News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by jsmeaton on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:33AM (#12085617)
No. Absolutely no. It can not ever be legal to own or distribute this kind of material. Imagine this kind of material exists of a child that you know. And it was legal for people to send this image to others, and to post it online unhindered. When the child gets older they can find this stuff of themselves and be revictimised over again.

Fuck that. You think not as much would be created if access was easier? I highly doubt that. I personally don't know anyone that keeps one or two regular porn links bookmarked - it's always onto the next thing.

> Sure, law makers and most sexually normal people are going to have a gut reaction of disgust to child pornography.

This quote here bothers me greatly. Sexually normal? EVeryone but pedophiles should be disgusted by this kind of child abuse.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by RHSeeger on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:36AM (#12085994)
My problem with our laws has more to do with the crimes that don't have victims. - Individual in high school takes provocative picture of themselves and sends it to their significant other... pedophile. - Person writes story involving underage sex... pedophile - Person draws picture involving underage sex... pedophile - Take a picture of sexual situations with someone that looks underage, but isn't... pedophile

These things (arguably?) don't have real victims, yet people have their lives ruined over them.

There's also the argument that being a pedophile is a mental condition. The fact that a person with such a condition can use fictional (stories, drawings, etc) material to mitigate their desire for actual damaging materials can be considered (once again, not with argument) a good thing; they are aware they have a problem and are looking to handle it in a way that does not cause harm to others.

Note: I'm a father of a young daughter, the very concept of young children being harmed by pedophilia sickens me. But the fact that a teenage boy can have their life ruined because their girlfriend (voluntarily) texted them a provocative picture is almost as horrible.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by jsmeaton on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:43AM (#12086048)
I agree with you but that's not the kind of material discussed in the article or by original commenter. Exploitation of children is evil. A 16 year old sending a dick/boob pic to their same age boyfriend/girlfriend and being arrested seems like unintended consequences.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by drunken-serval on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:07AM (#12086228)
However, it's currently being treated the same by some law enforcement entities.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by surge on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:25AM (#12086337)
Mostly by prosecutors looking to make a name for themselves by putting another sex crime conviction on their record and not giving a damn about the long-term consequences of the young life they ruined.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:39AM (#12085651)
I've suggested elsewhere that child porn should be legal to distribute in the limited case where the child has now reached the age of majority and consents to the distribution. That is, if the person being victimized is the child or their future self, once they are legally capable of waiving rights they should be allowed to retroactively do so, as they're effectively saying they don't consider it as victimizing them.

This also trivially means people can't get prosecuted for having pictures of themselves.

(I've also suggested more generally that all crimes against "victims" should be waivable by the so-called "victim", but some people have pointed out some issues with that.)

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:50AM (#12086096)
Wouldn't paedophiles then be able to pay victims to waive their rights, effectively turning them into child prostitutes?
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:53AM (#12086118)
Only if they continue to agree after they're 18. But in that case you have an adult deciding that it was worth the money, which makes it more akin to an adult porn star.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by DanBC on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:52AM (#12086582)
Or an adult victim of coercive control, that started when that person was a child.

You've just suggested that we give power to those who exert most psychological power over their child victims.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:02AM (#12086667)
Well we do allow adult porn stars. Doesn't your logic imply that we shouldn't, since maybe they were forced into it, and maybe they were even forced into it as a child?

What logic says someone can sell current pictures of themselves but not older pictures? Why worry about coercion in one and not the other?

If child porn is inherently bad, then it makes sense. That also explains why computer generated child porn was prohibited until the laws were mostly ruled unconstitutional. But if the only problem is the impact on the victim, then the victim should have control over whether they were really a victim.

(There are also consequentialist reasons mentioned in some of the rulings, though. For example, they say that child porn is used by predators to lure kids. Some of those reasons may have merit, and my "no victim" proposal may not work in reality all the time. But I feel it should at least be explicitly considered when deciding the law.)

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:07PM (#12090772)
> Doesn't your logic imply that we shouldn't, since maybe they were forced into it, and maybe they were even forced into it as a child?

No, obviously not. In the case of child porn, we know they were forced into it.

Currently in the case of an adult porn star who was forced into it as a child, that is illegal.

I understand what you are trying to get at, but the point of any age based legislation is based on the idea that children are less able to understand consequences than adults. The victims are explicitly not given control over whether they were 'really' a victim or not.

It is society as a whole that is determining that there is a crime - not the children or the adults they grew into.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:25PM (#12090866)
>In the case of child porn, we know they were forced into it.

We know that only if we consider a child's consent and an adult's retroactive consent as worthless, which is exactly what I'm arguing against.

>Currently in the case of an adult porn star who was forced into it as a child, that is illegal.

Is it illegal to distribute the pictures of them as an adult which they currently agree to?

>I understand what you are trying to get at, but the point of any age based legislation is based on the idea that children are less able to understand consequences than adults. The victims are explicitly not given control over whether they were 'really' a victim or not.

Which is why I proposed that we wait until they're an adult; now they can understand consequences, and so their consent should now work.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:18PM (#12091275)
> Is it illegal to distribute the pictures of them as an adult which they currently agree to?

No but that's irrelevant.

Their consent in the present doesn't get transmitted back in time to when they were a child so why is it relevant?

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:26PM (#12091292)
I started this line of analogy when a comment above said they could be an "adult victim of coercive control". If that's no longer the concern, then of course the analogy won't work.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by Fjolsvith on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @12:56PM (#12087706)
Since when was computer child porn ruled constitutional?
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:45PM (#12088116)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashcroft_v._Free_Speech_Coalit...

From the ruling, copied from https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/00-795.ZS.html:

>Held: The prohibitions of §§2256(8)(B) and 2256(8)(D) are overbroad and unconstitutional. Pp. 6—21.

> In contrast to the speech in Ferber, speech that is itself the record of sexual abuse, the CPPA prohibits speech that records no crime and creates no victims by its production. Virtual child pornography is not “intrinsically related” to the sexual abuse of children. While the Government asserts that the images can lead to actual instances of child abuse, the causal link is contingent and indirect. The harm does not necessarily follow from the speech, but depends upon some unquantified potential for subsequent criminal acts. The Government’s argument that these indirect harms are sufficient because, as Ferber acknowledged, child pornography rarely can be valuable speech, see id., at 762, suffers from two flaws. First, Ferber’s judgment about child pornography was based upon how it was made, not on what it communicated. The case reaffirmed that where the speech is neither obscene nor the product of sexual abuse, it does not fall outside the First Amendment’s protection.

Emphasis on the last sentence, with the triple negative.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:56AM (#12086136)
What are you talking about? How is a child participating in porn without their consent turned into anything like an adult porn star just because they were paid off when they were older?
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:07AM (#12086221)
Just like some people propose retroactive withdrawal of consent (e.g. https://archive.is/jV3gs), I propose retroactive granting of consent.

If the so-called "victim" does not consider themself victimized, then it's a victimless crime and should not be prosecuted or made illegal.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:11PM (#12090793)
Do you actually agree with that retroactive withdrawing?

In any case, retroactive granting is generally legal already, except in the case of children. And that's because it's a social more that is being enforced.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:23PM (#12090850)
>Do you actually agree with that retroactive withdrawing?

No, but introducing an extreme idea makes my idea sound moderate in comparison.

>And that's because it's a social more that is being enforced.

I did hint at this in my comment.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:22PM (#12091285)
Your idea is no less extreme than the one you referenced. Referencing it just makes you look like you're trying an underhanded debating tactic.

So is your point that we shouldn't enforce social more's? If so, why not just say that more directly. I don't think anyone is pretending this isn't one, so why do you need to resort to such indirection to object to that?

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:34PM (#12091323)
>Your idea is no less extreme than the one you referenced.

I mean they're on opposite directions, so it's not so simple to compare directly, as you'd be comparing distances that aren't between the same groups. You can look at distance from the Overton Window but that introduces its own vagueness.

>So is your point that we shouldn't enforce social more's? If so, why not just say that more directly.

Not quite. I suggest you look through my comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12086667 again:

>If child porn is inherently bad, then it makes sense.

>But if the only problem is the impact on the victim, then the victim should have control over whether they were really a victim.

I am a consequentialist, and I think you should only consider something bad if it has bad consequences. I recognize others disagree, but I did say that directly above.

>I don't think anyone is pretending this isn't one

Not quite in those words, but as I noted plenty of justifications for the laws are couched in consequentialist terms. I'd give them the benefit of the doubt that they actually mean that as the reason.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Thursday July 14, 2016 @01:33AM (#12091855)
How do you determine what 'bad consequences are'? Isn't some of that determined by more's?
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by halomru on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:23AM (#12085910)
>And it was legal for people to send this image to others, and to post it online unhindered

Even if child pornography were legal, that doesn't remove all laws about personality rights. You can't make and freely distribute any pictures of me without my consent (or the guardians consent in the case of minors).

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by mabcat on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:09AM (#12086736)
I think you will find, depending on where you live, that personality rights are often much narrower than that. In general the rights stem from protections against passing off or unauthorised use in an advertising context. In Australia and in most US states personality rights wouldn't have much to say about pornography, far as I know.