Had they had their own currency that was well handled their problem would still have been considered, but reforms could have actually helped.
Just because it did not work, does not mean it was not Austerity.
Otherwise, you would call every spending cut and or reductions in future growth Austerity. If your living above your means your living the high life not practicing asceticism.
Greece needed EU loans not to pay down debt but to continue to make payroll. Defaulting would have left them with less money on day 1.
> Otherwise, you would call every spending cut and or reductions in future growth Austerity. If your living above your means your living the high life not practicing asceticism.
Its totally false to say that Austerity is reduction in future growth. Normally decrease in the size of government leads to better growth.
You cant take the moral definition of Austerity, in economic Austerity means spending cuts and maybe some other measures to decrease debt.
The government was spending up to 15.2% of GDP based on borrowing money. That's never going to be sustainable and a default would have also forced them to make deeper cuts.
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/greece/government-budget
Also, several other countries have made deeper cuts. It's failure to collect and raise taxes that's been Greece's issue.
There was no remotest chance in hell it could have worked without fixing tax evasion problems.
> Cutting spending is basically Austerity.
Cutting spending is not austerity; saving money is the product of austerity, which is asceticism, something the Greeks are notably not known for, except for Sparta, which does not come into these tales. That there is a big difference in the two is proven by the fact Greece is still in a mess.Also, even if Greeks do start saving, that will only handle the symptom and not the root cause, which is corruption, and corruption comes from lack of discipline, which in turn is a state that comes from a certain way of thinking, a mentality.
Ironic that the very nation which once embodied discipline and higher cognitive thinking now lacks both, is it not? I weep for Greece, truly I do.
Without external input, decreased spending would decrease demand, which would decrease output, which would reduce the expected revenue:spending increases from the initial spending cuts, which would require further spending cuts to hit ratio targets, etc etc.
The Keynesians believe that you can increase demand by government spending but that was not an option for Greece anyway. The EU would have to pay for it but its hard to do that and do fiscal reforms at the same time.
The only solution you have left is really harsh reforms, and most importantly wage cuts. A flexible labor system is the best defence against extend recession. Check out some of the Baltic states, they took pretty harsh wage cuts. They were lucky that they did not yet have such large governments and debt that this could be done and they did not have to face default at the same time.
Greece was institutionally not capable of these things, and their situation was bad to begin with.
The should have defaulted and set up a tmp government in 2008 that could do sweeping reforms. Had they had a high change of being more or less stable right now. But the EU is against that and Greece was faced with the impossible task of both do structural reforms, debt payback and terrible monetary policy from the ECB. Its an economic shit show of epic proportions.
I certainly don't want the EU to put a government there.
Even if that was not possible, a default would have been good. Normal election would also cause some changes after such a period.
What the EU is doing is just terrible. Not letting them default and making all lending depend on the countries complaints with the EU.
Importantly for a country used to borrowing every year living within their means will seem like a huge sacrifice even if it's not optional. The further drop to paying down debt is even further, but it's that or default. And no you can't grow the economy with stimulus spending when you got used to decades of stimulus spending in the first place.
Back in the specific case of Greece, I think it may well be that the loan was taken in bad faith. But even though previous Greek governments committed fraud that doesn't mean anyone's better off now kidding themselves about the chances they'll pay.
Frankly, I'd argue that official lender's are already effectively forgiving loans by subsidizing indirectly via unreasonably good loan terms. No commercial entity would have given loans like the IMF and ECB have; they're worth far more than greece is paying. The question is then whether you're better off pretending that you are lending X principle at terms Y, or bookkeep that as the equivalent lending some fraction of X at fair-market terms Z. Even if greece can keep to the letter of the current deals, that's equivalent to having probably the majority of its debt forgiven, and the rest generating fair market returns.
It's just politics as to why that's not publically admitted - northern European voters might go bannanas. The downside is that the current situation might contribute to European instability, because southern Europe (and especially Greece) really believes they're paying all that unsustainable debt, when in fact, they aren't not really, not even today.
http://www.statista.com/statistics/275335/government-revenue...