News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK votes to leave EU by Retric on Friday June 24, 2016 @10:41AM (#11970093)
Magnitude is important. If government spending is say 40% of GDP and it drops to 20% GDP then the drop in revinues is not 50%, but closer to 20%.

Importantly for a country used to borrowing every year living within their means will seem like a huge sacrifice even if it's not optional. The further drop to paying down debt is even further, but it's that or default. And no you can't grow the economy with stimulus spending when you got used to decades of stimulus spending in the first place.

Re:UK votes to leave EU by emn13 on Friday June 24, 2016 @11:16AM (#11970391)
Clearly you can't reasonably expect spend more than you earn with a reputation for defaulting on loans. However, it's debatable to what extent debt downpayment is requirement. The risk of default is part of the deal a creditor takes on.
Re:UK votes to leave EU by Retric on Friday June 24, 2016 @11:47AM (#11970704)
If the intent is to never pay the money back then it's not a loan.
Re:UK votes to leave EU by emn13 on Saturday July 02, 2016 @10:25AM (#12022661)
If the intent is never to pay at the moment the loan is made, then it's fair to consider that fraudulent. But a loan isn't a guarantee - that's impossible. But situations unfortunately change. You can wait for default, but if you truly believe that the load has gone bad, it may well be better for both parties to renegotiate. If at that point you don't intent to pay the full original loan back (or as lender don't expect to receive all of the principal plus interest), that just means you're not delusional.

Back in the specific case of Greece, I think it may well be that the loan was taken in bad faith. But even though previous Greek governments committed fraud that doesn't mean anyone's better off now kidding themselves about the chances they'll pay.

Frankly, I'd argue that official lender's are already effectively forgiving loans by subsidizing indirectly via unreasonably good loan terms. No commercial entity would have given loans like the IMF and ECB have; they're worth far more than greece is paying. The question is then whether you're better off pretending that you are lending X principle at terms Y, or bookkeep that as the equivalent lending some fraction of X at fair-market terms Z. Even if greece can keep to the letter of the current deals, that's equivalent to having probably the majority of its debt forgiven, and the rest generating fair market returns.

It's just politics as to why that's not publically admitted - northern European voters might go bannanas. The downside is that the current situation might contribute to European instability, because southern Europe (and especially Greece) really believes they're paying all that unsustainable debt, when in fact, they aren't not really, not even today.