News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by d0100 on Sunday July 03, 2016 @10:24AM (#12026138)
If an animal can't communicate complex thought, he is just an animal. No matter how "smart" or "emotionally developed" they appear.

Until then it's just instinct.

And if the day ever arrives, it can just be seen as an evolutionary step for the species, and not as proof that they where intelligent all along.

Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by fao_ on Sunday July 03, 2016 @10:47AM (#12026183)
Define 'complex', and 'communicate'. Are deaf and blind people "just animals", no matter how -your quotes- "smart" or "emotionally developed" they appear?
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by d0100 on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @09:24AM (#12036225)
No need to stretch what I said. Communicate has a well defined meaning: share or exchange information, news, or ideas. And 'complex' was used to exclude what I consider instinctual feelings/thoughts: anger, hunger, love, happiness, obedience, etc.

The deaf and blind can communicate. And even in the case of a human vegetable, a broken table is still a table.

Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by fao_ on Wednesday July 06, 2016 @08:41AM (#12042651)
I'm actually not stretching it, I was demonstrating that your limitations either exclude humans or include animals.

What your limitations seem to ignore is that not only does most of our day-to-day behaviour fall under what you consider instinctive, but also that you seem to be ignoring the fact that many animals communicate in languages you might not necessarily be able to understand (Dogs, for example, communicate mostly in body language, looks, etc.).

Can you state an example of a complex thought? I can think of a fair amount of thoughts I would use to denote intelligence that would fall under what you consider 'instinctual'.

Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by mjlangiii on Sunday July 03, 2016 @10:41AM (#12026166)
Yeah, people seem to want to decrease the degree of separation between humans and animals. The scientists probably reach a bit in their conclusions, for many reasons, and readers seem to me they may have some latent desire to bring humans and animals closer together, like they want a grand unifying law of life and ethics or maybe a link to our past and how consciousness evolved which could mean we have more reason to treat animals more like equals. I get it, that all seems good and fine. But looking at the general evidence I still conclude there is a huge difference between animals and people. And I think the results of experiments don't change anything, regardless of what they find we should respect animals even though they're "just animals".

I liked the experience vs awareness model presented in Stumbling Upon Happiness where people think about the future (awareness of what's happening to them/others) and animals simply operate in the moment based on instincts and being informed by memories (experience). I think that is a pretty good model for the difference.

Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by tremon on Sunday July 03, 2016 @10:48AM (#12026186)
how do you define "communicate" though? Does it involve you interpreting or understanding the animal's communication?
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by d0100 on Tuesday July 05, 2016 @09:16AM (#12036171)
By it's definition: share or exchange information, news, or ideas.
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by grecy on Sunday July 03, 2016 @01:39PM (#12026869)
Hopefully when super-advanced telepathic aliens show up on Earth they don't think the same way about us because we can't communicate complex thought in the same way they can.
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by ZeroFries on Sunday July 03, 2016 @12:04PM (#12026450)
How did you arrive at the conclusion that communicating complex thought is not instinct, and all other forms of intelligent and emotional behavior are instinct?
Re:Rats free each other from cages (2011) by lttlrck on Sunday July 03, 2016 @01:31PM (#12026831)
What if an animal can communicate a complex though to another animal? Like we do?