News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by tinco on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:27AM (#12106125)
I wouldn't assume my definition is a better one than any other. But I am just like the articles author confounded by the idea that you can communicate this equation on a public forum without making it absolutely clear that you are interpreting the equation in a way that is different from the way an undergraduate or just regular person would interpret it.

I get how it's fun for intellectual people to come up with new definitions for things that expand our knowledge and understanding of the universe, and tease people who have the old simple understanding with seemingly impossible quandaries. But I would like the emphasize that I think this teasing is counterproductive. It leads people to believe mathematicians operate in a field that is fully disconnected from reality. Either take the time to explain how you define your construct, so they can truly appreciate the usefulness and ingenuity of the equation, or use different symbols and present it as a valuable yet opaque contribution to practical mathematics by showing its applications. Both cases will yield the much deserved admiration.

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by manish_gill on Saturday July 16, 2016 @09:13AM (#12106234)
What you're actually saying: "Make math simple enough for regular people to understand"

Problem with what you're saying: Hundreds and Hundreds of years of history and tradition and the sheer knowledge that's been built up in the current way we do Maths.

Another problem: It's not teasing if the ideas are actually complicated. Which this one most certainly is.

Another problem: Not all Math is practical and applied, some of it almost certainly operates in a field that is "disconnected from reality".

Another problem: Your solution of using different symbols has the same problem as XKCD standards.

Another problem: "Regular people" is vague. People fear math for a reason. They can suck at it.

Another problem: This idea is also fairly old. So your part about "old simple understanding" also doesn't hold true.

Only thing we can agree on: Math can suck at communicating ideas if you're not used to it and/or don't have the context and knowledge.

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by GavinMcG on Saturday July 16, 2016 @09:28AM (#12106264)
I think you're missing one important consideration, here: they're saying "make math simple enough for regular people to understand when your audience is regular people."

Scientific American is targeted at educated laypeople. The author's job is to communicate with that target audience. And it absolutely is a tease to use a headline that, to that audience, will come over as a bizarre indication that they're actually clueless.

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by avian on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:26AM (#12106119)
He didn't say "bad definition". He said "unintuitive" and I agree. The video is obviously meant for an audience that is not intimately familiar with infinite series or their applications in string theory. I'm sure most people found it most unintuitive as it is very much in conflict with how sums behave in everyday life. The fact that the video failed to discuss the important details is well worth criticizing, as the article explains.
Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by raverbashing on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:27AM (#12106124)
> The arrogance here is breathtaking.

Oh we can definitely agree to that

> that what you consider the bad definition is actually the good one

Sum is pretty much well defined for different sets used in mathematics. In none of them the sum of infinite positive numbers is a negative number.

Here's a definition for a bad definition: it is ambiguous

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by mSparks on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:38AM (#12106459)
id say thats a fail.

if i have a circle of circumference 5

the sum of 1+2 is equal to both 3 and -2.

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by raverbashing on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:48AM (#12106494)
Having two possible answers is not ambiguous, if you're defining a position in your circle in two ways

sum continues to work in the same in your circle (Commutativity, Associativity, Identity element and a + 1 is the next successor of A)

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by mSparks on Saturday July 16, 2016 @10:59AM (#12106528)
the definitions are identical to a number line + is a move to the right - is a move to the left

The point is, in "the universe" most of "infinity" are actually finite circles that you can travel along "infinitely" - because you eventually arrive back where you started.

and -1/12 just means 1/12 to the left before you get back where you started moving right.

Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by oneloop on Saturday July 16, 2016 @09:31PM (#12108629)
What are you talking about? How is it ambiguous?
Re:Does 1+2+3+... Really Equal -1/12? by flipp3r on Saturday July 16, 2016 @08:24AM (#12106115)
Have you?