That's nice. What business of it was theirs, that they should be told at all? It smacks of a third-grade classroom, where little Susie is upset because little Janey didn't bring enough comfortable shoes for everybody, so Teacher makes a rule that either you bring enough for everybody or you don't bring any at all.
Of course, in a third-grade classroom, this sort of thing makes some sense, because we don't expect children of such a young age to be fully in command of their emotions. I gather the interns we're talking about are in their early twenties. One would reasonably expect them to have learned something in the decades since they were in third grade themselves, but perhaps that's too much to ask.
I also think that the companies reaction may have been a bit extreme. That said, I can sort of understand their thinking.
1) the interns are thinking about their dress more than their assignments. Which shows questionable prioritization.
2) they think their ideas of what is acceptable or unacceptable should even be considered. Which shows a lack of understanding of their place in the pecking order (lowest of the low).
3) related to #1, THIS is one of the first they bring to the attention of management? really? Which shows an inability understand that first you have to build respect and trust before even asking for these sort of changes.
4) the fact that they organized to ask together smacks of making demands (even if not literally stated as such). This was not simply a query/proposal up the chain. At least it doesn't seem so to me.
Personally I can't imagine a story like this even occurring in 1986. The whole idea of mass protest over something trivial is a very 21st century concept.
The yahoo repost/clickbait framed it as a protest with no evidence I can see, the original source does not frame it as a protest: http://www.askamanager.org/2016/06/i-was-fired-from-my-inter...
People do have a right to privacy. The person with a medical issue may have asked that details not be disclosed to his/her co-workers.
The questionable part of this story might not be that the interns were terminated but that the existence of the medical issue was disclosed to them at all.
Which management obviously didn't care about since they ended up telling the interns about it (apparently as a shaming tool since they specifically mentioned service).
> The person with a medical issue may have asked that the nature of the issue not be disclosed to his/her co-workers.
Which they did not have to at any point, management could just have answered the initial question with "they have a medical exemption".
> they weren’t going to complain. That is, “until I noticed one of the workers always wore flat shoes that were made from a fabric other than leather, or running shoes, even though both of these things were contrary to the dress code.”
The interns were told that was a medical exemption… after they were mass-fired, but not when they initially inquired about the possibility of relaxed dress code:
> I spoke with my manager about being allowed some leeway under the dress code and was told this was not possible, despite the other person being allowed to do it.
> They could have been lectured on professional behavior instead and I'm sure most of them would have understood.
I don't understand how sending queries/proposals up the chain is unprofessional behaviour. Ignoring the dress code and coming in not following it would be unprofessional behaviour.
They asked informally, they got shut down (rather than answered), they went with a more formal query, they were fired.
That's sounds nothing like "interns are guests" but it sounds a lot like Corporate America's reaction to union noises.