News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by wyager on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:18AM (#12093977)
Jesus, I hope that's false. Cyberspace isn't real. It's absolutely insane to suggest that one ought to have control over some abstract data just because there exists a vague correspondence between some part of that data and some piece of land they own in the real world. Should photographs of buildings be illegal? After all, it's just a virtual representation of the real property. In fact, it's a much closer representation than just "these fake coordinates vaguely resemble these real coordinates".
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by heartsucker on Thursday July 14, 2016 @11:24AM (#12094613)
So let's say in some future everyone is always wearing AR. Now let's some someone somehow got derogatory terms to constantly float above your head. There are negative impacts from this: loss of job, harder to meet people, unable to get hire.

Because AR "isn't real", should you have no recourse against this? At the gut level, that doesn't feel right, so as much as some people want to pretend The Web is some wild west of freedom and lawlessness, it really makes sense (some times, with experts consulted) to have (some) regulations.

Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by wyager on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:07PM (#12096807)
You're leaving essentially everything about this scenario underspecified, but no; it should not be illegal to say mean things about someone through technology. Do you really have to ask that question?
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by heartsucker on Friday July 15, 2016 @06:14AM (#12099890)
If somone followed someone else around all day and yelled obscenities at them, there are laws to punish the perpetrator. If someone followed you around everywhere you went on the internet and comment and messaged and posted obscenities at you, you'd want the same protection.

I'm not saying people shouldn't be able to speak freely, but somewhere out there is a line that crosses from exercising freedom of speech into harassment.

This comic [0] explains it nicely. Just because it's on the internet and "not real life" doesn't mean it doesn't affect your happiness or your life "offline."

[0] - https://xkcd.com/1216/

Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by wyager on Friday July 15, 2016 @12:01PM (#12101914)
> If someone followed you around everywhere you went on the internet and comment and messaged and posted obscenities at you, you'd want the same protection.

It's called a troll, and no I wouldn't, because I'm not a tremendous wanker. I'm an emotionally stable adult who can deal with someone calling me names.

I prioritize free speech over the feelings of people who can't take shit on the Internet. It's not that I've never felt bad after someone criticized me on the Internet; it's that I understand that life is full of positive and negative interactions and you have to deal with both. Crying and demanding that insulting you be made illegal is a puerile and unhealthy response.

Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by TheCoelacanth on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:37PM (#12097359)
That seems like it would be covered by defamation without adding any new laws to deal with cyberspace.
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by heartsucker on Friday July 15, 2016 @03:41PM (#12103325)
In that case yes, and in the above:

> It's absolutely insane to suggest that one ought to have control over some abstract data

I was responding to that to say that it's not insane to govern the internet either by new laws or by applying and extending existing laws. My point was to illustrate a case that should without a doubt merit some governance when it's just "abstract data."

Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by tremon on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:23AM (#12094024)
I think you're missing context here: the GP specifically said he was talking about implications of AR application intersecting with real property.
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by BatFastard on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:57AM (#12094363)
AR and its intersection with real property is a HUGE topic. Can people post ads on your building in AR? Can they write nasty things about you and your customers? Can they setup trap for drug dealers? There are literally hundreds of such questions. Do you have control over how Google maps depicts your properties, how about China Netcom? AR is the worlds biggest genie, and people are just starting to become aware of it. The idea of "Controlling AR" is ridiculous! Its going to come from a million places..
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by yoodenvranx on Thursday July 14, 2016 @10:38AM (#12094172)
Yes, exactly, I am not talking about some random virtual world but specifically about AR and its connection to the real world.

I wonder what the military thinks about the Ingress portals and PokemonStops on their bases. In worst case that will results in some virtual ban zones around military compounds where AR is forbidden.

Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by wyager on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:06PM (#12096797)
AR doesn't "intersect" with anything. It's virtual. It's pixels on a screen. What shows up on my screen has no connection to someone else's physical property.
Re:Ad Agencies Scramble to Form ‘Pokémon Go’ Strategies by monocasa on Thursday July 14, 2016 @11:43AM (#12094778)
> Cyberspace isn't real.

You could argue it's just as real as the other fairly arbitrary borders that define public vs private property.