News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by Grue3 on Sunday July 10, 2016 @12:45PM (#12066171)
This will end as well as the "nanomachines" project did. By which I mean, nothing will happen, but a few people will get a bit richer.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by daveguy on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:27PM (#12066315)
That's quite an assertion. I think it is a leap to compare tech on a scale that has never been made with a novel rail design. Maybe it is commentary specifically on the funding of projects in Russia, but the hyperloop design seems quite a bit closer to reality than nebulous "nanomachines". Nanomachines are still very much an open ended research subject whereas the hyperloop seems more of an engineering project.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by forgotpwtomain on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:37PM (#12066353)
> Maybe it is commentary specifically on the funding of projects in Russia

Definitely this, it's far more likely to be a project to spread the national budget among Putin's cronies than to actually result in anything.

Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by ptaipale on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:47PM (#12066399)
Sounds like a commentary on funding and execution of projects in Russia. Compare to http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-03-18/putin-says...
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by sakopov on Sunday July 10, 2016 @03:19PM (#12066828)
Precisely. Reminds me of Skolkovo which ended up being a huge money laundering scheme instead of a high technology innovation center.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by BinaryIdiot on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:37PM (#12066351)
That assertion doesn't really make sense. Nanomachines are still theoretically possible but we don't have the technology to really make them shine yet. But hyperloop? Nothing new really needs to be discovered. It's simply an engineering task at this point.

So why do you think it would end like nanomachines? Simply Russian politics?

Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by lisivka on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:47PM (#12066398)
The only way to complete it in Russia is to buy it. But it is impossible to buy it because nobody completed it. So it will fail. If you want to understand why every big government projects fails in Russia, just look at salaries of workers in government sector.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by BinaryIdiot on Sunday July 10, 2016 @01:53PM (#12066427)
Fair enough. I don't know much about Russian politics.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by bubuga on Monday July 11, 2016 @11:21AM (#12071647)
> But hyperloop? Nothing new really needs to be discovered.

This isn't true.

The concept of a moving load travelling over the rayleigh wave speed on heterogeneous soils is something that's very new, very problematic, and very expensive to deal with.

Let's put it this way: the french currently hold the conventional high-speed railway speed record for just bellow 600km/h, and yet they are only able to operate their TGV trains on the record-breaking track at 320km/h. They can't push it any faster due to all the maintenance problems caused by very high speed travel, although SNCF is one of the leading rail companies and the track is brand new.

If there were no technical issues to be resolved, they wouldn't be capping their circulation speeds at around half their speed record.

This is one of the many technical issues. But then there are the multitude of economic problems which hyperloop is entirely unable to offer any solution, yet alone make a case.

Strapping a rocket on a short stretch of track is not a technical solution. It's just a marketing trick.

Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by BinaryIdiot on Monday July 11, 2016 @04:42PM (#12074380)
Oh I certainly didn't mean for my comment to come off as they have nothing new to do only that all of those issues, as far as I can tell, are engineering issues where yes they'll have to come up with new stuff but that what they want to accomplish is perfectly within the realm of discovered physics, etc.

So I just wanted to say it's an engineering issue at this point. But as far as I can tell that's still true maybe I just didn't convey that very well initially though I'm certainly not an expert at this so I concede I could certainly be wrong as well.

Perhaps my comment doesn't add as much to the conversation as I thought it would. Oh well.

Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by bubuga on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @04:33AM (#12077563)
> So I just wanted to say it's an engineering issue at this point.

It's far more than a mere engineering issue. It's primarily an economic issue. The engineering issues are mitigated by throwing cash at them, but in the end for an infrastructure project to make sense the payoff must be greater than the investment.

Meanwhile, air travel is already cheaper than conventional high-speed rail, is far more flexible to manage, and operates on a cruise speed that is at least equivalent to the best case scenario sold by hyperloop's salespeople.

Any airline is able to transport hundreds of people at a cruise speed between 800 and 900km/h with an investment of around 200 million dollars. Hyperloop's salespeople are selling a concept whose cost is some orders of magnitude higher, takes longer to build, and competes with ticket prices that are somewhere between 100 and 200 dollars a ticket. While an airline needs to rely on those 100 dollar tickets to pay off their 200 million dollar investment, how do hyperloop's salesteam expect an operator to amortize a trillion-dollar investment by competing in a market based on those ticket prices?

Furthermore, essentially airlines only need to maintain their planes and pay airport costs. An hyperloop operator needs to maintain, in addition to the vehicle, hundeds of kilometer of experimental track sections. Where's the business case?

There's a good reason why hyperloop's salesteam only invest in marketing and propaganda, and in spite of being backed by a savvy scifi-inclined billionaire with a long history of investing in amazing projects we don't see him opening his wallet to fund a real-world project. Instead, the project is focused on convincing others to foot the bill.

Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by BinaryIdiot on Tuesday July 12, 2016 @10:18AM (#12079152)
Fair enough. I'll stop talking :)
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by jkot on Sunday July 10, 2016 @02:05PM (#12066480)
Hyperloop is not that simple. There was article recently that even normal super train is not economically viable between LA and SF. Hyperloop will be much more expensive to build and maintain, while handling less passengers..
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by ZenoArrow on Sunday July 10, 2016 @02:16PM (#12066532)
Do you have any clues on where to look for this article? I'd like to see what assumptions it was working on.
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by jkot on Sunday July 10, 2016 @02:25PM (#12066570)
Re:Russia Jumps into the Race to Build a Hyperloop by aab0 on Sunday July 10, 2016 @02:33PM (#12066606)
Running a Winter Olympics is also 'simply an engineering task at this point'.