It's why I find auto-updating apps so infuriating. The trend is that every app, OS, and driver insists on being self-updating. It's going to be very difficult to maintain a reliable system if you're doing anything complex.
Privacy issues aside, that's another reason I never plan to use the continuously self-updating Windows 10.
There really isn't a good answer either way, but between "breaks occasionally" and "needs a full-time admin, but updates are vetted", I prefer option 1 for my private systems, and option 2 for things that run in production.
So you can't just say you want security fixes only, no new or changed features.
Going the other way requires developers to maintain a variety of old versions of their code so they can backport security changes. Which is a lot of work for them for very little extra value.
Also applies to Ubuntu, probably Red Hat, though the latter's vastly smaller repos mean vastly greater reliance on third-party sources, and concommitant risks of introducing/changing features when security fixes are wanted, or riding bareback without security updates.
There's also the inherent conflict between running current code and fixed code. Debian's legendary conservatism reflects a bias toward the latter, at least on its stable branches. Of course, you're welcome to lead and bleed on testing, unstable, or experimental, if you so choose.
I develop browser-based software which, after one Chrome update, was rendered unusable by a bug in Chrome. Fortunately, Google pushed out a new version with a fix the next day.
This also seems like a good reminder that transparent updating only works if your team is good and responsive enough to fix mistakes on the fly. If you're rolling out one update a month, you'd better give people a choice so they can decline when you hand them faulty upgrades.
this is safe, but it paints you into a corner over time, where you become paralyzed and can't improve anything. Needs better testing, so changes are safe.
At one place where I work, we're on nodejs 0.10, which is several release versions behind. It's causing us a bunch of problems, because while 0.10 is still technically not EOL'd yet, npm modules behave like it is... however we've left it so long, that the jump to current stable is a giant task, which we don't have the time for given other business reqs.
Tests indeed don't guarantee safety, but lots of small changes are easier to deal with than the occasional massive change. It's also the basic concept behind version control.
This story wasn't about trivial day-to-day developer bugs, but what kind of problems happen in really complex systems.
As someone who went through the process of a painful, long delayed upgrade not too long ago I definitely second this, although as a much more generalized principle I think it'd be more accurate to say that there's a fine, eternal balancing act between "work" and "meta work", and that this principle applies to way more areas of life then systems work. However much fun (or "fun") it may be, as mjd said there most/all of us primarily have work to do using our tools ("tools" being in the most generic sense here, including knowledge) rather then working on our tools. To some extent, a few days spent on tools/skills is a few days not spent applying them, and it's all too easy to sink so much time going down various rabbit holes that "actual work" loses out. But of course on the flip side improving our tools/skill sets is key to realizing major boosts in long term productivity, keeping up with changing standards, and so on. I remember a few years back at one workplace when a number of senior engineers (50s/60s) all finally bit the bullet and started to work to get up to speed on the latest CAD developments. Or myself a decade back when I decided I really needed to update my shell usage, read the full ZSH manual and spend some time seeing how I could improve my speed in general. There were many significant projects going on, but then there always were, always something that "needs to be done next week!". I personally find it can be a tough balancing act to optimize the savings gained from increased productivity down the road vs the time expenditure needed to begin realizing them in the first place, particularly if "everything is working fine". I know that over the years I cumulatively lost plenty of time on manual involvement in tasks I could have automated, but each individualized instance seemed trivial and it was easy to default to just hacking something quick and getting on with the day vs deciding it'd be worth spending time to improve it for good.
Of course that's all assuming there aren't any other barriers in the way. My extremely oddball pain point on one workstation was that I'd enthusiastically built an tower Mac Pro OS X system around ZEVO, an short lived attempt to salvage Apple's old ZFS work and bring a fully functioning version to OS X. And despite a few niggles (some which didn't matter to me, like CLI-only), by the time it was getting ready to go it was fantastic, nicely integrated and all that. I was pumped, it was exactly what I'd wanted under OS X ever since I'd seen Sun's original presentation, and I hopped fully onboard. But of course the company developing it promptly went under just as they were launching, were bought for IP/people by GreenBytes (which itself was subsequently acquired by Oracle), and after a single bug release that was it. It only worked under 10.8 and not one version later, and there was no clear upgrade path (I really didn't want to revert that system back to pure HFS). So 10.8 was where I stayed until OpenZFS and in turn O3X came along to save the day, but by that point I was out of the habit of frequent upgrades there. Testing is definitely helpful (along with a nice rollback system) but sadly can't always save you, frequent upgrades definitely help keep key meta-knowledge fresh.
This was a really cool bug track down article though, and inspiring.
Or rather, I did until this week, when it suddenly stopped working.
When this happens to me, the first thing that I ask myself is "what changed?", and I'm usually able to track down the cause to some configuration change. Incidentally, this is also why I never like modifying a working system unless it's absolutely necessary.
The fact that it ultimately was caused by some security features that would be very important for a multiuser shared server but nearly irrelevant for the (presumably) single-user local machine that he is using suggests that perhaps we shouldn't be thinking of "one size fits all" paradigm for OSs, since a lot of problems like this one stem from the unnecessary extra complexity introduced by such thinking.