News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:07PM (#12090772)
> Doesn't your logic imply that we shouldn't, since maybe they were forced into it, and maybe they were even forced into it as a child?

No, obviously not. In the case of child porn, we know they were forced into it.

Currently in the case of an adult porn star who was forced into it as a child, that is illegal.

I understand what you are trying to get at, but the point of any age based legislation is based on the idea that children are less able to understand consequences than adults. The victims are explicitly not given control over whether they were 'really' a victim or not.

It is society as a whole that is determining that there is a crime - not the children or the adults they grew into.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @08:25PM (#12090866)
>In the case of child porn, we know they were forced into it.

We know that only if we consider a child's consent and an adult's retroactive consent as worthless, which is exactly what I'm arguing against.

>Currently in the case of an adult porn star who was forced into it as a child, that is illegal.

Is it illegal to distribute the pictures of them as an adult which they currently agree to?

>I understand what you are trying to get at, but the point of any age based legislation is based on the idea that children are less able to understand consequences than adults. The victims are explicitly not given control over whether they were 'really' a victim or not.

Which is why I proposed that we wait until they're an adult; now they can understand consequences, and so their consent should now work.

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by zepto on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:18PM (#12091275)
> Is it illegal to distribute the pictures of them as an adult which they currently agree to?

No but that's irrelevant.

Their consent in the present doesn't get transmitted back in time to when they were a child so why is it relevant?

Re:The takeover: how police ended up running a paedophile site by ikeboy on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:26PM (#12091292)
I started this line of analogy when a comment above said they could be an "adult victim of coercive control". If that's no longer the concern, then of course the analogy won't work.