This number system was used to invent calculus, and worked just fine for over 150 years despite theoretical unsoundness. And it turns out that it's possible to formally define a provably consistent number system that obeys our intuition, the hyperreal numbers. See:
I disagree that it is possible to sum an infinite amount of integers. It would take infinite time and space to perform the calculation. There is literally no end to the integers, so the calculation would never complete.
I also still claim that the result cannot be positive infinity due to the definition of addition on integers. The result of addition of integers must be another integer and positive infinity is not an integer.
I do agree with the article however, that one can take the limit of a well-defined infinite series; but the limit is not the sum, only the bound that will never be exceeded no matter how long you are able to continue adding numbers for.
I completely agree with you and the article that 1+2+3+...=-1/12 is a sneaky trick and that the definition should be rejected.
That same argument gives you Zeno's paradox.
You can sum a pattern of numbers in O(1) time if you use logic instead of brute force. It doesn't matter if physically spending O(n) time on something is impossible when you only need O(1).
I believe Zeno's paradox is on the rationals, not integers.
>You can sum a pattern of numbers in O(1) time if you use logic instead of brute force.
There may be closed solutions for finite summation patterns, but infinite summation patterns of integers have no solution (by definition).
Also, yes, you can't literally compute an infinite sum but among any crowd that has likely taken calculus 1, you can place implied limits. :P (which, arent actually needed in the hyperreals because it HAS infinity, but whatever)
This not something you can agree or disagree on. You can make physical calculations with this result and get a prediction that you can measure and confirm. This result is sound.
In this case you might find the -1/12 useful, but have the opinion that they really should not be using '=' as a shorthand for what they're doing with the zeta function.
I agree. Infinity is a process that can yield a number but is not an actual number and, Cantor et. al. notwithstanding, there is no such thing as a "completed infinity" other than terminating it at a finite step. If you are careful and in certain contexts you can use the "limit" of an infinite converging process but you must make that assumption explicit to avoid errors.
All these bizarre math tricks rest on treating it as a number when its undefined. Its like those puzzles I read as a kid that "prove" 1=0 and they typically depend on an implicit division-by-zero step which is also undefined just like infinity. Once you start working with the undefined you have to very careful and even Gauss made errors when he was laying the groundwork for infinite series. To the degree that this math has ANY validity it is in the context of some esoteric and specialized area of math and it is NOT appropriate to foist it on the general public as a general result. The motive in such attempts is to impress or intimidate or destroy math (nihilism) which I find despicable.
There is no answer for an infinite sum. It is impossible to sum an infinite quantity of integers. The answer is definitely not positive infinity, as that is not a number and the sum of integers must be an integer.
The article points out a few times that such a "sum" is undefined.