News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by lisper on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:04PM (#12033843)
The author of this article is profoundly ignorant. There is a scientific method. Exactly how and why it works are both very well understood. The correct answer was worked out by Karl Popper and popularized by David Deutsch. Writing about the scientific method without mentioning Popper is like writing about physics without mentioning Einstein.

> James Blachowicz is a professor emeritus of philosophy

Why am I not surprised.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by Retra on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @12:55AM (#12034474)
Einstein didn't do all of the physics, and Popper did not solve all of the problems of establishing a clear scientific method.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by alayne on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:39PM (#12034271)
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jonsterling on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:59PM (#12033994)
Oh yes, rando on Hacker News is far more educated about philosophy of science than an actual philosopher!

Surely he knows about Popper (duh!).

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by dang on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @01:34AM (#12041381)
It's good to push back against glib dismissals, but please don't do it with snarky attacks. That's considerably worse, and degrades the thread for everybody.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jonsterling on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @02:01AM (#12041450)
I really wonder how "snarky attack that pushes back against glib dismissal" is somehow worse than "snarky attack which glibly dismisses the work of a professional philosopher". Do you have any clarification of your opinion?
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by dang on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @10:00PM (#12047078)
It's worse because personal attack (such as name-calling) toward a fellow community member is more destructive of the community. Both are bad, though.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jonsterling on Thursday July 07, 2016 @12:05AM (#12047430)
I suppose with respect to this particular community, I am most likely to take a position similar to that of Ra's al Ghul toward Gotham in Batman Begins...

By the way, do you mean that it is better for a HN member to attack an outsider (who has not consented to be subjected to the usual HN nonsense), than it is for a HN member to attack another?

Anyway, thanks for the clarification---personally, I believe the dogmatic “We are hackers, therefore we can easily grasp any topic in 20 minutes which it has taken an expert a lifetime to learn!” nonsense which is so prevalent here (as I am sure you have observed) is worse, and deserves to be smacked down.

I'll end my participation in this convo here, though, since I don't think there's anything to be gained for anyone in continuing it.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by dang on Friday July 08, 2016 @01:45AM (#12053739)
> "I'll end my participation in this convo here, though"

Perhaps I'm oversensitive, but when people do this it usually strikes me as a presumptuous attempt to seize the last word in an argument. There's no need to announce that one's participation is ending; one can simply end it. I don't want to end mine, because your comments raise points that have been on my mind lately about this community.

> "the usual HN nonsense"

> "nonsense which is so prevalent here"

These fall under the trope of 'dissing the community while being part of it'. There's something unbecoming about that. It feels like a status move, a way of putting oneself above others. If you're commenting here, you're as much part of the community as anyone else is.

People post such supercilious putdowns of the community all the time and have done for years, but it has slowly dawned on me that it's a kind of vandalism—like smashing windows in a neighborhood—that subliminally communicates that no one much cares about this place. (Yes I buy the Broken Windows Theory.) Somebody needs to stand up for the opposite position: that this is a community worth making better, not a swimming pool to pee in. I guess that makes it my job to do.

I'm sure you wouldn't smash windows, pee in a pool, or throw litter out the car window, so please don't do their online forum equivalents here. (When I say 'you', I don't just mean you personally, I mean all of us in your position, which is almost everyone here, including me.)

> deserves to be smacked down

No one could agree with you more strongly than I about the badness of being shallowly dismissive of others' work, and how important it is to have a culture of resisting that. But the sad fact is, there are worse layers than that in the layer cake of incivility—and if you go around smacking others down, you're doing one of them. That's incongruent with your case that people should be more considerate of others, much as it would be to point out how someone's manners need improving by socking them.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jonsterling on Friday July 08, 2016 @12:43PM (#12056839)
> Perhaps I'm oversensitive, but when people do this it usually strikes me as a presumptuous attempt to seize the last word in an argument.

Apologies---my intention was to signal that I wasn't interested in escalating the conversation or causing unpleasantness. I am completely happy to leave the last word to you.

Re "vandalism" and "being part of the community", thanks for your thoughts. I don't see myself at all as part of this community, but I do occasionally comment in it and on it. How is that possible? HN is a community of hackers and startup doers, and I once really was part of that (when I had the misfortune of being employed by a YC company); but a community is defined not just by collocation but by shared values & shared norms. Completely understandable if you'd rather I just buzzed off!

I understand the remainder of your comments, but I don't agree with them at all; to me, it is quite similar to the old bourgeois-liberal argument against antifa action, "you're just as bad as them!". In any case, it's completely understandable how & why you think that way, and I'm not interested in having a fight about it.

I will simply take the position that it is worse to arrogantly claim instant expertise than it is to (snarkily) criticize arrogance.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jccc on Monday July 11, 2016 @12:46PM (#12072297)
Uh, well gosh. Did you have this comment below on your HN profile before or after the above conversation?

"[...] if you notice that I have been hell-banned, just let me know so I can delete my account from this shithole."

https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=jonsterling

I'm probably not the first person to suggest this to you, but I've found that what I get from a community/workplace/neighborhood/family has a lot to do with what I put into it.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by jonsterling on Thursday July 14, 2016 @04:16PM (#12096860)
> but I've found that what I get from a community/workplace/neighborhood/family has a lot to do with what I put into it.

Huh? The comment I am criticizing in this thread is not directed at me, and has nothing to do with me. Seems a bit of a stretch to think that I caused it by my attitude, etc. It's a general characteristic of the HN community, not caused or sparked at all by my criticism or engagement.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by psyc on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:12PM (#12034032)
You may or may not be "right" in this particular case, but in general it's stupid to assume philosophers in the HN audience won't be drawn out to comment on such an article.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by ubernostrum on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:44PM (#12034126)
I have a degree in philosophy and did quite a bit of my work in philosophy of science. I feel qualified to smugly dismiss lisper's comment as an example of the well-known phenomenon of tech people on HN assuming that mastery and understanding in one field translates to mastery and understanding in all fields, sight unseen.

For example, defining just what is and is not "science" or "the scientific method" is something that scientists and philosophers of science have been working on for centuries. But this thread is full of HN randos basically chiming in with "here's my grade-school textbook's definition, guess we don't need all those so-called experts, lol". The level of not just ignorance, but ignorance of ignorance, HN users routinely display in this kind of conversation is frankly staggering.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by rbancroft on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @11:10AM (#12036954)
I first thought the article was a bit of a fluff piece, but after seeing this thread and the misunderstanding and over-simplification, it does seem apropos and worth discussing. The toolkit that makes a scientist does not necessarily make a philosopher of science and vice-versa. Thankfully I am neither so I can see both sides :)

(and the comments section on the nytimes site is a mixed bag as well)

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by mirimir on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:49PM (#12034141)
So why didn't the author even mention falsification?
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by twblalock on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:10PM (#12034205)
Because many philosophers of science reject Popper's views as unrepresentative of the way science is done by real people in the real world. The Wikipedia page for falsifiability enumerates some of these criticisms.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by mirimir on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:34PM (#12034260)
Well, then those real people aren't doing science.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by alayne on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @12:01AM (#12034327)
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by mirimir on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @12:09AM (#12034352)
Interesting, but it doesn't mention Kuhn.

Also, there's seems to be some attachment to the idea that truth can be proven.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by twblalock on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:46PM (#12034287)
This is the No True Scotsman fallacy, and a rather obvious example of it.
Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by mirimir on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:52PM (#12034295)
OK, so what do you consider to be science with hypotheses that can't be falsified?

Edit: Much cosmology and some theoretical physics seem pretty iffy to me, but at least there's the possibility of falsifiable hypotheses.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by powera on Monday July 04, 2016 @11:08PM (#12034199)
I took one class in the philosophy of science in college, and feel qualified to smugly dismiss the article.

The article makes the point that knowing what something is and defining it are different. He then repeats that claim about 55 times, and says nothing else about science at all, certainly nothing about attempting to define the scientific method.

(I don't really want to spend time arguing about Popper or Lakatos here. But that's not relevant to the content of the article at all.)

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by lisper on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:55PM (#12034164)
> is something that scientists and philosophers of science have been working on for centuries

That's true. But that does not mean that the problem is unsolvable, and it does not mean that the problem has not been solved. It has. Popper solved it.

Re:There Is No Distinctly Scientific Method by lisper on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:56PM (#12034166)
He may know about Popper, but he clearly has not understood Popper or he would not have written this article. For example, he would have understood why this:

"When a scientist tests a hypothesis and finds that its predictions do not quite match available observations, there is always the option of forcing the hypothesis to fit the data."

is a straw man.