Re:Why Favicons Rule the Internet
by iaskwhy on Friday March 19, 2010 @12:34PM
(#1204497)
I've said this before and I'll keep saying it: every site needs a favicon! It's a shame something so simple to create isn't everywhere yet. One example - http://www.pulseapp.com/ - which is the only site on my bookmarks bar without a favicon.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I don't have anything to say about Pulse favicon but the app itself tries to solve the same problem (and then some) like my Excel file here:
http://dl.dropbox.com/u/111770/CashFlow.xls
I use the above template to plan my personal finances and it works in a similar way to Pulse but at a very basic level. The funniest thing is just last night my wife said I could make a web-app out of the Excel and people would use it. Seems like Pulse did just that and a lot more.
I've more or less stopped paying attention to favicons ever since I started using chrome because they don't show up on the URL bar anymore. They're still there on bookmarks, true, but I basically don't use bookmarks anymore either. And most of my bookmarks bar is full of js bookmarklets (like Readability) that don't have favicons anyway.
They're on your tabs if you use a recent version of Chrome, which I find useful.
Wow. You're right. Not quite sure how I managed to miss that.
Favicons are not simple to create. You have to create a tiny icon that fits to your site. I always have lots of trouble with it.
That linked site though could simply use the green bars.
Re:Why Favicons Rule the Internet
by shadowsun7 on Friday March 19, 2010 @12:56PM
(#1204549)
Agreed. To be honest, creating a logo itself is hard enough. Not to mention designing one that can scale down to a 16x16px image.
Well, I make logos myself and I only consider it done when I have a good logo at different sizes. I'd say a logo is only a good logo if it's scales to the size of a favicon or to something really big so you can use if on outdoors. It might sounds like too much trouble just to make a logo but it's better to think about it before than changing it afterwards.
Cut it out, you're disturbing the programmers who think they're designers. Why would anyone use a vector layout?
You can charge more from clients who are already feeling the pain, so let them have a go at it first :-)