Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by acslater00 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @08:46PM
(#11965433)
Because the 10-year employee will be granted additional shares after her initial option grant is fully vested. And in a world where both have the option of leaving and preserving their option value, the follow-up grant will likely be larger than it is in the status quo, because the company will have to incent B to give an additional 6 years of her life to the startup.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by a13n on Thursday June 23, 2016 @08:48PM
(#11965440)
Sure but if you join on day 1 then the refresher grants could be peanuts compared to your initial offer? Why wait 4 years to find out you won't get any more equity instead of baking it into the original offer with a longer vesting period?
Longer vesting periods + more equity guarantee that employees get more equity. 4 year vesting lets the board decide what happens.
Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by encoderer on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:09PM
(#11965534)
In this scenario you give those employees a new 4 year refresher grant every single year. Not one at hire and one four years later. You pile them on both as a form of performance based compensation and to prevent the exact situation you describe.
In your example the guy who leaves after 4 years of low salary makes a lot less than the guy who gets incremental grants and a growing salary who is a vp at the end making 500k a year.
Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by a13n on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:57PM
(#11965970)
Seems like your incremental grants would be significantly less than the initial ones joining early on, no? Or is it common that leaders get big refreshers along the way?
I would say I'm pretty unfamiliar with early employee refreshes but from what I've heard refreshers are usually small compared to the initial grant.
Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by encoderer on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:11PM
(#11966024)
Yeah I think if you have somebody who is a classic "first engineering hire" and s/he grows into an engineering leader, each major promotion (to manager, director, vp) brings an opportunity for a rich follow-on, as well as a normal yearly grant. Now if somebody is particularly adept at negotiating and somehow take a full point out in their initial grant, you're probably right that incremental grants won't touch that value. But that is 2-4x what I've internalized as the norm.
Re:The Lack of Options for Startup Employees’ Options
by acslater00 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @09:00PM
(#11965493)
No one is going to 2.5x their 4 year early grant and vest it over 10.