In my own case, I guess having experience with PHP, Perl, Python and Ruby is the ultimate fail, because they all solve the same problems and are very similar to boot. Interesting way to look at it! What percentage of HN's audience did you just fail?
It all depends on what you want, of course, as I'm more of a jack of all trades, master of none kind of guy.
Of course, what the OP probably means is that these sort of random strings of technologies look, at times, a bit dubious.
Yes. If you were looking for a webdev position, you probably will not list your Perl and Rails experience with same prominance as your Tcl and C experience.
Point taken though.
Listing all of them together without further info doesnot give a good impression (to me at least). This is persional experience, so YMVV of course.
My point being that if you list all of them you probaly do not know any of these at the level I want/require.