News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by jondubois on Saturday July 02, 2016 @10:45AM (#12022729)
The reason why income inequality doesn't matter when compared to wealth inequality is this:

If you're a high-income earner in a big city and you want to buy a house/apartment, you're going to have to take on massive debt and you will end up paying double what a wealthy person would pay for the same house/apartment (due to interests).

In effect, prices on the housing market are not determined by income-earners; they are determined by wealth-owners.

To buy a house (or anything which is in limited supply), income-earners are forced to compete with wealth-owners; and wealth owners can afford to drive market prices way up - This is in part because wealth owners, on average, do not value money as much as income-earners do. Also, as mentioned above, they don't have to factor in interest rates when making purchasing decisions.

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by charlesdm on Saturday July 02, 2016 @10:58AM (#12022779)
As someone with a few very wealthy friends, this is not always true. It does however help to close a deal faster than someone who wants to purchase the same property using a mortgage.

1. Interest rates matter, because if they're low, they'll usually invest their money elsewhere / pay the interest / pocket the difference. They'll often do a deal "cash" (meaning, without debt) and refinance later.

2. Using debt to offset taxes matters too.

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by jondubois on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:15AM (#12022831)
But surely you must agree that wealthy people do drive up property prices more than mere high-income earners. Just look at the case of Mark Zuckerberg's purchases in Palo Alto (as an extreme example):

First he bought a house for $7 million (which was widely regarded as massively overpriced at the time). Then he ended up buying all adjacent properties for $30 million.

In a few short years, he single-handedly contributed to a massive increase in property prices in his entire neighbourhood. This is essentially the story of San Francisco's property market over the past 10 years.

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by charlesdm on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:41AM (#12022898)
Of course, because high income != wealth. It's only the first step.

It could become significant wealth if they saved + invested it well, but most high earners are excellent at spending it all. Just look at the amount of bigtime basketball / football players who remain with nothing a few years after they stop playing.

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by nstj on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:59AM (#12022949)
this could benefit if you qualified what very wealthy means
Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 02, 2016 @11:48AM (#12022920)
This can't be correct. Inequality is the result of a very small number of people holding a large amount of wealth, typically in the form of productive investments (e.g. factories, infrastructure, etc).

But if the number of people is small, the amount of housing they can consume is tiny. For example, NYC has 5,600 ultra high net wealth individuals. Assuming a wealthy person rents 10 flats, these rich people only have the same effect on housing supply as NYU (57,000 students).

http://marketurbanism.com/2016/06/27/do-the-rich-cause-high-...

The more inequality you have, the less competition you face from wealthy people. If we replaced 5,600 rich people with 1 mega-rich person, would that mega-rich person suddenly rent 67,000 flats, taking an additional 10,000 off the market?

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by pjmorris on Saturday July 02, 2016 @12:24PM (#12023010)
I think you're not accounting for real estate investment vehicles, e.g. REIT's and hedge funds. It's possible to own something without consuming it. Your hypothetical weathly person might choose to buy 67,000 flats and gain monopoly power over their rents.
Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 02, 2016 @12:38PM (#12023040)
In much the same way, Walmart/Tesco/etc reduce the food supply. How can a poor person possibly get enough to eat when they must compete with the near infinite spending power of Walmart? There must be mass starvation!

Similarly, if you own real estate and rent it out you aren't reducing the housing supply.

Your hypothetical weathly person might choose to buy 67,000 flats and gain monopoly power over their rents.

You don't get monopoly power over rents by buying 67,000 flats (out of a millions).

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by pjmorris on Saturday July 02, 2016 @03:38PM (#12023563)
People usually don't take out loans to buy groceries. The money/credit supply matters when buying houses. Note, too, that I'm arguing that the price is affected, not the supply. As the GP points out, those who can pay cash for a house are at significant advantage to those who must borrow. As I repeat, houses can be bought as investments as well as 'consumables'. Maybe buying 67,000 houses isn't enough to monopolize the market, but I'll argue that the 1.7T the Fed has injected in to the housing market over the last decade through its purchases of mortgage-backed-securities [1] has had an effect on house prices similar to the 'wealth-owner' the GP describes. On a smaller scale, are you willing to argue that property values in Palo Alto aren't affected by purchases like Mark Zuckerberg's? [2]

[1] https://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm#...

[3] http://money.cnn.com/2016/05/25/technology/mark-zuckerberg-p...

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by hammock on Saturday July 02, 2016 @12:16PM (#12022993)
Most of the real estate owned by UHNWI's in New York is not owned by one of the 5,600 living in New York. Rather the owners are from Russia, or China, or the Middle East, etc.
Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 02, 2016 @12:34PM (#12023028)
There are about 200k UHNWI in the world taking the most generous definition wikipedia provides. Supposing they are split across Tokyo, Shanghai, Moscow, Beijing, NYC, London, Mumbai and Delhi (to name only the expensive megacities I can name off the top of my head), that's 200k UHNWI out of 195 million.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megacity

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra_high-net-worth_individua...

Assuming each of them rents 10 flats, they might consume 1% of the total housing supply.

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by hammock on Saturday July 02, 2016 @03:17PM (#12023509)
Fair point although we are conflating households with individuals. Anyway, drawing a line at UNHWI is arbitrary, we are interested in cash buyers driving up prices. So another group to look at would be non-primary residence. The average across the five boroughs is 29%. And in midtown Manhattan it reaches 44%[1]. So we are getting to the big numbers now that you are looking for, big enough to move prices in a substantial way.

[1]http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/realestate/new-york-cit...

Re:Income inequality today may be higher today than in any o... by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 02, 2016 @09:11PM (#12024425)
From the article:

And perhaps surprisingly, the data indicated that “the vast majority of pieds-à-terre are middle class,” Mr. Miller said. “They are owned by people who have a studio in the city and a home in the suburbs, or maybe it was their first apartment that they chose to keep and rent it out.”

What does middle class people becoming landlords have to do with the rich?

Insofar as a flat is being rented out (as many of them are, according to the article), it's not even reducing housing supply.