News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by Retric on Saturday July 02, 2016 @05:32PM (#12023861)
Internet of things needs a point. It's more about features for features sakes than anything else. Sure, a manufacture can add wifi for ~1$, but then what.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by krapp on Saturday July 02, 2016 @05:41PM (#12023889)
>Sure, a manufacture can add wifi for ~1$, but then what.

Analytics, surveillance and lock-in. Require the user to apply for an online account and charge them a monthly fee to do something online that used to be free, monitor their usage and make it difficult for them to use another brand's products without significant friction.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by Retric on Saturday July 02, 2016 @05:49PM (#12023905)
Great now what's the killer app? I have seen an internet connected blender, toaster, refrigerator, microwave, vaccume, coffee maker, oven, dishwasher, close washer and dryer. But not a single reason to buy any of them.

AV, lights, thermostat, blinds, sure. But, that's 30 year old home automation stuff not 'the Internet of things'.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by ourmandave on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:17PM (#12023975)
I had to google internet connected toaster out of disbelief, but sure enough...

http://www.cmodigitalforum.com/2016/03/22/internet-of-things...

The linked article concludes:

Consumers may find it totally cool to design images for toast using a smartphone.

So the next killer app is you can design images on toast. Words fail me. Will people be uploading images of Jesus?

I assume the screen saver on the toaster will be flying toasters.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by baldeagle on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:26PM (#12023994)
Every fifth slice of toast offers a coupon to your nearest walmart for 38 cents off a stick of butter.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by stephengillie on Saturday July 02, 2016 @08:32PM (#12024333)
I'm amazed Betty Crocker or Kraft haven't partnered with GE or Sharp to make a smart microwave. Who doesn't want one-button cooking, isn't that one of the intended benefits of microwaves? Each brand could have their own app in the microwave app store.

Put in a bowl of Easy Mac and press the Easy Mac button in the microwave app, microwave perfectly cooks the brand name meal. This is possible because Kraft would have their test kitchens using the same app and microwave.

---

This is just like Roomba all over again. Sure, they made a vacuum robot, and stopped there. Where's the Roomba lawnmower, man? Where's the Roomba clothes-picker to put laundry on the floor into a basket? Where's the Roomba trash can that takes itself out? Does nobody dream?

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by Retric on Saturday July 02, 2016 @09:39PM (#12024486)
Your going to run out of buttons fairly quickly unless the meal can talk to the microwave. And at that point it might as well just give cooking instructions.

Honestly, this would be a great use for QR codes, but there is probably a patent out there.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by kps on Saturday July 02, 2016 @10:31PM (#12024591)
Internet-connected, the microwave can just scan the barcode on the food package.

You can only cook supported food, though; your food vendor needs to belong to the same consortium as your oven vendor.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by Retric on Sunday July 03, 2016 @06:37AM (#12025543)
Hot pockets don't have barcodes on the things you put in the microwave. So, your going to need to change the packaging.

You could use wifi and a cell phone to take a picture of the package, but that's more effort than entering a time.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by stephengillie on Sunday July 03, 2016 @05:19PM (#12027665)
Or open up the search feature and search your microwave for "Hot Pockets". Or the microwave could have a camera viewing the inside somehow. Think of today's microwaves with a $50 tablet built in.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by stephengillie on Sunday July 03, 2016 @04:28AM (#12025238)
Well, you could cook unsupported food the "old-fashioned" way, by poking a time into the microwave. 2 minutes should cook it, right?
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by stephengillie on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:37PM (#12024720)
You're right that there are implementation details to work out, but that shouldn't invalidate the entire concept.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by baldeagle on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:25PM (#12023992)
I think that anything that could be scheduled, except for people inherently having variance in their routines, could be fodder for the IoT. For example, the coffee maker idea would work if it were plumbed and drained and only needed cleaning like twice a year. But since my coffee machine already works at the push of a button there isn't much time to save.

The best IoT item I've purchased so far is a sprinkler controller. It does a good job of keeping the grass green, but not too green.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by notatoad on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:47PM (#12024057)
intelligent but not internet-connected sprinkler controllers have existed for a long time though. What's the benefit of connecting it to the net?
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by krapp on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:12PM (#12023962)
A killer app for consumers probably wouldn't exist for most things, unless you could integrate streaming or delivery services.

But I think the real killer app will help correlate consumer behavior, advertising and the supply chain. You could have a refrigerator that keeps track of everything you buy and where you bought it. Scaled up to tens of thousand or millions of consumers, you might have very useful data for stores to use to predict what to stock and how much, and how to target advertisements. I'm reminded of the story of Wal-Mart predicting one of their customer's pregnancies based on their purchasing habits, and sent coupons for related products.

I also think integration with social media is going to be a huge part of the IoT taking off but I'm not entirely sure how, yet, other than vague ideas about appliances having their own AI driven social media accounts and posting to your feed. That could both be useful, and an incredibly sinister way of getting consumers to empathize emotionally with a brand, even if only subconsciously.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by baldeagle on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:20PM (#12023982)
Dave,

Based on the contents of your fridge, and the contents of your potential guest's fridge, I can not open that door.

#firstdatefails

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by SpacemanSpiff on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:27PM (#12024001)
wow, with all due respect, to me this vision of the future sounds horrifying. My refrigerator on Facebook? No thank you.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by krapp on Saturday July 02, 2016 @07:08PM (#12024126)
To you, it sounds horrifying. To your children, or grandchildren, though, It will be completely normal.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by thaumasiotes on Saturday July 02, 2016 @09:08PM (#12024413)
Things can be completely normal and still horrifying. No matter what section of the status quo you bring up, there will be someone who despises it.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by killbrad on Saturday July 02, 2016 @08:41PM (#12024347)
I believe it was Target, not WM.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by jonathankoren on Saturday July 02, 2016 @07:05PM (#12024118)
>Great now what's the killer app?

You know all that stuff you bought and just use? That's all subscriptions now. So, enjoy your toast subscription! Just don't try bagels. That's a premium add on for an extra $2 a month.

Oh.. You meant for consumers. Yeah, I got nothing.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by petra on Saturday July 02, 2016 @06:58PM (#12024097)
>> Internet of things needs a point.

Why ? the $1 bullshit app industry, for example, is thriving.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by IshKebab on Saturday July 02, 2016 @07:55PM (#12024243)
Just because there's a ton of shit doesn't mean there aren't things that are improved with connectivity.

Wi-Fi video doorbells are pretty great (or at least have the potential to be great). The Nest thermostat is good. Security cameras are obviously better if you can access them remotely.

I have WiFi scales that are awesome (I've wanted some for yeeears but they've only just become affordable).

I wish I had connected blinds and curtains, and smart lights would be good if integrated with the wall switches (damn renting).

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by carterehsmith on Saturday July 02, 2016 @08:11PM (#12024280)
I am curious about the connected termostat. What is the value above non-connected one? I only see trouble here:

- It can autoupdate. Awesome. In reality, update will have a bug (how do they achieve that with something so simple?) and you house will freeze. This happenned to a bunch of Nest users. - Some dude from Elbonia will break into your Nest and shut off your heating and your house will freeze.

Good sides? Would love to hear them.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by dangrossman on Saturday July 02, 2016 @08:32PM (#12024332)
Everyone in my family adjusts the house's temperature by voice, via Alexa (Amazon Echo). Alexa controls the Nest via Nest's internet API. The physical thermostat is on the other side of the house, while Alexa can hear us from any room on the floor.

We also use the Nest Android app to change the temperature while already tucked in to bed for the night without having to get up, or to turn off the A/C if we've left home and forgot to, in order to save money.

Nest's connected features get used multiple times a day every single day in my house. It's virtually never adjusted by hand.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by carterehsmith on Sunday July 03, 2016 @12:24AM (#12024815)
OK one thing I missed is: why are you adjusting temperature several times a day?

Why not just program night/morning/work hours/evening temperatures and let the thermostat change to the right one. Nothing to do, nothing to think about.

Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by dangrossman on Sunday July 03, 2016 @12:51AM (#12024866)
Neither of us works a 9-5 job. Next Monday at 3PM, there might be nobody home, or both of us home, or I'm home and want the A/C on, or I'm home but the weather's nice so I'm working in the sunroom and don't need the A/C. That evening, we may spend a few hours out with friends or family, and don't need the A/C blasting at home for no reason. Or we may be home and need it after all. At midnight, we may both be sleeping, and she'll want the temperature around 68. Or she might be working an overnight shift, and when I'm sleeping alone I prefer it warmer. There's nothing that can be programmed into the thermostat in advance. Remote control offers the best convenience and best economics.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by carterehsmith on Sunday July 03, 2016 @05:57AM (#12025430)
I see, thanks.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by Retric on Saturday July 02, 2016 @09:15PM (#12024434)
Sounds like fairly bog standard home automation. You should really not want to mess with the thermostat much, but I can see it's a renters shortcut when your dealing with a single temperature zone which seems reasonable.
Re:The “Internet of Things” Needs a Fix by ci5er on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:48PM (#12024737)
IoT is the superceding moniker of M2M, right?

I can't tell if I am about to accuse you of failure of vision, but if I end up doing so, it isn't intended in an mean-spirited way.

I'm an engineer. I build things. If somebody needs a motor or a control system or a marijuana distiller or a laser printer postscript engine kanji-to-scanalizer, that's what I get hired to do.

Recently, I was hired by a residential-to-light-commercial construction engineering company. They get plots and plats and architectural designs and collect their own soil samples and have to generate slabs and framing plans. Pretty mundane, but a lot of their process is done by hand, and they wanted to automate it.

During the process, it becomes apparent that a big component is soil - on the foundation. 30 year insurance plans on how much the foundation gets distorted by ... well, in some areas, ... rainfall.

It turned out (this is a few years ago now, so now we have data) that moister causes expansion and contraction. That causes the foundation to flex and fail. It also turns out that, one can measure the flexing with sensors, report back to the data-munging mother ship, and tell the sprinker system to water more or water less and ... save foundation cracks.

Now, yes, I know that this is nothing more than adding WiFi for ~1$, as you say. But it's a pretty big business value that works all up and down the value chain for how 30 year costs and risks and layoffs get allocated for entire subdivisions. I guess I'm not disagreeing with you - I guess I'm saying that, I agree, but, that's still a lot of value.