News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:16AM (#1209310)
One thing that bothers me about taxes is that they are around 20-30% of profits. If you take on a business partner and give him/her 20%, you expect something in return.

What do we get for our taxes? Wars and social programs that will be bankrupt long before we can benefit from them. (roads, etc., are < 1%).

I would be OK with paying the taxes for social programs if I thought those programs would be sustainable into my old age, but they aren't and nobody seems to care, even though this is widely known.

So when you write the IRS a big check, you are paying for old people, and when you are old you will not receive the same treatment.

By the way, most of the cost of healthcare is in areas where the money has very little yield, such as end of life care for the elderly, bypass operations, stents, and statins. If people actually had the opportunity to consider the value of healthcare, reform would be nothing like what it is now.

Next time you see an old person eating bacon and eggs in a restaurant, picture that person's bypass operation, years of statins, and excessive end of life care that you are paying for... and think to yourself how perverse "reform" is.

Meanwhile, there are millions of so-called "illegal immigrants" who can't even call the police if they are assaulted or abused (for fear of deportation) being left out of the reform.

Most of your income taxes go to wars and medicare, and most of the healthcare reform goes to the practitioners who practice useless surgeries and interventions on a vulnerable population of elderly.

The "reform" bills don't change anything, they just transfer even more of the wealth of young people to the elderly and their exploiters.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by MartinCron on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:38AM (#1209374)
I like driving too, but don't focus too narrowly on roads. I think you're getting benefit from more than < 1% of taxation. Public education helps everyone. Research helps everyone. Having a criminal justice system helps everyone (well, the non-violent drug offenders would disagree). Having a strong civil legal system helps everyone. Meat inspectors help everyone. Financial regulators help everyone.

You could even say that knowing that we don't have senior citizens starving and dying in the streets as helping everyone. I like knowing that I live in a society that takes care of many of the less fortunate.

I'm not saying that government is good at solving every problem, but focusing on just roads, wars, and old people is very narrow.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:55AM (#1209557)
As you'll notice in my comment I was not arguing against a social safety net. I was arguing against "paygo" social programs that will not be sustainable in the face of demographic change. I was not arguing against the criminal justice system either. And as you point out, nonviolent drug offender enforcement is a huge burden on society for a variety of reasons.

Not only do I not want senior citizens starving and dying in the streets, I want to be sure that a senior citizen 50 years from now won't starve or die in the streets.

Consider what congress has done to social security benefits over the past few decades. Right now the social security retirement age is OLDER than the average lifespan of African American men. Why are you defending this approach?

People work hard for years and plan for retirement only to have the social security retirement age increased. If a private firm did this the CEO would end up in jail. Why are you defending this racket?

If you're going to take by force 12.5% of someone's lifetime earnings (all most middle class people can afford to put away for retirement), you'd damn well better live up to the promise you made to him about what he'll get and when.

You seem to think that taxes == good social programs. On the contrary, the current budget is full of unsustainable things that only exist to give a handout to one special interest group or another... everyone knows they aren't sustainable and that they exploit those paying in now, but there is a collective action problem (which, incidentally, you are helping to perpetuate).

I've paid lots of money into social security... where has it gone? To fund the war in Iraq. Where will it be when I retire? By that time Soscial Security will probably have been cancelled or merged into the general budget or turned into a welfare program. I really don't understand why you would defend a regressive tax that allows congress to avoid having to be accountable for what it spends.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by muhfuhkuh on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:32AM (#1209510)
I always have and always will take umbrage with how people downplay the government's role in ameliorating the lives of people.

Case in point, can anyone really deny that the overwhelming majority of the cures and vaccines for deadly afflictions that have plagued the US (and the planet, for that matter) have been developed in a university or non-profit lab under the funding, technology transfer, and/or support of governments (in the US case, the NIH)? Polio (Salk), TB vaccine (Calmette), the list goes on. Hell, even Norman Borlaug helped eradicate famine in several parts of the 3rd world under the encouragement (and part-funding) of the Roosevelt administration.

You're right that it's not just about socialized interstates and bunker bombs. It's truly about doing those things that just _cannot_ fit on any sane balance sheet trading on Wall Street (or if they tried, investors would truly revolt).

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @04:59AM (#1209814)
It's truly about doing those things that just _cannot_ fit on any sane balance sheet trading on Wall Street (or if they tried, investors would truly revolt).

This, to me, is the single most convincing reason for the government to be in charge of health-care, and not the markets. It's always been my assertion that the government needs to be responsible for investments that vest in an amount of time longer than the length of the average career; things like basic science research, retirement benefits, and health care.

I think the failure of the American automotive companies makes this point rather clearly. When automotive execs were faced with a decision in the 60s and 70s to either raise salaries or promise their workers plush retirement benefits, which did they go for? The retirement benefits, of course! Why? Because those execs would likely be long dead and gone before the proverbial shit hit the fan. Ah, but what about the investors? Shouldn't they have demanded long term fiscal responsibility from the executives? Um...why? If you were 20 in 1960 and invested $100 in GM, how many times over would your money have doubled before the trouble began? ...and you'd be 70 now! If you were a prudent investor, you would've moved that money out of stocks and into bonds sometime during the surpluses of the 90s.

In my opinion the government should exist to cover those things the market won't (or to sufficiently incentivize markets to act responsibly enough that they do cover extremely long term investments).

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @03:20PM (#1211114)
You bring up some interesting points.

I'd argue that the much maligned concept of "corporate personhood" is designed to solve the problem of individuals having short (and finite) time horizons for making cost/benefit calculations.

Similarly, patent law offers a tradeoff between unfettered innovation monopoly by offering a limited, short-term monopoly on exploiting new ideas. Consider briefly the FDA approval process and a profit-seeking scientist developing a pharmaceutical. The scientist has a 20 year time horizon to maximize profits, so she has a huge incentive to do R&D and to launch the product. Meanwhile the FDA regulator collects the same salary whether he approves or delays approval of a drug, yet he stands to be fired and disgraced if the drug he approved causes harm. If he's overly cautious in order to keep his job, society suffers profoundly.

If you claim that government is better than private industry at solving these sorts of problems, you are making the rather strong claim that the incentives of the FDA burocrat are broadly superior to the incentives of the R&D scientist.

It follows that you would believe that if all R&D scientists were paid a fixed salary and stood to gain nothing for finding a breakthrough drug but stood to be humiliated and disgraced if any unforeseen consequences of a discovery occur, society would be significantly better of.

I think that's a fairly sweeping claim to make, and I'm curious if you could elaborate.

Also, with respect to the automotive pensions, I think you'd be well advised to review this history of the PBGC (pension benefit guarantee corporation). It is a government entity tasked with offering pension insurance for workers in the event that the firm fails. Surprisingly, both unions AND corporate interests lobbied congress to decrease the premiums firms would pay into the PBGC. The result is that the PBGC is not actuarially sound and that if a few major US firms failed the PBGC would go belly up.

Why did this happen? Corporate interests understand that once the government provides a safety net, so long as they were compliant they have nothing to lose (plus, if the firm failed then it's game over anyway). Unions focused on increasing the current allocation of benefits and didn't worry about the future... after all they "won" improved pensions for workers and were pleased when firms could dedicate the extra cash (saved by having artificially low risk premiums) to other forms of compensation, etc. So in this case the government clearly acts on the whim of interested parties and utterly fails to protect citizens (even though doing so is a trivial matter of actuarial calculations and collection of a premium!).

So I would be curious to read your elaboration based on these points of rebuttal.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @10:45PM (#1212039)
Whether we call it "corporate personhood" or "the state", I think you and I do not disagree that much. Let me try restating my premise:

I make personal decisions based on the effect those decisions will have in my lifetime. I make family decisions based on the effect those decisions will have in my or my children's lifetimes. Presumably, a corporation should make decisions based on the effect they will have in the corporations lifetime which should, because it's a corporation, be regarded as unbounded.

The problem is that responsibility is a slippery thing with respect to corporations. If the CEO makes a decision which will result in disaster in 100 years, is the CEO responsible when that disaster occurs? or will the CEO be dead? So then the shareholders should be responsible, right? except how many current shareholders will still be shareholders in 100 years? Sure, stocks take the future into account in the price, but how far into the future? At some point, the "outlook is hazy" and stocks put decreasing emphasis on outcomes the further into the future those outcomes will be realized. So who is responsible?

My premise is that, if left to market forces alone, no one is responsible! That means that market economics, alone, cannot make wise 100 year decisions. Ah, but what about states? A state whose corporations have all made bad long-term decisions is not going to last very long, so that over a long enough time scale there will be an evolution toward states which can force responsibility for long term decisions onto someone. I would argue that this is at least partly the reason for the rise in representative forms of government: when the governing responsibility is amortized over the entire population, decisions will likely be made with an eye to at least two lifetimes (the classic "won't somebody think of the children", or "our children will have to pay off our debt").

The bottom line is that sometimes governments have to make decisions that seem at odds with the markets, because they must be responsible for the long-term consequences in a way that corporations are not.

Let's take your R&D scientist, and I'll turn the problem on its head: Given that I have 20 years in which to recoup my expenses, why would I study diseases of the poor or cure short term illnesses? The poor can't pay much for my pills, and a pill to cure pneumonia will only make money for a week or two per person. So what do we end up with? Statins! Lot's and lots of statins! High cholesterol is a disease of the rich, and once you start on statins you have to keep taking statins the rest of your life.

What don't we have? Antibiotics! In fact, most people don't talk about it, but there is a looming antibiotic crisis on the horizon. I've spoken with an expert on the appearance of antibiotic resistance who has studied MRSA and VRSA, and he gives us 20 years until we're basically out of effective antibiotics. You don't have to take my word for it, though...just look at the timeline for the discovery of new antibiotics, and how much it slows down there toward the end: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_antibiotics.

So what of the FDA bureaucrat? It's a straw man unless you can tell me the name of the person responsible for approving thalidomide for use as an anti-morning-sickness treatment. The individual bureaucrats have little to no incentive to not simply "follow the science", but as a society we have every incentive to have a safety net that keeps us from having to support a generation of armless individuals.

This is already getting a bit long, but as for the PBGC? Well, so what? Everyone lobbies the government and gets to give less money to the government and put more money in their pockets. That's a government failure if ever I've seen one. Of course, its not surprising given how close we've allowed corporate interests and government to get.

I was discussing this just the other day with a friend, and if it were up to me to fix the government, you know what I'd do? Every federal politician is set for life! Food, housing, vacations anywhere you like...it's yours! The taxpayer cost for the number of politicians that affect our lives with their decisions would be negligible, but it would effectively remove any and all impact that special interests could have on politicians. Also, if you knew that, when you went into the voting booth, you'd be rewarding someone with a lifetime free pass...well, I bet you'd think about that choice a bit harder than you do now, right?

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @03:21AM (#1209704)
Ok so you've successfully argued for 1% of the Federal budget and 5% of state budgets. I hope you're not going to stop your thought process there.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by muhfuhkuh on Tuesday March 23, 2010 @09:21PM (#1214629)
Manned space missions that go more than "just passed the exosphere", making sure people with the pre-existing condition called "old" and "dirt poor" and the extra-duper fun combination "old and dirt poor" are actually not left to die on the streets with a simple infection, networks of massive national laboratories whose prime mission is to secure technologies and advance science for one of the most technologically advanced and by far most innovative countries on earth (perhaps not in the adoption of personal electronics, but we surely laid the foundation for all innovation, not the least of which was von Neumann and his work with Eckert and Mauchly's ENIAC, the first programmed computer). Those labs take several billion a year each to operate, and have arguably single-handedly placed and kept the US at the forefront of technology for decades.

I'm not going to pussy-foot around it, we spend 50% of our tax dollar on defense, and most of that into personnel and pure weapons r&d and manufacturing. It's a shame, but it's the truth. Just imagine if we could refocus those dollars elsewhere (in an ideal world, anyway), where would we be now?

More importantly, why hasn't private industry come and done it for us?

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @05:01AM (#1209816)
Well, ya gotta be able to kill people! That accounts for another 23%...
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by startuprules on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:16AM (#1209465)
I would dare to say that our government sucks at solving any problem. A few examples:

U.S. Teens Trail Peers Around World on Math-Science Test http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/12...

U.S. prison population dwarfs that of other nations http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/23/world/americas/23iht-23pri...

Lehman Cooked The Books Prior To Collapse; Geithner And NY Fed Implicated http://thelibertyguardian.com/2010/03/lehman-cooked-the-book...

Let's face it; our government is setup to help the big corporations.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by MartinCron on Monday March 22, 2010 @02:28AM (#1209629)
Oh, come on, that's just confirmation bias. Our government solves lots of problems. A few counter-examples:

People love Medicare. It helps keep old sick people from financial ruin. That's a good thing.

Lots of banks have failed in the last few years, but government-run programs (FDIC, mostly) keep the fallout from damaging citizens.

The United States is home to many world-class research institutions, many of which receive government grants.

Bernie Madoff was running a huge ponzi scheme to defraud investors, but was eventually caught, by the government, and sent to prison.

The military and US AID have helped save lives and assist in reconstruction of post-earthquake Haiti.

FAA regulators have made air travel extremely safe.

NHTSA and other regulators have improved the safety of cars and saved countless lives.

The Parks department has conserved millions of acres of winderness for people to enjoy for generations.

The Endangered Species Act has literally saved species from disappearing from the planet.

The National Science Foundation helps fund RadioLab, the best thing on the radio.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @03:12AM (#1209690)
Uh, if the banks had been allowed to fail the FDIC would have been wiped out.

If GM and Chrysler had been allowed to fail the PBGC would have been wiped out.

Fannie and Freddie were wiped out and would incidentally have failed due to investor flight in the early 2000s if they had submitted financials to investors like other firms (meanwhile the CEOs got very rich). BTW off the books entities are what everyone hated about Enron... our GSEs are the exact same scheme.

Bernie Madoff's daughter was married to a SEC official and in spite of being reported to the SEC multiple times over the years his fund was not investigated. Only the biggest financial crisis since the great depression made his scheme unsustainable, at which point the fraud was obvious, and he was used as a scapegoat for the crisis itself... as if his fund caused it!

Some of the items on your list are good services that are provided by government... but if you look at the government budget they make up (at best) a few percent.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by MartinCron on Monday March 22, 2010 @11:36AM (#1210531)
I was responding to a preposterous absolutist comment that government sucks at solving any problems. This preposterous absolutist comment was backed up with a small handful of examples solved poorly by government, so I put up a few counter-examples. You can counter some of my counters and we could go back and forth all day, but that doesn't help anyone.

The fact that government can provide multiple valuable services for just a fraction of overall budget each isn't proof of anything. There's a very trendy and shallow mindset these days that government is absolutely terrible at absolutely everything. The truth is more nuanced than that.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:17PM (#1210641)
That may be true, but just as the smallest scientific theory is usually the best one, the smallest government intervention is usually the best. This entails that a local program is usually going to be better than a state program, which is usually going to be better than a Federal program at addressing needs.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by protomyth on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:14PM (#1210637)
In this specific area, the gov is treaty-obligated to provide health care to Native Americans. They have failed miserably - http://www.reznetnews.org/article/indian-health-cares-broken... - the sad part is that those stories in the article are the typical and not even the worst.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by patrickgzill on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:22AM (#1209325)
My one-sentence view of what is going to happen in America is that "repudiation is coming" - on multiple levels, people, organizations, maybe even states will say "sorry, we can't fulfill obligation X any longer, we are done paying" .
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by patio11 on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:36AM (#1209368)
Or, less extreme, changing the terms of the promise after the promise is made. Very few pension funds are so comprehensively mismanaged that they will not be able to pay any pensions, but very few are so competently managed that they will be able to pay all promised pensions, so look for them to do things like means testing to get out of their obligations. ("You spent the last forty years saving money by yourself!? Pfft, what do you need a pension for. Amscray, we've got people who actually need the money to look out for.")

This is inevitable for social security, and I'm thinking the gold-plated public pensions (and many private ones) will follow suit.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by adolph on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:39AM (#1209377)
Case in point: "But even if the decision does leave some Arizona children without health-care coverage, Orient said, there is no alternative in the state's current financial situation. 'At a certain point, it doesn't matter how good you think a program is,' she said. 'If you can't pay for it, what are you going to do?'"

http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/2010/...

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jeremymcanally on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:20AM (#1209318)
The idea behind a big piece of the reform is to reward doctors who push preventative care over pills, surgeries, and continued treatment. Therefore (ideally) we will see less and less of these preventable surgeries since doctors and hospitals are striving to reduce their preventable and recurring care for patients (i.e., they get cash if they reduce it).
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by gojomo on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:45AM (#1209395)
Can you provide a reference for this "cash benefits for doctors who reduce long-term costs" portion of the bill?
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by blasdel on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:21AM (#1209475)
I think this is one of the parts of the bill where the imperative and desired result is outlined clearly, but the mechanism to that end is left up to an independent commission to start implementing in the next several years.

I think it's a very smart move: lets them avoid 'Big Design up Front' and the associated bickering + reification.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by gojomo on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:51AM (#1209549)
This seems based on the idea the future will be braver at making tough choices -- and saying no to popular overspending -- than the present is.

Is that the long-term political trend? More steely-eyed fiscal realism each year? Is our society today braver at telling organized lobbies (including suffering or fearful people), "no, that sounds nice but costs a lot more than the proven benefits", than it was a generation ago?

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jacoblyles on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:24AM (#1209331)
My favorite proposed solution is "defined contribution instead of defined benefit", which would address most of the incentive problems and inequities you mention.

In Washington, they call it "privatizing" and run you out of town.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by coryrc on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:23AM (#1209330)
And for anyone who doesn't believe you, here's Newsweek's take on increasing the burden on the young:

http://www.newsweek.com/id/224020

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by stretchwithme on Monday March 22, 2010 @02:55AM (#1209668)
I think you see things very clearly. Such is the quagmire of a declining democracy where most people are intent on shifting the costs of their decisions to everybody else.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jamiequint on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:15AM (#1209464)
"most of the healthcare reform goes to the practitioners who practice useless surgeries and interventions on a vulnerable population of elderly"

A lot of doctors don't want anything to do with medicare patients because they are often breakeven at best and in many cases a net loss. They are many times required to care for these patients in order to maintain hospital accreditation programs that allow them to look attractive to patients with insurance (where the hospital actually makes some profit).

It is good to pay attention to healthcare availability, but no sustainable solution can ignore the cost side. Excess litigation has played a significant role in the massive overinflation of healthcare costs. Flooding hospitals with patients with government insurance - likely to be net-negative income for hospitals - is going to destroy the healthcare system faster than it fixes it.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by kurtosis on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:27AM (#1209337)
I find myself very sympathetic to your view - especially the part about not wanting to pay for wars. I have also frequently heard people claim that entitlement programs to support the elderly are "unsustainable" - but I honestly don't understand what this means. Do you mean that the costs of providing for our elders would grow without bound? Also, if you know of a nice explanation that presents the evidence that entitlement programs like social security are doomed I would be very grateful if you could provide some links. I would really like to know.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by Xichekolas on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:40AM (#1209382)
The entitlement unsustainability is entirely a problem of demographics. People are living longer and having fewer children, so the ratio of young working people (who pay) to old retired people (who benefit) is diminishing.

The classic answers are to either increase FICA taxes or cut benefit levels... which seems idiotic, when the obvious solution (to me) is to just raise the eligibility age. Part of the problem is that people are living longer, and are mostly healthy and able to work longer, so raise the retirement age.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by orangecat on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:37AM (#1209519)
Part of the problem is that people are living longer, and are mostly healthy and able to work longer

You're right about the demographics, but I'm not sure this part is correct. Yes people are living longer, but it seems that a great deal of that is that when a 70 year old contracts condition A which used to be fatal, we can now often keep them alive at great expense until they die at 80 of condition B. It doesn't mean they'd be effective workers at 70.

My "obvious" solution is to focus on curing aging, which is generally the fundamental cause of both A and B. Until that happens, means-test benefits. Warren Buffett doesn't need to be getting checks from the government.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jacquesm on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:42AM (#1209530)
'Curing' aging is really going to break the economy. Pension systems were not meant to take care of people for ever, if 'aging' gets cured then you can expect to work until you drop dead.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by sailormoon on Monday March 22, 2010 @04:44AM (#1209797)
If aging is really cured then I will be happy to work until I either have the assets to retire unassisted or work forever. After all, I'll be in perfect health. And just think how productive I will be after a century or two!
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @05:09AM (#1209824)
Ok, people really have to STOP entertaining these sorts of ideas. "Aging" is not going to be cured. PERIOD. FULL STOP!

The primary increases in longevity over the past century have come from increasing survival into adulthood. If, instead of considering longevity at birth, you look at longevity at 35 (that is, how long you can expect to live if you've already made it to 35), the increases are a lot less dramatic. Furthermore, if you look at the records for "oldest living person", that number effectively hasn't moved in the last 200 years, and is stuck somewhere between 110 and 120, which should give you a pretty good idea of where the upper limit is.

Sure, with improvements in medicine, we can keep people productive into their 70s and 80s when they used to spend their last decade or so as invalids. The future of medicine looks like this: you're healthy and active into old age, then you hit the floor. No long suffering, no being bed ridden...but you still hit the floor at some point.

Entertaining the notion that we could live forever if only we spent enough on medical technology is one of the main reasons that we're in the situation we're in. You are not immortal. You will die.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jacquesm on Monday March 22, 2010 @06:07AM (#1209904)
> You are not immortal. You will die.

Spot on.

I keep saying that but that's not a very popular point of view here.

HN is rife with 'uploaders' too, people that think that within their lifetime they'll be uploading themselves in to a computer so they'll be immortal.

I really don't get how people can delude themselves like that, given 0 evidence some enormous extrapolation gets made which then attracts a lot of followers.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by sailormoon on Monday March 22, 2010 @10:35AM (#1210381)
Speaking of 0 evidence ...

The human body is a machine. It is a very complex and intricate machine, but a machine it is nonetheless. Yes, we do not yet have the understanding. Yes, we do not yet have the necessary tools. But we will have them one day.

It is a machine, and any machine can be fixed with the right knowledge and tools, and it would seem quite foolish to claim otherwise.

It would seem equally foolish, of course, to plan one's life around the very uncertain wager that these technologies will be acquired by humankind within one's lifetime. No disagreement from me on that one.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @10:12PM (#1211964)
Sorry, but you're wrong. The human body is not a machine. The human body is a collection of chemical processes. Chemical processes must obey the laws of thermodynamics. Among those is the second law, which dictates the tendency toward disorder. We, as humans, are allowed to "disobey" the second law because we represent far-from-equilibrium forms known as dissipative structures (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissipative_structures).

Now, you might say that any machine is a collection of chemical and physical processes. Fine. If you want to perpetuate a machine analogy, consider this: the camshaft in your car is subject to chemical wear through oxidation, etc. Eventually, the gear teeth will wear out, and it will need to be replaced wholesale. Fine, you say, we'll make replacement parts. But what about the brain? You can replace any arbitrarily large set of components in a car's engine and still call it the same engine, but do you think that holds true for humans as well? And even, say, we figure out how to preserve the human brain (or even, gasp upload it)...problem solved, right? Nope, sorry again. "You" are not your brain. "You" are an emergent property of your entire body. Your brain without your body is as much "you" as your body without your brain is...

Bottom line: study some biology. It's not as simple as the "easy A" course you took in high school or college led you to believe.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by foldr on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:35PM (#1210704)
>Yes, we do not yet have the understanding. Yes, we do not yet have the necessary tools. But we will have them one day.

We'll only have them one day if they're not beyond the limits of our understanding. Given that our understanding has limits, this is far from certain.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by Xichekolas on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:44PM (#1210719)
> Given that our understanding has limits, this is far from certain.

That is a pretty big assumption to make. If you are saying that our understanding is limited at this point in time, then I'd agree. Barring loss of data/memory, our understanding will always be limited now compared to our understanding in the future.

But if you are claiming there is some fundamental upper bound to our understanding, and that a complete functional understanding of the human body is beyond that upper bound, then I have to ask what motivates that claim.

Not to put too fine a point on it, but that kind of thinking is what supports flawed pseudoscience like "intelligent design" (not claiming you support that, and really not trying to open that can of worms; just drawing a parallel). Sure, if you assume that our understanding is already at some kind of limit, and then show something we can't explain, it follows naturally that it must have supernatural origins. If, on the other hand, you realize that our inability to explain something is most likely just a function of time (eventually we'll learn enough that we will be able to explain it), then the argument seems absurd.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by foldr on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:59PM (#1210759)
>But if you are claiming there is some fundamental upper bound to our understanding, and that a complete functional understanding of the human body is beyond that upper bound

I'm claiming the first conjunct. I don't know whether or not a complete functional understanding of the human body is beyond our understanding.

I don't see why a claim that our understanding has certain fundamental limits should need to be justified. Rather, the opposite claim seems to require justification. If you look at any other animal on earth, this is obvious. Why should we be the only animal without limits?

This is not to suggest that what we happen to know right now is the upper limit, just that there is an upper limit.

>not claiming you support [intelligent design], and really not trying to open that can of worms

Oh please, this issue has nothing at all to do with ID.

> it follows naturally that it must have supernatural origins.

Or, more plausibly, that it has natural origins which are too complex for us to understand.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by orangecat on Monday March 22, 2010 @01:34PM (#1210854)
"Aging" is not going to be cured. PERIOD. FULL STOP!

Why not? It may be difficult, but aging is a collection of physical processes, and physical processes can be modified with sufficiently advanced technology.

Sure, with improvements in medicine, we can keep people productive into their 70s and 80s when they used to spend their last decade or so as invalids. The future of medicine looks like this: you're healthy and active into old age, then you hit the floor.

That's exactly my point. Medicine today consists largely of playing whack-a-mole with diseases whose underlying cause is aging. That's expensive and produces continuously decreasing benefits. We haven't failed to cure aging; we haven't even tried.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by jballanc on Monday March 22, 2010 @10:13PM (#1211965)
First cure thermodynamics. Then we can talk about aging.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by sailormoon on Monday March 22, 2010 @10:33AM (#1210373)
While I think you are completely and utterly wrong, and that it is inevitable that aging will be cured or anyway worked around, that's not what I was trying to say. The GP claimed that curing aging would "break" the economy with indefinite pensions. My point was simply that if aging was actually "cured" then pensions would be unnecessary as everyone would be in perfect health, willing and able to support themselves, indeed with increasing productivity and hence value over time.

I don't really have the inclination to get into a detailed technical argument but I don't think these sweeping claims that aging is "not going to be cured. PERIOD. FULL STOP!" are credible in the least. The human body is a machine that can be repaired like any other, given the technology and understanding. It might not be in my lifetime, but I can't think of any reason why perfect anti-aging technology would not be available eventually. And if you're going to make broad claims to the contrary, you'll need to back them up.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by Daniel_Newby on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:54AM (#1209415)
"Next time you see an old person eating bacon and eggs in a restaurant, picture that person's bypass operation, years of statins, and excessive end of life care that you are paying for..."

Cardiovascular disease is mostly caused by carbohydrate consumption and inactivity. The Feds subsidize these, and health care "reform" will make the problem worse.

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @02:04AM (#1209574)
Not to nitpick, but I think it's mostly caused by refined carbohydrate consumption, high fructose corn syrup, smoking, and obesity.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by sailormoon on Monday March 22, 2010 @04:47AM (#1209798)
In other words, the exact opposite of what your parent post said. And fyi HFCS is refined carbohydrate.
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by vixen99 on Monday March 22, 2010 @07:22AM (#1210026)
Right and it's vital for people to know this. For anyone who wants to know more I recommend starting with http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2003/03/2... Mercola is not an original researcher but he does substantiate his views ('Soda should almost be illegal to give to children. I can't think of any reason or justification to continue such a disease-promoting practice') with links to the many peer-reviewed publications.warning against its use. This sorry story of HFCS, obesity and ill-health is gathering momentum. . http://www.ajcn.org/cgi/content/abstract/79/4/537
Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by grandalf on Monday March 22, 2010 @05:41PM (#1211475)
Well, it's not as if eating lots of fatty (high calorie density) food doesn't also result in obesity.

I think that implicit in your expression of dissent to what I initially wrote is belief in the fallacy of "good fats".

Re:House Passes Health Care Reform by nvasilak on Saturday March 27, 2010 @01:48AM (#1222631)
You should read some of Weston Price's research: http://www.westonaprice.org/Ancient-Dietary-Wisdom-for-Tomor...