Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by ucaetano on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @09:32AM
(#12085966)
Or you can think the other way around: it is THE space station because countries around the world collaborated to create one large one, instead of each one trying to launch a single small one.
There is a lot of synergy from having a single large space station vs. many of small ones.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @01:24PM
(#12087953)
The entire point of the ISS was to consolidate all the efforts and budgets of various space programs and build one trans-national station. Why would you participate in this and then also build a second one? What benefit would you get? This is like saying its depressing that there's only one internet.
Arguably, without the ISS there probably wouldn't be any space stations. Stations were falling out of fashion by the 90s and even before were largely propagandist projects. The ISS was an attempt to turn all this wasted effort into something world usable (not just for the space faring powers of the time) and into something more science-centric. It was also an attempt to stop Russian militarization of space like mounting guns on stations (Salyut 3's 23mm cannon) or building more space battle platforms (Polyus). In fact, parts of the old Polyus system are now part of the Zarya module on the ISS. Seems like win-win for international cooperation, science, and peace.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by knz on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:08AM
(#12086713)
I agree but there is the small issue of cost. I've read before that the ISS was the most expensive project in global history at > $150B. I used google to confirm the cost and was stuck by 1) the fact that "Is the International Space Station real" was in the autocomplete options, and 2) How bloody expensive the War on Terror was/is ($1.7 Trillion according to Google).
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @11:45AM
(#12087093)
The ISS's cost was substantially due to the cost of the Shuttle program. Building an equivalent space station today using the rockets and systems we have available now would likely be considerably cheaper, by a factor of 10 or more.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @03:31PM
(#12088976)
It should almost go without saying. The Shuttle was one of the most expensive launch vehicles in history.
There are several helpful counterpoints to hand though. Two being the history Russian and Chinese space stations. All of them, including the Russian components of the ISS, have been vastly less expensive per module than the US components of ISS. Even if you factor in building and launching modules by US standards on US rockets it's still vastly less expensive than using the Shuttle.
Moreover, we've already seen that it's possible for US companies to deliver spacecraft to the ISS in the commercial cargo program. It would actually be just as easy to deliver components to the station using similar systems for about the same cost as a cargo launch today (around $150 mil at the high end). Over the roughly 2 dozen assembly flights for the Shuttle assembled side of the ISS that works out to an equivalent cost of about $4 billion, plus extra module construction costs. Keeping in mind that such flights have already been used or are being planned to use for adding modules to the ISS (such as BEAM and IDA).
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:42PM
(#12089523)
Note that the incremental cost of a shuttle mission was $450 million, but that ignores the high fixed costs. Excluding sunk development costs the average price of a shuttle mission throughout the life of the program was a whopping $1.2 billion.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by jessriedel on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @05:05PM
(#12089659)
OK, so that's a factor of 2.7, but not even halfway to a factor of 10.
Sorry to be a stickler on this, but I like to use the ISS as an example of outrageously inefficient science, and so I'd like to make sure this isn't completely attributable to the cost of the shuttle (which, I think we agree, was it's own terrible boondoggle).
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by Sir_Cmpwn on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @10:09AM
(#12086241)
>The first-generation models will weigh 5 grams but the team wants to get them down to just one, which would allow them to track even the lightest fliers like swifts. Each tag comes equipped with a solar panel, GPS, and a huge memory, and can measure acceleration, temperature, bearing, pressure, light intensity, and more. Unlike the smallest current data-loggers, they can transmit information, too. They can even be reprogrammed from space.
I thought this was a pretty decent amount of info for a non-tech news source.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by fillskills on Thursday July 14, 2016 @05:22PM
(#12097266)
Good point. Just looking to see if there is more details on how the sensors were made so small and still able to transmit their location. It just blows my mind.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by sandworm101 on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @03:43AM
(#12084542)
Interesting, but why involve the ISS? Putting a receiver/relay into orbit seems the perfect job for a small cube sat, or just a regular com sat. Why all the hassle and delay of human spaceflight? And, being on the ISS, the receiver will be stuck in the ISS orbit. that means not tracking anything at higher latitudes higher than the ISS inclination (ie the far north/south above/below 52*).
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by InclinedPlane on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @04:06AM
(#12084645)
Because there are already regular delivery trips to the ISS, and the cost of such experiments is thus substantially subsidized by ISS operations. A cube sat would have a very limited lifespan and cost more than their program budget on its own, besides being too limited to be useful.
If their program proves successful they might be able to raise enough money to put hosted payloads on other spacecraft, one of the best being Iridium NEXT. But for now the ISS is their best shot.
Re:The Space Station Is Becoming a Spy Satellite for Wildlife
by russellalbert on Wednesday July 13, 2016 @07:28AM
(#12085338)
Would be so much better if there were more than one ISS around the globe and use it for this kind of role to stop putting lots of little satellites up.
The SciFi fan in me thinks we should shove a couple more up there to keep it company.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiangong-1 [2] http://www.n2yo.com/?s=37820
There is a lot of synergy from having a single large space station vs. many of small ones.
Arguably, without the ISS there probably wouldn't be any space stations. Stations were falling out of fashion by the 90s and even before were largely propagandist projects. The ISS was an attempt to turn all this wasted effort into something world usable (not just for the space faring powers of the time) and into something more science-centric. It was also an attempt to stop Russian militarization of space like mounting guns on stations (Salyut 3's 23mm cannon) or building more space battle platforms (Polyus). In fact, parts of the old Polyus system are now part of the Zarya module on the ISS. Seems like win-win for international cooperation, science, and peace.
There are several helpful counterpoints to hand though. Two being the history Russian and Chinese space stations. All of them, including the Russian components of the ISS, have been vastly less expensive per module than the US components of ISS. Even if you factor in building and launching modules by US standards on US rockets it's still vastly less expensive than using the Shuttle.
Moreover, we've already seen that it's possible for US companies to deliver spacecraft to the ISS in the commercial cargo program. It would actually be just as easy to deliver components to the station using similar systems for about the same cost as a cargo launch today (around $150 mil at the high end). Over the roughly 2 dozen assembly flights for the Shuttle assembled side of the ISS that works out to an equivalent cost of about $4 billion, plus extra module construction costs. Keeping in mind that such flights have already been used or are being planned to use for adding modules to the ISS (such as BEAM and IDA).
Soyuz costs $62.7m/seat. [1] Which means that 8 seats to the ISS on soyuz is actually more expensive than a shuttle launch.
I couldn't find how much non-astronaut Soyuz payloads cost.
SpaceX's Falcon 9 Full Thrust can lift almost as much payload as the Shuttle, at 22,800kg.
I'm not sure how much each Falcon 9 launch to the ISS costs. Maybe someone else can chime in?
0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle_program
1. http://www.space.com/20897-nasa-russia-astronaut-launches-20...
Sorry to be a stickler on this, but I like to use the ISS as an example of outrageously inefficient science, and so I'd like to make sure this isn't completely attributable to the cost of the shuttle (which, I think we agree, was it's own terrible boondoggle).
[1] http://www.parabolicarc.com/2016/07/11/upmass/
http://icarusinitiative.org/sites/default/files/ICARUS%20SP%...
That one doesn't seem to be loading for me, but the Internet Archive has a version:
https://web.archive.org/web/20160331224522/http://icarusinit...
I thought this was a pretty decent amount of info for a non-tech news source.
If their program proves successful they might be able to raise enough money to put hosted payloads on other spacecraft, one of the best being Iridium NEXT. But for now the ISS is their best shot.