Sorry, but this is completely incorrect.
The approximate formula for success in investing or trading is "percentage right" * "average win profit" - "percentage wrong" * "average loss" = overall profit.
Many traders are correct only 20% of the time (I'm looking at you, stock options traders) but make fortunes because they understand this formula.
You can also lose a lot of money even if you are right 90% of the time because you fail to manage a big loss properly.
It's basic expected value, magnify your wins and minimize your loss to what you know you can lose.
And there are also catastrophic losses, if you play it too risky, where you won't have enough to continue investing after a particular hard hit.
Investment houses don't start from the same place as an index fund. Their returns are penalized from the start due to the fee structure. So not only do they have to beat the market, they have to do it by a sizeable margin before the end user sees a profit advantage.
For a retail investor it is hard to justify not choosing an index fund.
Understand the market, understand the product and technology well, and you can do significantly better than any wall street analyst. Don't rush into it, but do your research. Look at the numbers and the growth potential.
This is very dangerous advice because it just ain't true. Under efficient markets, you can do equally well as "any wall street analyst"
2. Why would you assume you can't do better than an analyst, in your area of expertise? Someone who understands tech well will be able to make better tech investments, than, let's say, investments in mining. That seems pretty obvious to me. That doesn't means you'll always get it right, but it does increase chances significantly.
2. Honestly, the analysts got it wrong in their own area of expertise often enough that I don't think it makes sense to pretend they're oracles in comparison to anyone else.
I'm not saying it's not very hard to make money by trading. But be aware that you can't just assume efficient markets and have done with it.
Is looking at the company numbers enough, or do you have to look at companies in detail?
Is domain knowledge enough, or do you need to look at corporate culture, people and business plans?
How fast do you need to be, in term of reacting to events?
My professional life now revolves around mining. I'm confident to know who to invest in and who not to.
My personal life centers around various hobbies - I'm confident I could choose a few companies in those spaces to invest in. Unfortunately, most of those are well performing private companies.
what happen?
I completely disagree with this statement and I've seen it (or a variation of it) many times over the years. You can have a win rate of 99%, but still lose money if the 1% losing trades/investments wipe out all your wins. The win rate isn't what people should be looking, but the profit expectancy. Other than that, I agree with what your are saying, particularly #2. I don't think the majority of people should be actively trading/investing, they don't have the time to build the expertise and will probably not invest the time in learning about their bias.
Thanks for the overview. I'd heard about the constant trading difference before (I've tended not to think about it, since I'm a buy-and-hold-for-years type). Do you have a sense of how much cost winds up being associated with broker commissions and/or the buy-ask spread? I hadn't been aware of the simpler capital gains situation (thus far, I've just blindly copied down whatever's summarized on the year-end tax statement they provide onto my IRS forms).
*: The exceptions tend to be new-ish funds which are less liquid and have purchase costs on the mutual fund side. I haven't seen more than one or two of these recently.
[1]: http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/3e0cc962-ec0c-11e4-b428-00144feab7...
Some point out some greater risk in ETFs because they can lend their securities : http://www.etf.com/etf-education-center/21031-understanding-...
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/3e0cc962-ec0c-11e4-b428-00144feab7...
As for it only "technically" being a mutual fund: consider that VFIAX predates VOO by 10 years. How does that square with VFIAX only "technically" being a mutual fund, when presumably it was a real, honest mutual fund in the years 2000-2010 (before VOO was introduced)
Minor quibble. That is not accurate.
You see teenagers buying hotdogs with a credit card. Visa and Mastercard go public, you buy shares, it goes up, up, up.
There's no zero sum here and people can spot special values without deep analysis.
(But even if trading is zero-sum in a strict monetary sense, different risk preferences, desire to liquidate positions in order to buy something you value more, etc. mean that it's not zero-sum in a utility sense.)
There are, however, externalities that make it less costly for Visa to sell lower than the theoretical max. Happy investors are easier to manage, market momentum is strong, etc.
(Brexit nonwithstanding)
...actually that is a hole in my argument.
Okay: if you can find a cultural trend that you earnestly believe thatFinance people are out of touch with, then it makes sense to do arbitrage there.
Right now we are quite high in the cycle - 9 years from the last crisis, end of QE, slowing growth - so at least in my view, it's an asymmetric bet to wait and see. But what do I know.
Vanguard says you're wrong.
https://pressroom.vanguard.com/nonindexed/7.23.2012_Dollar-c...
It astounds me that so many people think they can be great investors. It would be like me trying to build an ark with no experience in carpentry or ship-building. Really it just strikes me as a legal and socially acceptable way to gamble. Please recognize that this is a zero-sum game, and the other person taking your trade is likely a professional who spends their entire work week doing deep analysis.