> Civilization is about bringing order to chaos
Please don't take HN threads on generic ideological tangents.
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12030324 and marked it off-topic.
Taking two quotes out of context and presenting that as the reason for marking the comment off-topic is a bit bizarre. Are you saying that any comment that appeals to broader philosophical arguments is necessarily off-topic?
The bulk of the essay is an exploration of what AAVE actually is. Some of what emerges debunks the notion --- casually tossed off in your comment --- that the rules of AAVE are somehow lower-class; many of them are shared by other dialects of English, and even more are present in the primary dialects of other languages.
Even more persuasive is the essay's central implied point: contrary to your description of AAVE as "street talk", AAVE is an intricately and rigidly defined dialect of English. You can't speak or write it simply by mangling Standard English. Well-educated writers who have samples of AAVE to work from fail comprehensively at replicating it, as the essay demonstrates in its hilarious payoff.
To the extent the essay concerns itself with AAVE education, it's to point out that AAVE-aware education produces superior results in outcomes for Standard English education, in the same sense that teaching French people to speak Standard English is easier when you allow the speakers to acknowledge the French language.
Why not? It would help understanding how many people talk.
This kind of snobbery can be seen in Canada. Many English-speaking Canadians have to take some years of French schooling. However, due to whatever the opposite of "cultural Marxism" (edit: okay, the opposite of "nihlism", per your own edit) is, English Canadians are mostly taught the prestige dialect of France, which is not nearly as useful to Canadians as learning how Quebeckers actually talk would be. Sure, the prestige French dialect isn't completely useless either, but without this linguistic snobbery we could be doing a lot better to understand each other.
Also, nihilism is impossible. A belief in nothing is still a belief.
Teaching AAVE in schools is not going to help the students in black communities, it's just going to further alienate them from the rest of society. Accepting papers written in AAVE isn't going to prepare people for reality: no one cares about social justice for a dialect, they care about effective communication.