News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Torgo on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:38PM (#12096632)
Any time I read anything about legalizing all drugs I am struck by how that opinion would change if they tried to function with a heroin addiction.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by sophacles on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:51PM (#12096714)
How is it any different than trying to function with an alcohol addiction? Are you suggesting that we should ban the booze too?

A surprisingly large amount of arguments against drugs are circular:

Addiction is bad -> make it illegal -> look at all the legal trouble addiction causes -> Addiction is bad.

And most of them get even sillier if you replace the drug being demonized with the word alcohol.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Torgo on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:52PM (#12096716)
>How is it any different than trying to function with an alcohol addiction?

pretty different! Both the addiction, how easy it is to get addicted.

I've got a challenge for you, start using heroin, then decide to stop, like a casual drinker. Report back your experience!

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by TheCoelacanth on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:14PM (#12096847)
FYI, withdrawal from alcohol is among the worst of any drug. It is one of the few drugs where withdrawal can actually be lethal.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Delirium_tremens

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by PeCaN on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:25PM (#12096907)
OTOH, it takes a lot longer to become physically dependent on alcohol than opiates.

But yes, don't mess with your GABA system unless you like seizures; and don't mess with your opiod system unless you like being miserable.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by fucking_tragedy on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:43PM (#12097028)
It takes sustained periods of constant or binge drinking to first enter withdrawal territory with alcohol. I know people who binge on the weekends, are definitely psychologically addicted to alcohol, but experience no withdrawal symptoms.

First time you do heroin, dose once everyday for 3-7 days and you've got yourself a very painful withdrawal ahead of you. Once you're no longer heroin naive, it could take only 2 doses in a week's time to send you back into withdrawals.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Torgo on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:51PM (#12097087)
I had withdrawal symptoms after two times using opiates, and the experience was horrifying. I cannot imagine being a regular user, then having to cease. I would probably end my life rather than experience that.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by squeaky-clean on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:24PM (#12096899)
> I've got a challenge for you, start using heroin, then decide to stop, like a casual drinker.

Just because it's easy for you to refrain from drinking alcohol does not mean it is easy for everybody. Some people have a serious problem to the point where the only way to guarantee they don't abuse it is to not even be in the same room or house as the stuff.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by jshevek on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:30PM (#12097315)
> Some people have a serious problem to the point where the only way to guarantee they don't abuse it is to not even be in the same room or house as the stuff.

His point remains: Heroin is intrinsically different from alcohol, given the ease with which a new user can become addicted after a just a few uses. We should be careful of false equivalencies when discussing how the law should treat these two substances.

Bringing up those people who've already reached the level of 'serious problem' that you describe doesn't address his point.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by liquidise on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:53PM (#12096727)
Your comment illustrates just how little a drug being illegal does to keep it from being abused. I've never seen someone arguing that people should do more heroin, instead that drugs being illegal is a failed experiment.

While it feels like the easy way out, do not confuse drug legalization as supporting the abuse of hard drugs.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Torgo on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:00PM (#12096774)
You are underestimating the number of libertarians on this site that just see the destructive effects of an incredibly addictive dangerous drug as a problem you could solve using the free market.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by mindcrime on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:34PM (#12096962)
You are underestimating the number of libertarians on this site

There's two or three of us left, yeah.

that just see the destructive effects of an incredibly addictive dangerous drug as a problem you could solve using the free market.

That's not really an accurate view of what (most) libertarians believe. I don't feel like writing a huge monologue here, but I'll say this:

1. Libertarians are, in general, opposed to the initiation of force to achieve social/political/whatever ends, because we consider initiation of force/violence to be immoral.

2. Within that framework, most libertarians also support a free market approach to economic issues for a variety of reasons, both moral and consequentialist.

3. The goal of libertarian approaches isn't to "solve problems" like drug addiction using free market techniques, or anything else. The goal is to eliminate the use of initiation of violence. Whatever else happens as a result of removing initiation of violence from the equation is seen as being either a. acceptable, and/or b. a problem that needs solving through whatever means can solve it without initiating force/violence.

Now, libertarians will argue, quite rightly, that the free market does provide the best solutions to many issues. But we don't actually claim that the free market is the be-all end-all that magically solves all problems. We just think a world based strictly on voluntary cooperation, despite whatever other problems might endure, is a better world than world predicated on use of force/violence.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by pzone on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:14PM (#12096844)
I think you're mischaracterizing people here. I think everyone would agree drug addiction is a problem that requries some government intervention. But clearly the policy we have right now is not great. The argument is that legalization + prevention + treatment would be, overall, better than prohibition. Not perfect, but better.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by jshevek on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:37PM (#12097357)
I absolutely agree that the parent didn't do justice to the range of opinions, and your post improves on the discussion.

I'd like to nitpick the word "requires" (vs "is best served by")

> everyone would agree drug addiction is a problem that requries some government intervention.

Personally, I believe that it is absolutely theoretically possible to address our societies drug addiction problems without any government intervention, if only we as a culture were willing to do so.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by hasenj on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:47PM (#12097430)
Addiction is a personal psychological problem. How can the government intervene? The government cannot make you happy.

Look at obesity rates.

People get addicted because their life sucks. How can the government make their life not suck?

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by pzone on Friday July 15, 2016 @12:49AM (#12098994)
Sometimes government can solve problems, other times it can't. Even in the case of obesity, the government at least tries to educate people. But addiction is not so similar to obesity, because it's much easier to monitor and control people's drug use through regulation than it is to monitor and control people's food intake.

I think drug use is more like payday lending. Payday lending a shady industry, people who take advantage of it are often not too well off, and sometimes people make terrible decisions and screw up their lives, to the profit of the lenders. (or drug dealers.) But people are always going to want to borrow money for short periods of time just like people are always going to want to use drugs. No government policy is going to make everyone in the world happy, but we can try to minimize the number of miserable outcomes with some careful intervention.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by hasenj on Friday July 15, 2016 @02:04AM (#12099209)
The only viable intervention is education.

Case in point: school lunch in Japan

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0vwC51FxP10

I have an eery feeling that something like this will never fly in the US. People will complain about 'muh freedom'.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by squeaky-clean on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:32PM (#12096950)
> You are underestimating the number of libertarians on this site that just see the destructive effects of an incredibly addictive dangerous drug as a problem you could solve using the free market.

Nobody has said that here. So until one of those libertarians comes in and comments, let's keep the discussion to what has actually been said?

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Archio on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:14PM (#12096846)
Why have you never tried heroin? I am struck by how often the response to that question is not "because it is illegal".
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by ponyous on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:47PM (#12097424)
Is this your actual experience? I have talked with few friends about this and all of them pretty much said: "I don't want to destroy my life"
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Archio on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:17PM (#12098582)
That's precisely my point. Most people avoid heroin because they don't want to destroy their lives, not because it's illegal.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Thursday July 14, 2016 @09:29PM (#12098434)
I have never tried heroin because at the time when I learned about it, I looked at some information and came to the conclusion that it would not be a good decision to make given the physical addictiveness of the drug. To be honest, I attributed almost zero weight to the fact that it was illegal.

Remember, opiates are legal now, with a prescription.

I wonder, hypothetically if there was a drug where the effects were as pleasurable as I assume heroin must be, but with no physical addiction or nasty side effects, would people still be against it?

What if, in the future, your cellphone could emit a frequency that generates pleasure in your brain, but as soon as you turn it off, you are back to normal. Would that be made illegal?

Could it be simply a moral objection to unearned pleasure that people are really against?

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Friday July 15, 2016 @12:26AM (#12098930)
Oh, I forgot to say that also it seemed much more dangerous to directly inject a drug of unknown providence into your vein than to smoke or swallow it. There's also a risk of infection that isn't there with drugs taken by a different method.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by colatkinson on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:54PM (#12096734)
Typically, advocates of universal legalization want to increase spending on rehabilitation, etc., so addicts would actually be able to seek and receive treatment instead of hiding their problems.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by Torgo on Thursday July 14, 2016 @03:56PM (#12096750)
I am in favor of decriminalization of consumption, not of legalization.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:02PM (#12098542)
Decriminalization of consumption is better than the current situation, but I am in favor of legalization and regulation.

It seems kind of hypocritical to me to say it's acceptable (or at least not illegal) for people to consume drugs, but not protect them by giving them any ability to know what it is they're actually taking, because they would still have to buy drugs of unknown strength from shady characters, manufactured in dodgy underground labs from ingredients of unknown origin.

Maybe decriminalization of consumption, as well as government testing labs that can identify unknown substances for people? That opens up it's own can of worms, of course.

It's a difficult conundrum, but our current system is the worst possible option. Almost anything would be an improvement.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by MichaelGG on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:34PM (#12096963)
It's not that hard to function if you have legal access. Opiates are stupidly cheap. With clean equipment, no illegality, no difficulty buying -- it simply would not be that big of an issue for many people. Remember that many (millions) of people are on opiate therapy and manage to function. The heroin junky stereotype is usually for people prevented from obtaining medicine via legal channels.

Indeed, even the hygiene part could use some open innovation. Right now IV users mostly have to repurpose insulin needles (interchangeable thin needles (like 30G)) are rare. Long-term IV use is geared towards hospital use.

Removing the medical industry gatekeeping of who gets to use opiates would blow open the marketplace.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:13PM (#12098572)
Indeed, even the hygiene part could use some open innovation. Right now IV users mostly have to repurpose insulin needles (interchangeable thin needles (like 30G)) are rare. Long-term IV use is geared towards hospital use.

Needles aren't illegal, are they? Can't people just buy them?

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by MichaelGG on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:55PM (#12098690)
They are hard to obtain in many places. Plus "no one" does IV-direct-to-vein-injections on a regular basis. It's either IM (so larger needles), subcutaneous (like insulin), or IV catheter (larger needles, expected to stay in a day or longer). So even in places that do carry needles, it's unlikely you'll find e.g. Luer-Lock 30G.

In some places it's illegal, as it's "drug paraphernalia". In the UK there was even a story about a kid being denied buying teaspoons since he was underage (patients often cook drugs in a spoon before injecting).

So IV patients right now have a very hard time. If they are lucky, they can convince a pharmacy they are diabetic and need insulin needles, in some cases.

Legalizing would mean stores can sell and make money, and would start to reduce the stigma.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Friday July 15, 2016 @12:23AM (#12098921)
Wow.

If there's any better evidence that the drug wars have nothing to do with public health or safety, I haven't heard it. That's bananas.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by DanBC on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:38PM (#12096994)
People currently have heroin addiction. They also have considerable problems caused by dirty heroin - the contaminants in heroin make injecting pretty risky. Lack of access to clean needles, and lack of a clean safe space to inject make injecting pretty risky.

Treating opiate addiction as a public health, not criminal justice, issue requires some of the tens of billions spent on the war on drugs to be diverted to health and social care.

Re:Shedding light on the dark web by fucking_tragedy on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:35PM (#12096968)
Typically when I see a "decriminalize it all" opinion espoused it's followed up with contingency that drug & safety education, exchanges, therapy, detoxification and rehabilitation are also sufficiently funded to address current issues and any other that may arise from decriminalization.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by aqme28 on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:26PM (#12096913)
Does making something illegal reduce its rate of use? I'm not convinced that it does.
Re:Shedding light on the dark web by brokenmachine on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:22PM (#12098596)
Does making something illegal reduce its rate of use? I'm not convinced that it does.

Really?

All other things being equal, you'd have to agree that it does, wouldn't you?

Going to jail is definitely a disincentive. Otherwise the people who choose to do illegal drugs would just do it out in the open, with no regard for the threat of incarceration.

I don't think that many people would do something with the only reason being because it is illegal. Would you? There has to be some other incentive, for example the drug makes you feel good, or is an interesting or novel experience? Otherwise, why do it?