize the burbs can become highly desirable areas right? I've lived in a number of cities where the butbs in 1960 became hot areas in 1990 due to population growth.
People who bought houses here for $100-200k in the 1980s can sell them for more than $1 million today.
Of course if you buy houses and rent them out you can make money. Being a good landlord takes work though, and it's by no means a guaranteed way to riches. Having unused rooms in your house or land that's idle? Lousy investment. Summer home? Lousy investment.
Indeed, being a landlord is work, but I think that being your own landlord and pocketing the tax deductions and "imputed rent" is quite manageable for a family.
- Just because some gets you a positive return, doesn't mean it's an ideal investment. If you can get a 6% return, then an investment getting you 3% isn't that great.
- Real estate is local. Schiller is looking at average across the entire country. Areas appreciate at different rates. If you're lucky enough to buy in an area where prices are rapidly appreciating, then it can be a great investment. If you're buying at the top, then it can be a really bad investment.
If you're lucky enough to buy red on the right spin, roulette is a great investment.
Which is silly because you'd never invest that way.
As an individual investor you probably don't care about other people's returns, but an economic analysis has to look at the average case and not at what lucky/sophisticated investors get.
Which is same conceptually as "investing on average across the entire country". So, while I'm not encouraging real estate investing, what you are saying runs completely against the generally accepted conclusions of Finance Theory.
However, the average rate of return on real estate is pretty consistent. That would argue that although areas appreciate at different rates, over a long enough time period, they returns are all pretty small.
As to your second observation, I look for cashflow, appreciation is just a side (but not necessary) benefit. Appreciation gains depend on selling to the market, and with a shorter timespan for the deal, is usually referred to as flipping.
To me, flipping is similar to speculation.
Cashflow is similar to investing in a business/going concern. The value of the business can go up or down, but the monthly payments keep showing up in my bank account.
The article talked about investing, but I would rarely consider one's personal home an investment for reliable financial gain. Far too many costs involved that are not offset by income, until the final sale. And the sale _might very well_ depend on timing and other people's (market) opinion to get the most return - Not something I want to depend on.
So for me, the way I invest, real estate has been a rewarding investment.
Have you actually looked at the Schiller time series data? It's an average of regional data. It's entirely appropriate to consider Schiller's subindexes if you live in one of the 20-30 metro areas they pull from.
He completely ignores the effect of mortgages (leverage) and the expense of renting instead of buying. He ignores investment property (as you highlighted), the ROI of building on vacant land, tax advantages of owning, and numerous other factors.
Thank you.
Real Estate works for us, more than paper assets, and less day to day time requirements than building a business for sale (exit plan) or that someone else operates for our profit. Everyone is different, YMMV.
Education is key. If you would hire a coach for exercise/strength training in a gym/fitness club, then I would highly recommend hiring a coach for real estate investment. As I stated elsewhere in comments, we went over the same material (and more) in 6 months with a coach that it took me 3 years to piece together on my own.
Patience - We were not ready to actually purchase our first piece of property until almost 4 years after we started preparing. Preparations for us included making our credit report as beneficial to us as possible, learning about the responsibilities of being a landlord, learning about the job duties of a property manage (even though we sub that out, we still want to know what is appropriate and what is not), learning about negotiations (did you know you can include almost anything in a buy/sell contract? "We'll pay $x and this 320i BMW in return for that piece of property" is a deal I heard referred to by another real estate investment expert), learning about the legalities of business entities with respect to real estate ownership, and so on. Now we just save up for the next down payment, then start looking for the next deal. And although there are ways to get into deals without a large (or any) down payment, they usually require considerably more effort and time, and I have a service business to keep going. So we do it the more lazy/easy way, with cash and financing.
Due diligence - It is better to walk away from a deal that I just can't make cash flow enough, than to get stuck with a poor/sub-performing investment. We walked away from quite a few deals, even though there were several I was relatively sure I could make work. On-site inspections have uncovered many potential gotchas that would have been financially painful. Some landlords extract the most profit out of an investment they can, and this can frequently result in much deferred maintenance, which can get very expensive very quickly. And like a start-up, you can only sustain a given burn rate for so long, before the deal crashes.
Teamwork - Although I have been gifted with what intelligence I have, it is not a good thing if I am the smartest person on my team/in the room. We all have different strengths, and I am not good at everything, so I try to surround myself with teammates that provide those missing/weak areas I have, as well as mentors who have already gone down that road. Having a good property manager go over a property will help me identify concerns, see places for improvement, etc. Having a reliable contractor (I am still looking for my next one, last one wasn't a good fit for us) can keep me out of those large up-front costs. A knowledgeable attorney for real estate investment in the area I am investing in is very important - It would be terrible to build up a portfolio then lose it all because I did not adequately protect ourselves (entity + insurance + operating practices).
Okay, enough. Sorry for the deluge, but I really _like_ the process of real estate investing.
There is also a large contingent who make a profit by coaching, so there is a sizable pool of those types of people/firms, as well. As long as I know from the outset what the motive is from the potential coach/firm, I can weigh what I am told to decide if it has value or not. Example: Free class? Usually has something hidden. Class on xyz for $399? Material more likely to be upfront, and of course a possible "up-sell" to more classes.
A sad fact (to me) is so many people do not _do_ what they learn about, that I do not worry very much that I may lose a prospective deal to a fellow student/coach. In fact, I would benefit from more people practicing investments like this in an ethical way, improving my community, as well as possibly conditioning people to expect proper deal making practices in my area.
Also, as I just alluded to, real estate is a very _local_ endeavor, so a mentor/coach may be from a different area and may have little interest in opportunities in the area you look in - Which may or may not be the area you reside in.
Two of the coaches I have hired in the past come from The Rich Dad contingent. Kiyosaki has garnered much attention, negative and positive, so if you pursue them, do so with your eyes open. I think he is sometimes a jerk in some of his presentations, but most of the time he is conveying basic knowledge, and I have found much of this knowledge from other sources, outside of his organization. It is one of my tenants that if I get the same information from multiple distinct sources, there is a higher probability it is an underlying truism or is at its base likely sound (or at least based on sound information). But do keep in mind they run a for profit company, and one of their items for sale is more classes/coaching.
I live in California, so another source I have looked at for like minded people (and their source of coaching/information) is the California Apartment Association, as well as North Coast Rental Housing Association. There are very likely similar agencies in your area/country to find other people who share your interests.
I periodically stay in touch with some of the people I have shared online classes with, so those communities can be built and be a source of information, as well.
I have heard it repeated that there is a large amount of money chasing business deals right now, one way of being involved (and earning some of it) is learning how to put those deals together.
But I have only gotten out of it what I put into it...
To me it's not so much about building wealth in real estate, as saving money on living accommodations in order to build wealth elsewhere.
But based on my experience, I would recommend you just keep looking. We have a fourplex in California, it cashflows about $200 per unit, but part of that is due to the healthy down payment we put up. And this is in an economically depressed county, the work environment is so-so, _contrary_ to my research mentioned above.
Due diligence is the key for us. I optimized on "most income potential for the down payment," then ended up paying extra because the previous owner had a firm line in the sand and someone else was also interested in the same property.
Thanks to phantom cashflow (depreciation) and the repairs we make here or there, we put money in our pockets but are able to show the IRS a loss during _some_ years, based on the US tax code (conservatively legal).
I have been corrected before on HN about "too good to be true" numbers, so I do need to point out YMMV. We were beneficiaries of being in the right place at the right time, but we also spent the previous years getting ready: reading books on residential rental real estate investing (note the specific angle there - many ways to make - and lose - money on real estate, be specific), cleaning up our credit reports, building up a down payment, learning the local markets so we could buy something local and keep an eye on our first property, learning about property management and being landlords, meeting and interviewing prospective property managers, meeting and interviewing prospective real estate agents, and then setting up the correct legal entity to hold the property in. We hired a coach after the first purchase, and had much of the same learning material, but far more compressed - We went over in 6 months what it took me 3 years of research to get on my own. And that does not include the invaluable tips one can get from someone who already walks the talk.
We also evaluated at least 10 properties in person that did not pass muster, and that was after weeding out scores of properties that we did not even bother to visit.
We had a few deals fall through, but usually because something was not good enough, usually not enough return on investment, or too much deferred maintenance (requires deeper pockets to get in, but can be more profitable in the end - IF you know what you are doing. And have a good team.).
This specific deal earned us %13 - Not great, but definitely better than other deals. I have a friend who would not look at deals unless they had %28 ROI or more in them, but then he also talks a big game :)
But it IS possible. In fact, thanks to the elastic property of real estate negotiations, it is a place where you can still get in with nothing down every once in awhile, but one really has to be prepared for those deals when they come through.
Besides location, location, location, I think the bigger catchphrase should be financing, financing, financing. There is a lot to be said about the art of negotiation, when it comes to a buy/sell agreement.
But again, YMMV, and I only got out of it what I put into it in sweat equity, as well as capital.
And, we are still learning...
We also own a rental in Florida, but that is a whole other story...
Even the investment in farmland is not taking the production of the business into account. Wouldn't that be similar to investing in some servers, but letting them sit and hoping they appreciate in value, rather than being involved in what the servers are doing?
This article seems so at odds with land/home investment, I am wondering what Schiller's real motivation is with it, or if it is taken out of context...
What am I missing?