News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by coldtea on Monday July 04, 2016 @02:05PM (#12032105)
>A friend argued that it's still the same language, so you can understand what others are saying even with a different dialect. Please.

Even if you cannot understand it, it remains the same language. Language is defined by the syntax rules and vocabulary, not the exact way those are pronounced (which can vary even between the same dialect).

>The only reason people have a problem with AAVE is some sort of racial pretentiousness. Even the use of the phrase "Standard English" in this article is pretentious. Standard to whom? Brits certainly have a different perspective of what "Standard English" is from Americans.

There are still majorities and minorities, and the first define what's "standard". Besides, even the Brits have their standard and their not so standard English.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by mcguire on Monday July 04, 2016 @09:06PM (#12033847)
"Language is defined by the syntax rules and vocabulary..."

And it's a damn good thing that we have The Universal College of English Grammar, Vocabulary, Weights, and Measures to tell us how to talk good and what pseudo-words should be expunged. Otherwise, we'll end up speaking a weird bastardization of German, French, Latin, and who knows what else.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by coldtea on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @10:03PM (#12040795)
Not sure what the snark here is supposed to address, but in general we don't speak a "weird bastardisation of German, French, Latin, and who knows what else" when we speak English.

We speak the english language, for which dictionaries that cover almost all of its vocabulary (spare some neologisms) do exist.

That English has borrowed words from other/older languages (and incorporated them into its own syntactic scheme and vocabulary) does not mean those words are still German, Latin etc in the context of English.

They are just english words of German, Latin, etc etymology. And more often than not, even their spelling and meaning has changed from their originating language.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by devishard on Monday July 04, 2016 @02:26PM (#12032194)
> Even if you cannot understand it, it remains the same language. Language is defined by the syntax rules and vocabulary, not the exact way those are pronounced (which can vary even between the same dialect).

Syntax rules like "no double negatives" or vocabulary like "fleek" and "pneumococcal" and "dreich"? All of that is English, and I can point to dialects of English that have each and dialects of English that don't have each.

> There are still majorities and minorities, and the first define what's "standard".

Where? In the neighborhood I grew up in, the majority uses double negatives. In the UK "colour" is the majority way to spell "color". If you want to argue that the majority determines the standards, then the standards are contextual, because different segments of the population are the majority in different contexts.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by tptacek on Monday July 04, 2016 @02:28PM (#12032201)
I agree with you, but I think the word "standard" gets deployed for lack of any better term. Maybe "Mainstream American English" would be more precise, but it's clunkier, too.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by devishard on Monday July 04, 2016 @04:40PM (#12032876)
I think we use the term "Standard" because it accurately describes the fact that it is a standard enforced by a lot of institutions. Failure to comply with this standard is punished in a lot of ways.

To be clear, I'm not saying that's how it should be, I'm merely describing what exists.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by pluma on Monday July 04, 2016 @03:50PM (#12032636)
Technically speaking there is no standard version of any language, outside artificial standards like those defined by the Academie Francaise for French. There certainly aren't any speakers of the standard version.

Technically every person has a so-called idiolect, which has a shared subset with what you would call the standard language but both includes vocabulary (and likely grammar) that is non-standard and also excludes some vocabulary (and again likely grammar) that is standard.

Just like a statistical average it's incredibly unlikely (and sometimes even possible) any one person matches that standard. The notion is only really useful when talking about groups -- as is the entire concept of a "language" (or even dialects).

The entire notion of whether something is "correct" or "incorrect" ultimately depends on mutual intelligibility and whether some authority (even supposedly "descriptivist" authorities like dictionaries effectively act as authorities) acknowledges it or not.

"Language" is a lot like "species". It's a useful concept at scale but it brakes down when you try to talk about relations between individuals and if you try to define the borders too clearly it becomes apparent that it's all just a leaky abstraction to make sense of the far too complicated mess you are trying to reason about.

Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by devishard on Monday July 04, 2016 @04:53PM (#12032948)
I don't disagree that everyone has their own idiolect, but I don't think that's generally the most relevant attribute of the way someone speaks at the given moment. I think the group within which they are speaking has a much greater impact; i.e. the dialect I speak with my friends from high school is very different from the dialect I speak in a job interview for an academic software job. Sure, there are some words or structures I use more often that are unique to me, but the differences based on the context of my speech are way larger.
Re:African American Vernacular English Is Not Standard Engli... by Retra on Monday July 04, 2016 @10:38PM (#12034107)
Definitions follow usage, not vice versa. If what you are saying were true, there'd be no way for language to first develop save for some divine being handing us a book of words we didn't know and magically teaching us how to use them.