Re:When You Dial 911 and Wall Street Answers
by SolaceQuantum on Saturday June 25, 2016 @06:14PM
(#11978250)
Wait, why is it morally questionable that a society comes together to, uh, pool resources and do social things?
We are a social species. It makes sense that a social species pools resources together for the good of their collective whole.
Re:When You Dial 911 and Wall Street Answers
by arcticbull on Saturday June 25, 2016 @06:23PM
(#11978284)
Remind me, how is the collection of taxes to pay for services in the public interest 'morally questionable'? The fire department in particular is such an obvious case because a fire affecting one property can easily spread to the next -- and so on. Is that something you want to happen because the property owner of the first house couldn't afford the fire department? That's morally questionable.
Re:When You Dial 911 and Wall Street Answers
by jschwartzi on Sunday June 26, 2016 @11:15AM
(#11981117)
Moreover, given a choice, a lot of people wouldn't pay ahead of time for a private fire service, leading to the kind of bankruptcy situations the article is describing. Some localities solve this problem by levying a property tax and using it to maintain public emergency services, so that anyone who would benefit from their presence in a catastrophe has already paid for the service.
This whole article just discusses the consequences of not wanting to pay taxes on anything. It perfectly described a libertarian paradise of private, for-hire, emergency services.
1) force the population to collectively pay for these services or 2) force specific individuals to provide these services for free
Option 1 is morally questionable and option 2 is a type of slavery, so it seems privatization isnt quite as bad as the alternatives. At least with a privatized service those who wish to opt out, can.