A straightforward way to keep someone around after their four-year vesting clock expires is to grant them new shares on a new vesting schedule.
Their initial grant was part of compensation that reflected their probable value contribution to the company over the four-year vesting cycle. If the company would accrue additional value by their continuing to work beyond four years, it should compensate them for that additional value with more equity.
And it's not adequate to say their work will increase the value of their already-vested equity. Dilution happens.
Also, it's not true that the two employees receive the same compensation. The one who departs receives six years less (salary, bonus, benefits, etc.) than the one who continues for ten years.
Longer vesting periods + more equity guarantee that employees get more equity. 4 year vesting lets the board decide what happens.
In your example the guy who leaves after 4 years of low salary makes a lot less than the guy who gets incremental grants and a growing salary who is a vp at the end making 500k a year.
I would say I'm pretty unfamiliar with early employee refreshes but from what I've heard refreshers are usually small compared to the initial grant.
There's a ton of criticism in this thread but I think people are missing the point.
1. Why 90 days expiration sucks.
If you're an early employee at, say, Uber... your options have vested but you can't afford to exercise them because you don't have $10m+ in cash. If you leave you lose it all because you can't exercise them. There goes your big payout, you are stuck working at Uber until they IPO (or forfeiting your equity).
2. Why 10 years expiration sucks (on its own, keep reading!).
Consider the case where you have two employees who joined on day 1. Employee A works for 4 years and vests X% in options, leaves. Employee B works for 10 years and vests X% in options.
Obviously you want to retain your most senior employees and turn them into leaders within your company rather than see them leave. Those who stay and help carry out the mission are way more valuable to you than those who leave right when they vest.
If you change nothing except 10 years till option expiration after leaving, employee A and B get compensated the EXACT same thing despite employee B contributing 10 years and employee A contributing 4.
3. Longer vesting + more equity fixes everything
If you dish out more equity over longer periods of time then employee B would rightfully be compensated more than employee A.
I don't understand the negativity in this thread whatsoever. Can someone please level-headedly explain why they disagree rather than just downvoting into oblivion?