Seriously, all they need to do is add a basic pokemon PVP with the same battle mechanics from the mainstream, and maybe random events, and they could keep it going for a good while longer.
Also, the always-on-gps is a huge issue with it. They need to find some way to lessen it.
I think this is very true, when I was in 5th grade It wasn't wandering around catching pokemon that made me love the game. It was battling my friends, and trading with them.
Catching Pokemon is the core gameplay aspect of it. Walking around, discovering new places, new Pokemon is what the game is currently meant to be about. That is why the PvP is laughable compared to other games.
Then again, that only really makes sense if they really thought it was going to have a bunch of new players, and I'm not sure there were indications it was going to be this big?
Niantic will have to iterate quickly to build in depth. The need to walk around is a lot of friction to playing a location based game. They'll have to introduce features that are enticing enough to overcome that friction. Simply collecting pokemon and filling out the pokedex isn't going to be enough in the long term.
The only reason I play Ingress is the social aspect of it, and the need for walking. I don't have any other game in my cellphone that I play regularly and I don't care about angry birds and so on. If I want a seated experience my computer has far better games.
So, it depends on the user, there are no absolutes in gaming.
On the other hand, the strategic games that are at the heart of Ingress depth don't exist in Pokemon Go, so we'll see.
* It's not even obvious that the first 'catch' is a choice between the three starting pokemon?
* What's the green circle which changes shape mean?
* What's 3 footprints? Look online for a bunch of myth already being set up.
* One prominent site is still suggesting you can "pick up" missed pokeballs so they're not wasted!
Ingress' tutorial & tooltips were far better designed.
So far Go lets you search for pokemon, power them up, and "battle" with them. Trading is coming. Isn't that pretty much everything the previous umpteen Pokemon games let you do?
Unless they flesh out the gameplay (either with new elements or mechanics, or by "porting" over from the existing games in the Pokemon franchise), the success of the game could easily be short lived.
(I've not installed Go, and don't intend to, so it may have some actual game in there beyond collecting and tagging locations. Everything I've read seems to indicate it's as shallow as Ingress with a graphics change).
By the time they have a strategy and have included locations the moment will have probably passed. I also wonder how non-playing folks at a sponsored gym (say) will feel about the foyer or cafe being full of kids playing phone games. At least some attempts will carry negative as well as positive consequences.