We've noticed an uptick in this kind of thing lately, and no, you can't do it here.
A claim that is easy to generate evidence for, because it is true, is that being black severely limits your economic opportunity. That, of course, is a boring claim; numerous studies have demonstrated the discrimination black people endure based simply on their names. Should they, in the interests of "fully integrating", change those as well?
This comment was written in response to a poorly argued comment that has now, with the introduction of "talk like hoodlums", been edited into something worse.
But is there anyone that isn't made extremely uncomfortable by that possibility? Yet the logic is exactly the same. How is changing your skin color to fit in, any different than changing your language?
I think there is a cruel logic to parent commenters point. He's absolutely correct, teaching the kids to "speak white" would probably make them better off. At least in terms of statistical outcomes. But the suggestion just seems so wrong and offensive. In the same way as telling them to just change their skin color and "stop being black", were possible to do so.
Your argument is crass, but I think you're being needlessly romantic. Unlike skin colour, you can "wear" more than one language and switch between them as appropriate.
In fact, if you spend any time studying linguistics you will quickly learn that even "monolingual" speakers speak different languages depending on the context. We classify these as different registers or sociolects but ultimately the effect is the same:
The language we speak heavily depends on who we are speaking to, not only on who we are.
Whether we can preserve languages that are effectively running out of contexts to be useful in is another question. But that is basically an argument about controlling natural evolution. And that's actually a solved problem: just look at how we preserve other cultural artefacts like art and crafts.
Also, just because a culture is disappearing doesn't mean no new cultures will be created. I'm sure the Romans never worried about their language going away yet the modern "lingua franca" is ultimately a descendent of a bunch of regional varieties of a language closely related to Old Norse. A thousand years from now the worry about the future of AAVE will seem as quaint as the worry about the future of Kentish Old English would seem now (if anyone worried at the time at all).
Heck, the situation of AAVE is actually infinitely better than that of Kentish Old English: there is a wealth of contemporary study into AAVE and thanks to modern technology it is trivial to archive speech samples, even including the spoken word and interviews with native speakers.
If you ignore the politicisation of this issue (because all "race" issues are political in the US, even when they're supposedly about language) the decline of AAVE is no more tragic than the decline of any other regional or social language.
Preserving languages is a solved problem. There is no reason to worry about AAVE beyond ensuring its preservation except for race politics.
People change their language all the time (which is why the skin color comparison is nonsense to begin with). Ultimately that means some languages are going to be discontinued. Preservation helps preventing these languages (as cultural heritage) from being forgotten.
Saying AAVE speakers shouldn't learn and speak GA is more akin to saying redheads shouldn't should only procreate with other redheads because otherwise redhead culture might go "extinct" (or rather: only survive in the form of occasional mutations).
They have for 1000's of years but it is getting more techy.
They shouldn't be doing it cause it makes the racial majority feel bad?
Some pretty twisted logic if you sit down and think about it.
Further, "[i]n Oakland itself... it was found that teachers who condemned AAVE pronunciations [sic] and interpreted them as reading errors got the worst results in teaching AAVE-speaking children to read, while teachers who used AAVE creatively in the classroom got the best results."
I couldn't find evidence in the article that anyone was telling young black Americans that they could talk like "hoodlums" and expect to get ahead in life.
Perhaps understanding the linguistics will help you and others from automatically having negative connotations about speakers of AAVE.
2. Are you assuming all or most black people speak this way and/or can't speak 'properly' in proper circumstances? Do you draw the same conclusions for the vernacular of (poor) southern whites?
3. '[I]ntegrate', 'culture', and 'Uncle Tom' have real historical significance. Do African-American's simply need to speak the standard white American dialect to 'get ahead in life' or do they need to also act white? Perhaps look white?
In the recent past, not having a real education and not wearing a suit everyday severely limited your economic opportunity. Entrepreneurship in the form of "hacker culture" changed that. I think the same can happen with entrepreneurship in the form of "black culture" or any culture.
Please question assumptions, second-guess terms like hoodlum not to be politically correct but to be accurate, and know history explains a lot about why society is how it is, anthropology does too.
We know whites who speak non standard English also suffer from job difficulties.
We know middle class immigrants like to get their kids to integrate into their new society by learning their new country's language and being proficient in it. We see this in France, Britain, Japan, etc. Fitting into the mainstream, like it or not, improves life opportunities. I know people like to retain their culture, and that's fine, but actively despising it and then saying the mainstream culture shuns you is unsurprising.
It's like bikers who dress like bikers do as to "enjoy" the the image that brings then complain they get reactions from people or police which affect them negatively, even if they aren't engaging in their aura. It's not exactly the same, but the mechanisms have similarity.
African-American parents push for standard English as well.
African-Americans know fitting into mainstream culture improves life opportunities.
African-Americans don't actively (or passively) despise the mainstream culture.
African-Americans do complain about the reactions from people and police which affect them negatively, even when wearing a suit and speaking perfect proper English.
Is it possible black people aren't really different but are treated differently? Why?
Or maybe my reading, travel, and observations have selection bias skewed too positively.
Calling is broken generates defensive attitudes that will likely impede any actual process of integration.
This is similar to kids learning Mandarin in China, they are taught that Mandarin is a different language than their dialect not that they speak broken Chinese, so they learn Mandarin and are eventually able to use it in business/formal situations.