News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @02:28PM (#11981966)
This is a really good interview, in that the interviewer has knowledge comparable to the interviewee. Obviously that can't be achieved for when a single interviewer interviews people with widely ranging skills (e.g. many radio shows themselves) but is nice to have with something niche like this.

On a different note, why is that (as far as non-expert me knows) that nice mics often have eq settings? Is this not a blatant layer violation?

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by k0ngo on Sunday June 26, 2016 @02:51PM (#11982067)
> On a different note, why is that (as far as non-expert me knows) that nice mics often have eq settings? Is this not a blatant layer violation?

The low-frequency/subsonic content that this switch will remove often consists of wind noise, pops from talking too close, vibrations from the floor/mic stand, etc. Even if these low frequency noises may be more or less inaudible, they'll contribute to a large signal swing that will decrease the headroom in the following amplifiers. In other words, you won't be able to turn up the gain in the microphone amplifier/mixer as much as you'd want, because the low-frequency but high-amplitude content will make the amplifier clip and distort the sound. Filtering the signal after the mic preamp won't solve the problem, because the preamp (which can provide in the order of 60 dB gain) will be the component that clips. By including a low-cut filter in the head amplifier circuit inside the microphone (the amplifier serves only as a buffer, and usually with unity gain), the disturbing low-frequency noises can be removed before entering the high-gain microphone preamp. You can find the low-cut switch next to the capsule in the U87 schematic [0]. It seems to me that they increase the capsule bias voltage, thus changing the low frequency response by electrostatically tensioning the membrane.

[0] http://recordinghacks.com/images/mic_extras/neumann/U87-sche...

edit: tweaked some things. meta: i'm not very good at commit messages.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @03:55PM (#11982388)
Ah needs to be with the mic preamp, ok. Granted there's a lot of inertia in connectors, but has anybody tried to run extra wires in the mic cable to control these things from the both?
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by tacos on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:29PM (#11983342)
As odd as it sounds, microphone cables weren't standardized until 1992. Before then companies did all sorts of stuff.

Here's a Neumann mic from 1952 that could be set remotely. http://recordinghacks.com/microphones/Neumann/M-49

Today it is increasingly common to put the analog stuff as close to the source as possible and remote control it.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:12PM (#11983502)
What is the standard? I mainly see XLR but I've stared at far more live equipment than recording equipment.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by tacos on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:32PM (#11983554)
It's XLR. But even then Americans and Europeans couldn't agree on where to stick the three wires.

This is the 1992 document that finally standardized "pin 2 hot" among other minutiae: http://www.aes.org/publications/standards/search.cfm?docID=1...

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Monday June 27, 2016 @01:40AM (#11984370)
Interesting, thanks!
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by tacos on Sunday June 26, 2016 @03:18PM (#11982199)
For a vocal/voiceover mic loud sounds are not a concern. (The U87 has a pad switch for those cases separate from the proximity/EQ switch.)

The things you mention (vibrations, LF rumble) are typically handled by the highpass on the mic preamp and are in the 75 or 80Hz range. In musical terms, that's 4+ octaves below the 1k proximity rolloff on the mic itself.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by drewcrawford on Sunday June 26, 2016 @05:26PM (#11982821)
> Is this not a blatant layer violation?

This is the one of the areas a recording engineer's problems are different than a software engineer's intuition.

In software, we have a lot of problems that can ultimately be traced back to not having good "visibility" into the software or its state. This has various far-reaching consequences, from specialized tools to examine software (such as debuggers) to cultural values ("one job per component") that help us reason about complex systems we cannot see.

But in the case of audio, we have a multiple sensory organs to directly perceive sound. A bad audio engineer would be able to push a few buttons to move his headphones around in the signal chain and know in seconds where the EQ is occurring. A good one would simply know the U87 rolloff "by sound" and would not have to conduct any investigation at all.

There are some cases where more detailed analysis is done with fancy tools–mastering song recordings, for example. But in live sound, an audio engineer's primary concern is UX, because good UX is the difference between solving a problem quickly and annoying pops or worse. One button that engages a good EQ is much, much better than something like this: http://adn.harmanpro.com/product_attachments/product_attachm.... And epoxying the single button to the correct position is even better still!

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:31PM (#11983549)
Isn't controls on mics the worst UX because the wrong people are always messing with them?

You raise a good point about (even in the bad case) moving headphones around the signal chain---and damn as an (especially functional) programmer I'd like that to be able to tap arbitrary locations in data flow like that. Enough all these control-flow-based debugging tools!

> One button that engages a good EQ is much, much better than something like this

Well there's always overkill, but would one of those be worse than one of those and then, next in the signal chain, a 1-button EQ whose functionality is completely subsumed?

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by ww520 on Monday June 27, 2016 @01:11AM (#11984301)
Yes. Especially the instrument people who always turn up their instruments' volume mid play because they want to push theirs through. It really messes up the sound engineer's overall tuning.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by mrsirduke on Monday June 27, 2016 @02:50AM (#11984530)
> You raise a good point about (even in the bad case) moving headphones around the signal chain---and damn as an (especially functional) programmer I'd like that to be able to tap arbitrary locations in data flow like that. Enough all these control-flow-based debugging tools!

You should look into dtrace and it's new Linux counterpart who's name currently alludes me. It's almost like being able to do just that.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @05:22PM (#11997694)
I'm very aware of dtrace. probes are kinda like faking dataflow on top of control flow I guess.

I was thinking more of a development aid that would render a dataflow graph like max/msp---in the general case the graph itself is changes but thats's OK.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by riprowan on Monday June 27, 2016 @09:47AM (#11986118)
> Is this not a blatant layer violation?

No, you want to apply cuts as early as possible in the signal chain if you're trying to prevent overloads later in the chain. The "EQs" that you see on mics are almost always bass cuts designed to reduce proximity effects. This gives you much better dynamic range at the preamp because bass frequencies are energy-intensive, so cutting them early allows the amplifier to not have to do all the work amplifying (and distorting) them, just to cut them later.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by beat on Monday June 27, 2016 @11:37AM (#11986859)
Microphones need tremendous amplification to even get them to "line level" signals to interface with other audio equipment - 60db is not uncommon. Bass signals require a great deal more power (watts, or in this case milliwatts) to amplify accurately than midrange/treble signals, so they're a lot more likely to cause distortion. Rolling bass off as early as possible - preferably at the capsule, before the microphone's internal circuitry - reduces distortion.

Beyond that, with a few exceptions, most of the signal rolled off by the switch is stuff you don't want to hear anyways - "plosive" pops, rumble from low-frequency buildup in rooms, vibration, etc. Much of it can't even be reproduced by most speakers (speakers don't do low bass because, as said before, it's a hard problem and not actually audible in most cases).

As an aside, when mixing records, I'll often roll off guitars at 200 or 300hz, losing a couple of octaves of low-frequency information. In theory, this is awful. And if you listen to the solo guitar tracks, it's awful. But in an actual mix, it's great! It gets the low end of the guitars out of the way of real low-frequency instruments like bass and kick drums, making the bass sound tighter and cleaner. The guitars sound clearer too, because they aren't getting muddied by competing bass instruments.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by heuermh on Monday June 27, 2016 @04:05PM (#11989036)
This is one of the reasons I find recording guitar so unsatisfying; I want the recordings to sound like what my guitar amps pushing air in the room feels like. If I succeed, the mix turns to mush.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by beat on Tuesday June 28, 2016 @10:55AM (#11994244)
Try using far less gain on your guitars when recording. Gain that sounds great in-room is too much for a record, generally.

The great challenge of recording is to capture the authority of a roaring guitar amp, the brashness of drums, the purity of a voice, and then squeeze it down into something that fits in an iPhone earbud and still has realistic proportions. That's why the idea of "accuracy" in recording is so ludicrous. A record is to a live performance as a HO train set is to a real train. It's a miniature, a model. To make it look "right", you have to exaggerate some details and lose others.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by mcguire on Sunday June 26, 2016 @05:18PM (#11982776)
Layer violation?

The goal is to get good sound out of your recording equipment, not to get ISO approval. :-)

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:06PM (#11983484)
My aesthetic pleasure in engineering is more the means than the ends; nobody pays me to go on HN, so the latter is what I focus on :).

Every recording studio or both for a live venue I've seen always seems to have 'round 1/4 equipment always in use, 1/4 rarely but sometimes used, 1/2 equipment never used :P. I really do respect the science and art that goes into audio engineering, but damn that's a lot of clutter.

Now the flip side is it's a lot easier to trim the fat administering a bunch of a computers (and the clutter isn't a huge sunk cost like some once highly valuable piece of equipment one might be loath to chuck), and yet this ideal is also far from realized most the time. Boxes in closet are just a lot more obvious than files in a directory.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by scarecrowbob on Monday June 27, 2016 @01:06AM (#11984285)
Honestly, the less stuff I have to do in post (or in a mixer doing live sound) the easier the world is for me. The closer to the source that you can fix issues the better.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by ArkyBeagle on Sunday June 26, 2016 @05:59PM (#11982975)
Not (a layer violation) so much. Audio gear has evolved serendipitously anyway. Times were, when you wanted an EQ that wasn't just a "tone control" , you got out the soldering iron. Pultec wasn't even a thing until 1953.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @07:55PM (#11983444)
Mm, I think serendipitous evolution may explain but does not justify layer violations. In this case, it's not just engineering aesthetics but a real practical pain: buttons in lay people's hands == more problems. [People getting angry at tech and then mic is off at live events is practically a trope!]

Arguably compression wars and other such things are also a layer violation: sound engineers can guess at but not be sure of listeners' equipment. With computer and audio (or anywhere engineering, business, and less educated users meet), optimizing against presumptions is a common source of layer violations.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by ArkyBeagle on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:16PM (#11983516)
I have never believed layering fixes anything; I'll take "layer 3 switching for $400, Alex".

As has been noted, the particular quirks of the U87 ( or the like ) mean a filter to lessen proximity effect are Useful.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by tacos on Sunday June 26, 2016 @03:15PM (#11982178)
Actually it's a terrible interview because the interviewer won't shut up and is far less knowledgable than the person he's interviewing.

The "EQ settings" on the mic are actually to compensate for proximity effect. On the U87 it starts cutting at 1k -- way above what the interview states.

http://www.coutant.org/u87ai/u87.pdf

Another mic commonly seen in broadcast (and top podcasts) is the Shure SM7. Has similar switches, and even comes with a plate you can screw over the top of them so people don't futz with the settings.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by geerlingguy on Sunday June 26, 2016 @03:55PM (#11982386)
Mic choice is a lot more nuanced than is indicated in the review. Heil, EV, Neumann, Shure, and other manufacturers have a variety of mics for a variety of situations, and I bet there are some other reasons besides cost why the RE20 is such a popular studio mic across the US.

Also, rooms, talent, and equipment are often much more influential than mic selection in making a 'signature' sound. But mics are to audio engineers as languages are to programmers... Everyone has a favorite, and opinions border on the religious.

Source: worked in radio engineering for 4 years before starting programming, live audio engineering 4 years after that, and have worked with dozens of mics and varying degrees of on air talent in many environments.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by tacos on Sunday June 26, 2016 @04:12PM (#11982460)
Agreed! Unlike the U87, the RE20 is a dynamic mic so it doesn't need power. Quieter, less to go wrong, built in pop screen, smaller but still big enough to look "important", and you really can't break it. It's less boomy by default and so you get a more natural sound when you close mic things with it.

Likewise I'm sure you could swap a U87 on person X with a RE20 on person Y and it might even sound "more like NPR" depending on the natural sounds of their voices.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by geerlingguy on Sunday June 26, 2016 @08:28PM (#11983542)
Agreed on all points but the "really can't break it" — it's not some crazy indestructible capsule like the SM58! :)
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by riprowan on Monday June 27, 2016 @09:45AM (#11986109)
People use SM7s and RE20s as kick drum mics all the time, they're really, really durable compared to a U87.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by gerbilly on Sunday June 26, 2016 @06:43PM (#11983156)
>Actually it's a terrible interview because the interviewer won't shut up and is far less knowledgable than the person he's interviewing.

I agree. The number one rule of good journalism is not to put yourself in the story.

Step back, way, back, and let your subject tell their story.

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by ukyrgf on Monday June 27, 2016 @10:41AM (#11986430)
I didn't even understand his follow up to the engineer saying it rolls off at 250MHz:

> Current: Yes, but if you’re at a station and kind of frustrated with the bassy, boomy sound you get on your studio mic, and you can’t get the engineering staff to do anything about it for you, one thing that you could do yourself is to look on the mic and see if there is a bass roll-off switch, and turn it on.

Is the interviewer just tossing out "life pro tips" in the middle of an interview? Why does it start "Yes, but" when it's not a counterpoint to _anything_?

Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by Ericson2314 on Sunday June 26, 2016 @03:41PM (#11982307)
Sobering what a non-expert like me can miss then reading this.
Re:An audio engineer explains NPR’s signature sound by girvo on Sunday June 26, 2016 @11:16PM (#11984013)
The SM7s are by far my favourite mic, and what we had in my tiny little community radio studio!