News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What advice would you give college students about... by derefr on Sunday March 21, 2010 @11:58PM (#1209264)
I never said to give up—I just think there are ways to succeed at external tasks that don't involve changing the kind of person you are internally. Because otherwise, it's basically equivalent to saying "only extraverts can do this job"—that if you aren't one already, you need to turn yourself into one. And that sounds like a defeatist attitude to me—why can't I do that job and still be myself afterward?

But in generally programmer-y terms: I don't think it matters what you've got on running the inside, as long as you can manage to conform to the right protocols :)

Re:Ask HN: What advice would you give college students about... by jacquesm on Monday March 22, 2010 @12:08AM (#1209281)
Protocol is exactly the right term, but 'introverts' can have issues with protocol.

I figure that at heart I'm an introvert, I'm just very good at masking it :)

And over time it got better, I no longer have a problem approaching total strangers and starting a conversation, it became something of a sport. And that kind of ability is priceless in a sales situation, as long as it is genuine.

You can be yourself just fine, it's just that if you appear unapproachable or if you can't approach others that your chances of success as an independent take an instant nosedive. So you man up and overcome your limitations, you try to do your best and in time you'll look back at that 'introverted geek' that you used to be and you wonder what happened to him or her.

It doesn't mean you're going to 'turn yourself in to an extrovert', it simply means that in order to succeed you will have to behave more or less as predicted, protocol as you call it. And that such protocol has a lot in common with extrovert behaviour is unfortunate, but that doesn't mean that you are changing your base character.

I also think that there is way too much emphasis on being 'introvert or extrovert', I hardly ever come across people that fit the stereotypes well enough that the label alone is sufficient to predict their response in every situation.