News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by DannoHung on Thursday March 18, 2010 @02:51AM (#1200670)
Things I don't understand:

* Fork?

* H.264 HTML Video support via a plugin?

Why aren't these valid solutions?

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by rlpb on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:25AM (#1200847)
It's a valid solution for a client. For a web developer, chances are that your visitor isn't using the fork and hasn't installed the plugin. This means that web sites won't be able to rely on HTML5 to deliver video, and so will use something else (such as Flash).
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Thursday March 18, 2010 @03:36AM (#1200720)
Yes, someone could fork Gecko + XULrunner + Firefox; but it is a huge pain-in-the-ass to even track it as upstream, much less diverge from it.

It's purposefully architected to make a plugin very unsavory — you could do it with a plugin/extension that inspected every DOM for failed <video> embeds, dynamically replacing them with an <embed> of its own NSAPI plugin. You'd be guaranteed to get FOUC, poor detectablity, and regular breakage. At that point the author is better off just seamlessly falling back to Flash.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by carussell on Thursday March 18, 2010 @10:20PM (#1203166)
"It's purposefully architected to make a plugin very unsavory"

I'd like a citation for this please, or at least some synthesis based on some explicit rationale (which is what I expected on the with that em dash, instead of a non-sequitur).

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by blasdel on Friday March 19, 2010 @01:01AM (#1203423)
Gecko links directly with liboggplay to restrict themselves to exclusively WAV and vorbis+theora in ogg containers. Every other app out there uses a standard media handling library: ffmpeg (esp. if bundling), GStreamer, QuickTime, DirectShow, or some combination of them.

This was made explicit when us proles discovered that Mozilla has had a GStreamer <video> implementation for two years, for use in their mobile port so that they have a hope of playing video in real time:

> My exclusive focus for this GStreamer integration has been to make it work with Fennec. Not enabling it in Firefox on platforms where GStreamer has been ported to, is as far as I know a political decision. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=422540#c105

Architecting against plugins is not new in the free software community. RMS purposefully designed GCC so that you couldn't interface with its internal representations to make it impossible to have independent language frontends, optimizers, or target backends. That led directly to ECGS, a complete fork of GCC away from the FSF's control after they let it languish and refused patches — the FSF lost and eventually blessed it as the 'real' GCC. Its closed architecture is the primary motive behind LLVM's ascendancy.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by allyt on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:18AM (#1200775)
Because you need to pay licensing fees measured in "millions of USD per year" if you're going to distribute software which decodes H.264.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ubernostrum on Thursday March 18, 2010 @04:44AM (#1200804)
Or you just delegate to the OS, which either already ships a licensed copy of the codec (Windows and OS X) or has users who ignore patents and install unlicensed codecs (Linux). By doing this you incur a whopping license fee of... zero dollars, because licensing becomes someone else's problem.
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ZeroGravitas on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:20AM (#1200839)
It's not someone else's problem if your stated mission is to be "dedicated to promoting and preserving an open, shared and innovative web."

It's like a shareholder owned corporation deciding that making money is someone else's problem.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by GHFigs on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:09AM (#1200965)
Then why do they still allow me to use Adobe's h.264 license?
Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by ubernostrum on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:24AM (#1200845)
It is an ideological issue; look at my other comments and you'll see me saying that.

My problem with comments like the one I was replying to is that they refuse to see this; there is an easy solution to the financial issue of codec licensing, but it keeps getting thrown out as a red herring, when the focus should be on whether Mozilla's ideological stance is a good thing.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by allyt on Thursday March 18, 2010 @05:47AM (#1200870)
they refuse to see this

Nah, just hadn't read up/thought about the issue enough, thanks for explaining. I'm actually a bit of a supporter of software patents, as they give business reason to invest boatloads of money in things like H.264 to begin with.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by sid0 on Thursday March 18, 2010 @07:15AM (#1200976)
> which either already ships a licensed copy of the codec (Windows and OS X)

Only Windows 7 does.

Re:Dear Mozilla, Please Don't Kill HTML5 Video by KirinDave on Thursday March 18, 2010 @01:44PM (#1201951)
So? Mozilla is making a fair amount of money now. It's a big expense to license, but it's not an unobtainable one. Part of being a big player is sometimes paying out to license the best technology.

Mozilla is asking us to side with them based purely on ideology and an impact to their bottom line as a corporation. And Mozilla is not a tiny garage operation anymore.