But I like the original Yiddish, because it illustrates the point rather clearly (transcribed to the latin alphabet): "a shprakh iz a dialekt mit an armey un flot"
There's a nice, relevant discussion of the origin of the quote on the Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_language_is_a_dialect_with_a...
Considering the history of the quote it's probably a direct dismissal of the "just broken German" assertion (because German had an army and a navy but Yiddish obviously did not).
There isn't really an official version of French either:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgiNoNqYXMA
Or rather, both English and French have prestige dialects. If you want to adhere to high social standing, you try to emulate the speech of BBC or CNN reporters, or you try to follow the constraints of l'Academie.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prestige_%28sociolinguistics%2...
I like that in Spanish the corresponding Royal Spanish Academy has gotten a bit laxer in recent years and rather than trying to tell people all around the Spanish world how to talk, they just document variations in their official dictionary. To do this, they are aided by other Spanish academies around the world, including the US Spanish Academy:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_of_Spanish_Languag...
They still publish articles on how to spell, but I find that more tolerable, as spelling is artificial but speech is natural.
Yes, yes there is. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acad%C3%A9mie_fran%C3%A7aise
The very video you link to calls Quebec French "Joual"... not French. It criticizes those who say they don't speak properly. They speak Joual proprely :)
Joual is a dialect of French, sure, but not proper French.
PS: I've never before heared the term "Joual" before (I'm a native French speaker). Thanks for the TIL!
France does not have the exclusive right to define what "French" is.
Québec and other parts of the Francophonie have many differing versions of French, and not all Quebeckers speak Joual exclusively (nor do all New Brunswickers[1] speak Chiac exclusively). The French spoken in Québec has the same rich history and origins as the French spoken in Québec. You can read more about the history of Québec French here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oyf8tz_IoyQ
----
Quebec is not the only non-France part of the world where French is spoken, and as a citizen of one of these parts, I still believe (like most French speakers) that French is, indeed, formally defined.
You are free to speak whatever dialect of French you like (or come up with your own), nobody is arguing against that. I'll speak my own just as well. That doesn't make it proper French.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_language#Dialects
EDIT: Failed at linking to the appropriate section, which would have been ok if it didn't make my reply excessively pedantic. If you read it before my edit, sorry.
The rest of the time I'm quite happy to speak my dialect instead.
Ergo: I don't consider dialects (mine or others) to be French. They are dialects of French. Not French.
Not all Québec french is "Joual" FYI.
Also there is nothing credible that makes Parisian French[1] the official correct one.
The academy can prescribe all it wants, it doesn't mean it has to be followed.
Language belongs to and is made by the people, not by Coanan the grammarian at the Académie.[2]
If linguists want to study it and create dictionaries, and descriptive grammars, great. But I don't care to listen to them once they start to prescribe: don't tell us how to speak.
[1] Which one anyway, St. Denis accent is 'Parisian'.
[2] There are studies demonstrating that in mixed language environments, it is the second generation children who 'creolize' the mostly unstructured pidgin spoken by their elders. This creole has fixed grammatical rules and is the beginnings of a new language.
[1] http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/national/deplorable-queb...
For example, what would you call a small piece of break baked in a broadly spherical shape? The University of Manchester decided to find out: http://projects.alc.manchester.ac.uk/ukdialectmaps/lexical-v...
Your evening meal, what do you call that? That varies, too: http://projects.alc.manchester.ac.uk/ukdialectmaps/lexical-v...
What about grammatical "errors", such as "The dress what I bought"? They looked at that too: http://projects.alc.manchester.ac.uk/ukdialectmaps/syntactic...
I encourage people to explore the menus on that site. It's fascinating, genuinely.
English is a dynamic language, particularly in its first birthplace, structured as it is after multiple invasions from Latin speakers, Germanic/Anglo-Saxon speakers, Vikings, the French, and more recently African, Caribbean, Sri Lankan and Indian/Asian migration from the former empire and commonwealth.
It is why we can turn anything into an adverb and immediately make it rude/suspect ("I am so going to have a good penguining tonight"), or delightfully ambiguous on the one hand, but the intent obvious on the other ("This track is so brick, mate, you should listen to it").
English is not French. There is no official version of it. We talk about "proper" English as being "The [King/Queen]'s English", perhaps, but only to identify it as being distinct from the English used by many others. People aspire to use it as royalty does for obvious reasons, but it is churlish to dismiss variations.
The fact that this issue happened in Oakland, that it was an issue relating to African American children in particular, that it is divorced from the reality of English and its traditions, all of this makes me suspicious the underlying cause was a form of implicit/subconscious racism. It may even have been explicit.
That said, I've noticed America in particular has held onto a form of English and developed it in a way that is quite divorced from the UK. It's thought that the modern New York accent and vernacular is not wholly dissimilar to 18th-century English South West, for reasons perhaps obvious to those who understand a little of the history of New York and its earliest settlers. Likewise, Canadian accents have more than a hint of Scottish in many parts: 1950s Canadian films to me sound almost 100% Scottish.
What is the point I'm making? It's a language for all of us. Yes there is a standard English. But those who seek to deny its development within sub-cultures and regional variations are not just denying its tradition and history, but avoiding a possibly very beautiful future.