News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by elchief on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @02:55AM (#12041591)
BMI is so bad.

I'm 6'0 and the last time I was under BMI 25 I was a triathlete. The only way I could be <25 would be to exercise 3 hours a day and eat 1200 calories. F-off and die

I did quit smoking though:

- Really wanted to - Picked a good mental argument against it ($100k CAD over 20 years) - Picked a quit date - Patch + zyban + nicotene lozenges

If you live in British Columbia, the government will pay for your patches or lozenges (hint: ask a friend)

Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by maccard on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @05:03AM (#12041979)
I'm 6'1 and I had a BMI of about 26 until recently - I was definitely pudgy. I also claimed that BMI was worthless until I dropped a few pounds and realised that it was right and I was just making excuses.

If you're an athlete, or a bodybuilder, or particularly tall or small, it won't necessarily fit you. but if you're of normal-ish stature (ie 5'4 to 6'3), and don't keep track of your weight, it's probably bang on.

Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by sgt101 on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @06:39AM (#12042232)
I've had a BMI of 27 for most of my adult life. I used to do competitive sport and trained for sessions a week 45 weeks a year, I got to 40 and couldn't cut it anymore so I quit. My bmi stayed at 28... I looked at a photo of me at age 28 about eight months ago and compared myself to that. The photo showed muscle bulk and tone, the mirror showed a big belly. I've adopted what I call the beer, bread and biscuits diet (as in NO) and avoid alcohol four days a week altogether. I've lost six kg, six more to go!
Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by throwaway7767 on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @08:19AM (#12042559)
I'm about 6'2 and very lanky. My problem has always been that I don't eat enough, and my doctors have told me all my life I need to consciously try to eat more (which I try to do) to gain weight. I don't really do any planned exercise but I don't have a car so I get some daily workout from walking/cycling. In short, I'm no fitness nut or bodybuilder.

Every time I've taken BMI, the result is that I'm "slightly overweight". That's bullshit. If I actually tried to eat less, I'd probably end up having health complications related to malnutrition.

So BMI is very much bullshit when applied to individuals. It might have some relevance for the average case, and therefore be useful for demographic comparisons of large groups.

Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by samolang on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @05:52AM (#12042108)
> The only way I could be <25 would be to exercise 3 hours a day and eat 1200 calories.

You could weigh 184 pounds and have a BMI <25. Even with a sedentary lifestyle you'd still burn 2,199 calories a day. This is patently false.

Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by Benji_San on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @03:14AM (#12041656)
BMI isn't really reliable on a individual level as it doesn't take body composition into account. Athletes are generally "overweight" according to the BMI cutoff.
Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by nradov on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @08:54AM (#12042709)
That's generally untrue. Winning endurance athletes are almost all in the normal BMI range. You'll only see "overweight" (by BMI) athletes in certain sports such as weightlifting and (American) football which require huge bursts of muscle power for only a few seconds at a time. Those are also the athletes who unfortunately tend to gain a lot of fat and have many health problems once they retire from competitive sports.
Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by Madmallard on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @03:22AM (#12041683)
Are you all muscle? If you were fat I'd suggest high fat low carb diet.
Re:Helpless to Prevent Cancer? Actually, Quite a Bit Is in Y... by elchief on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @03:54AM (#12041768)
I think my celtic skeleton weighs 80 lbs