News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A ZFS developer’s analysis of Apple’s new APFS file system by tjl on Sunday June 26, 2016 @09:03PM (#11983634)
I don't think BTRFS has all the features they want. One thing you can do with APFS is do an upgrade of an HFS+ partition to APFS. That might be difficult with BTRFS.

You don't necessarily need snapshots on a watch, but I can see it coming in useful on a phone when you're editing pictures and video.

Snapshots on a watch could be useful for system recovery. Say something went wrong during an update you could potentially use the snapshot to revert to a previous version.

Re:A ZFS developer’s analysis of Apple’s new APFS file system by shmerl on Sunday June 26, 2016 @10:21PM (#11983849)
Filesysytem snapshots are useful for recovery, but it's a very powerful mechanism for it. I.e. I think for a watch it's an overkill.

On the other hand, computers are gradually moving towards miniaturization, so I suppose all this really is quite transitory, and soon enough all such considerations wills simply be irrelevant.

Re:A ZFS developer’s analysis of Apple’s new APFS file system by Dylan16807 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @11:51PM (#11984129)
BTRFS can upgrade from ext4 by slotting itself into free space and marking the old metadata as a special snapshot. The same thing should work on other filesystems with few new challenges.
Re:A ZFS developer’s analysis of Apple’s new APFS file system by cyphar on Monday June 27, 2016 @12:58AM (#11984274)
Support for that has been dropped within Btrfs AFAIK. Also, "upgrading a filesystem in place" is more of a lottery than a feature that people should actually use. So many bad things can happen.
Re:A ZFS developer’s analysis of Apple’s new APFS file system by Dylan16807 on Monday June 27, 2016 @01:34AM (#11984357)
Well I did it a month ago, on a reasonably-updated system, at least.

The main point is that upgrading "in-place" does not require any of the metadata to be in the same place between old and new filesystem. With a mildly flexible destination filesystem, the old filesystem can stay there until you're completely sure the conversion is a success. You end up with two read-only filesystems sharing a partition, and you choose which one to go forward with. Cancelling at any point is trivial, even if the conversion process crashes.