No, they are not. The optimization discussed here adds something to the existing GC, and removes nothing.
> Does anyone feel confident that a 'good enough for everyone' GC will ever be produced?
The Go GC is constantly improving, and its performance in Go 1.6 and 1.7 is considered very good my most users.
Without full memory control you're always going to making trade-offs in terms of performance. Hopefully the GC is "good enough" for your use case but there will never be a one-size fits all GC.
In almost all practical programs the new GC (in 1.5) was a significant win, or at worst no change.
Also true of Ruby or PHP. Which perform abysmally.
"Most users" needs aren't what we look for to define technical excellence - if anything, I most often see "most users" used to guide the compromising of technical standards.
Go does target "most users". That's the demographic. There will always be edge cases for which the general design does not work.
I personally like the "ARC" approach with ObjC and Swift where compiler statically adds and optimizes reference counting routines, promotes objects to stack when possible and requires programmer to manually resolve cyclic references (and Xcode supports nice methods to debug and visualize memory in order to detect unintentional cycles). Accidental memory cycles are rare enough and quite debuggable at a very little mental cost to mark some references as "weak" or "unowned". But the long-term performance and memory exhaustion issues caused by GCs are completely bypassed.
There was a Swift talk exactly about struct vs reference types and making use of COW data structures to reduce ARC impact.
Probably not, GC is always full of tradeoffs. That's why the JVM has a bunch of tuneable GCs, and there are third-party JVMs with their own strategies and GC tradeoffs (e.g. Azul).
Does anyone feel confident that a 'good enough for everyone' GC will ever be produced? If not, surely the language designers should settle on picking a type of program that they will optimise for, and sticking to it.