As near as I can tell these allegations are primarily referring to a pull request by Michael Snoyman [1] that completely removed four existing sections from the haskell.org download page and replaced them with a link to a tool only a few months old written mostly by Michael and others at FP Complete. I think any reasonable person would agree that a pull request like this to a language's official website is completely ridiculous and should definitely not be accepted. In fact, Gershom & co have proven very reasonable because they did eventually add stack to the downloads page [2] after it had more time to mature and became more widely used.
Furthermore, Chris Done (an employee of FP Complete who is also associated with this new website) made the underhanded move of revoking his permission [3] for haskell.org to use the web design that he contributed under a BSD license [4].
These are just two examples of a pattern of what I think is pretty lousy behavior on the part of key players in FP Complete that should be taken into account when listening to their rhetoric.
Regarding their point about /r/haskell being full of flamewars, from what I've seen the only flamewars there are ones involving the above mentioned people from FP Complete and they are usually the ones doing the flaming.
[1] https://github.com/haskell-infra/hl/pull/130/files
[2] https://www.haskell.org/downloads
[3] https://mail.haskell.org/pipermail/haskell-community/2016-Ap...
https://www.reddit.com/r/haskell/comments/3lax6y/discussion_...
But this whole thing is just so silly. The real value in Haskell, to me, seems to be for learning functional programming, since it forces you to use that paradigm. Beyond that, it's just a hobby language. There's nothing wrong with that, but it's not worthy of this East Coast/West Coast hip hop-esque schism.
Like seriously, the only recent disagreement that led to a major project splitting in half that I can think of is what happened with HTML5. Something as critical to the computing world as HTML is a lot more worth fighting about than Haskell. I feel like new versions of the C++ standard, even when there are big changes, don't have people as up in arms as they are over this.
It's not a bad thing, but I think like you said in the beginning of your post, you aren't qualified to speak on this. Haskell is a very powerful and capable language, and you've basically called it a toy.
It's good you've played around with the language, but to say you've built nothing substantial in Haskell and go on to say it's just a hobby language is like me saying I played around with Python and decided its only value is learning the imperative paradigm.
I categorically disagree. Your comment states that Haskell is both good for learning functional programming and bad because Haskell forces you to use the functional programming paradigm (aside: it doesn't).
There is also a distinct lack of compassion for those that use Haskell in their jobs or have in the past.
> so maybe I'm not qualified to speak on this.
Then how do you so quickly move to "Haskell is just a hobby language"?
I'm not a Haskell greybeard, just a light user, but despite the improvements via FPComplete's output, at least some of it feels NIH and unnecessarily polarizes the community. For instance, reusing Shake in Cabal(-install) and getting nix-local-build and Backpack production ready look like improvements that will be beneficial for a longer time, rather than splitting the community with a different build/package structure (stack).
I mean, dividing the already small Haskell community doesn't make sense to me. If Gershom doesn't play fair with the management of www.haskell.org, this should be raised officially and fixed, because haskell.org is not a one man project and there's a team around it.