id say thats a fail.
if i have a circle of circumference 5
the sum of 1+2 is equal to both 3 and -2.
Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12?
by raverbashing on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:48AM
(#12106494)
Having two possible answers is not ambiguous, if you're defining a position in your circle in two ways
sum continues to work in the same in your circle (Commutativity, Associativity, Identity element and a + 1 is the next successor of A)
the definitions are identical to a number line
+ is a move to the right
- is a move to the left
The point is, in "the universe" most of "infinity" are actually finite circles that you can travel along "infinitely" - because you eventually arrive back where you started.
and -1/12 just means 1/12 to the left before you get back where you started moving right.
Oh we can definitely agree to that
> that what you consider the bad definition is actually the good one
Sum is pretty much well defined for different sets used in mathematics. In none of them the sum of infinite positive numbers is a negative number.
Here's a definition for a bad definition: it is ambiguous