News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by StavrosK on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @05:56PM (#12039815)
I work for silent circle, as a backend developer. I speak for myself, and not the company.

As far as I know (and, sure, I may not know, although if someone wanted something from the server I'm one of a few guys that could get it), we haven't received any letters. What makes me even more confident, though, is the fact that there really isn't much data to give. All we have is some ciphertexts for attachments, and messages aren't retained, even encrypted (why would they)?

We don't even log IPs or other personal information, so I'm not sure what usefulness an NSL would serve.

Anyway, this is not an official company stance, I just wanted to comment about my personal experience because I see some speculation here.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by noonespecial on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @09:40PM (#12040709)
>We don't even log IPs or other personal information, so I'm not sure what usefulness an NSL would serve.

Perhaps you were just ordered to start... and plugging in that little black box from the G-Men somehow, umm, killed the canary process. Somehow.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by StavrosK on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @06:18AM (#12042174)
Perhaps, but, if that were the case, I think our security officer (who is a great guy and great at his work) would have quit immediately on moral grounds.

It's more likely (and I'm just grossly speculating now) that the business weighed the relatively small chance of us being ordered to give the virtually zero amount of data we have on everyone with the chance that something will go wrong updating the canary and there will be a bunch of bad publicity again.

Keep in mind that, while one may think "you're just uploading a text file, how hard can it be", it's much more resource-intensive than that. You need multiple redundant people to make sure the world doesn't freak out because your CSO was on vacation, you need them to coordinate about updating, you need them to (crucially) know how to store the PGP keys securely, you need to keep that number low to make sure the key isn't stolen from one of them, you need good tooling to minimize the chance that there's a mistake while uploading, you need to keep the machines that host it running even after a move, the DNS entries up, monitoring to tell you if the canary is stale, etc.

It's a lot of things to get right and a lot of things that can go wrong, and the failure case for that is "your stock goes down", which is a heavy price. I think the mistake here was that there wasn't a bigger, more explicit and pre-emptive announcement (something like "we'll take the canary down in X weeks because Y"), which I think would have more successfully assuaged fears.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by Osiris on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @07:21PM (#12040216)
Couldn't an NSL force the company to start retaining that information though? You may not have past data but you can certainly collect future information.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by hendersoon on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @08:30PM (#12040484)
Yes, they can try to compel you to do literally anything. Remember they tried to get Lavabit's SSL certs. Either you comply or fight it in secret court.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by StavrosK on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @05:49AM (#12042096)
I honestly don't know, I'm not a lawyer and I'm not familiar with what the secret courts (the concept of which I openly have much disdain for) can make you do. Keep in mind that SC is a Swiss company, so I don't know how much the US can compel.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by llamataboot on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @06:06PM (#12039856)
hmmm, but surely if you are going to go to the trouble of keeping up a warrant canary, you're not going to accidentally take it down?
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by StavrosK on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @06:07PM (#12039867)
Are you talking about this instance, or the previous one where it failed to be updated?
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by hippich on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @06:59PM (#12040128)
canary could also mean that starting now company begun gathering information for giving it away to NSA :)
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by mikestew on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @07:44PM (#12040300)
I speak for myself, and not the company.

As soon as you said "I work for that company", you speak for them, whether you like it or not and no amount of disclaiming changes that in the mind of the reader. Additionally, you went on to explain things that only someone that works there would know, so you are explicitly speaking for the company. I'd normally recommend that an employee delete such a post, perhaps explaining the error. Given that it involves an NSL, I recommend this action more strongly than I might normally. Ask yourself, "what do I and the company have to gain from such a post, other than getting to sound like an 'insider' on HN?", and then ask "what's my worst possible outcome of posting such a thing?" Weigh the two, choose a winner.

As a warning to others, one should always ask themselves if they are posting outside their wheelhouse for an ego boost, or if it truly helpful information to others and to the company. Useful advice in the general case, IMO, but especially if you're posting in reply to "my company's in the news". I generally just shut the hell up and let the PR people handle it. Especially when you're an IC or middle-manager, 'cuz odds are that you don't have the full story.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by tptacek on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @08:20PM (#12040443)
I'm not sure what the point of this comment is, but want to chime in to say I'm always happy when people directly connected to stories on HN take the time to shed what light they can on them. I'm kind of repelled by the instinct we have to tear those people down.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by mikestew on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @09:05PM (#12040599)
I'm kind of repelled by the instinct we have to tear those people down.

Sorry you took it that way. Myself, I'd hate to see our desire for gossip overrule wishing to avoid folks having a difficult conversation with their manager. Maybe not in this case, but if enough people from various companies start posting out of turn on public forums when they as individuals don't know the whole story, someone's going to wake up to a bad day. It's one thing to comment on "MSFT Announces new, cool widget thingy": "I worked on that, and what a long road we've travelled!" Quite another when the headline is "Google writes down $4 billion on stupid acquisition", and "I work Google, but I only speak for myself, and I think..." Any whiff of controversy and I'd say just stay out of it.

But it's just advice, do what you like with it, including ignore it.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by pjlegato on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @10:17PM (#12040835)
Gossip is, by definition, unreliable secondhand (or greater) rumors. If he actually works there, it's firsthand and therefore not gossip.

Perhaps more people should have difficult conversations with their managers. Or perhaps his management supports, or at least actively doesn't care about, these sorts of posts? We have no idea.

Surely as an adult, he can decide that for himself, without being subject to sermonizy advice meant to take care of his own interests for him because he's deemed incapable of doing it himself.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by 3pt14159 on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @08:06PM (#12040390)
Eh, I'm not so sure he's endangering anything. He's only staking his personal reputation, that's what "I only speak for myself" means. If it comes out that the company does what he says he doesn't see them do, then hes only burning himself; not the company. Worst case scenario he gets fired and someone else will hire him. It isn't like he works for the NSA. Good software developers are hard to find and bleeding information serves a purpose.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by hendersoon on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @08:28PM (#12040477)
That's true. The only way that he or his company could truly be hurt is if Silent Circle did get a NSL and he admitted to it publicly.

If they got a NSL and he lied about it, no harm will come to him. Or if he's telling the truth, obviously.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by lazaroclapp on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @12:43AM (#12041259)
> The only way that he or his company could truly be hurt is if Silent Circle did get a NSL and he admitted to it publicly.

At which point we are talking civil disobedience, so worrying about whether that will land them in trouble with management is missing the point by a mile and a half.

Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by JshWright on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @06:13AM (#12042161)
He's not a US citizen, and does not reside in the United States, so the legal risks to him personally are comparatively small.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by eldondev on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @10:31PM (#12040876)
Actually, a lot of times I think IC's have the fullest story. If you are a backend dev at a smallish company, you probably know how the stuff works. Also, warning people against "waking up to a bad day" is spoken as someone who really values their place as a cog in a machine. If your co-workers are not being frank with you, in my opinion that company is probably not a really healthy environment, and best to move to greener pastures. I think HN is about frank talk, and let the PR people send canned releases to ars.
Re:Silent Circle removes warrant canary by jjcm on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @11:45PM (#12041074)
I've been bit for talking about a company I've worked for in the past, simply because someone took my personal opinions as company dogma. That said, I still continue to do it. I feel it really adds value and a human element to a conversation. People all to often forget that a company is a collection of individuals. Getting insight from one of those individuals, especially one who isn't PR or management is really refreshing.

Yea, there's a chance it will backfire. But I think that if everyone speaks openly it's much better for the community. I think one of the things you're also overlooking is the teacher effect - talking about something and teaching it provides a better insight and understanding of it to yourself. I've had great insights into things I've been working on because I discussed things surrounding them on reddit or HN. Community feedback is always valuable.