News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by TDL on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:49AM (#11961278)
I agree with you. I think pensions are a mistake in general, however, many municipalities, counties, and states are locked in to existing pensions schemes. I am for doing away with pensions in the future, but the existing obligations need to be funded appropriately.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:05AM (#11961482)
Doing away with pensions? Huh? How would that work? What would everyone do when they got too old to work? Do you think people should just build up a savings account? Without an annuity what would they do if they live longer than they planned and run out of savings?
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by eweise on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:17AM (#11961605)
You mean what would all the government workers do when they get too old to work? I don't know but I don't get a pension so why should I pay for theirs?
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:32PM (#11962286)
I don't understand (and I'm being down voted so I must be saying something stupid) but why do you care if government workers get a salary and a pension bought for them, or a bit more salary and buy their own pension?

And don't most most jobs still include a pension as a standard benefit? I'd say you were in the minority if you're a full time tech worker and have no pension at all.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by toast0 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:14PM (#11962677)
The problem with government pensions is that the work of today is paid for with money today and a promise of money in the future for an undeterminable number of years. Many governments have not saved prudently for their future obligations and the result is current taxes going to support past workers, which taxpayers don't appreciate when it gets extreme.

In the private sector, pensions have been going away -- I've worked for about nine employers in the last 20 years or so, only one had a pension plan, a public school district. (I wasn't eligible to participate because I held a part time position)

Many (most?) private sector employers offer participation in defined contribution retirement plans such as 401(k), some with employer contributions -- those are much simpler to manage, today's work gets paid for today. There are some government plans of this type, and taxpayers don't get upset about them, generally.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:17PM (#11962700)
Ok, so my ignorance was that when the parents said 'pension' they didn't say that they really meant 'defined benefit pensions'.

A 401k and other defined contribution pensions are still a pension.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by khuey on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:29PM (#11962817)
In colloquial American English "pension" nearly always means defined benefits.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by rm_-rf_slash on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:51PM (#11962447)
Government jobs are dull, underpaid, largely unrewarding, and people in them have to take shit from Ayn Rand acolytes like you every day for problems that are way above their pay grade.

Assuring that the people who serve society don't spend their final years in poverty is the least we can do.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:52PM (#11962458)
There's social security, retirement funds, and savings. Why does 'government job' mean anything special?
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by rm_-rf_slash on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:03PM (#11962569)
Government jobs are often very low pay. Many government workers who are promised a pension are locked out of social security. If you are being paid so low that you cannot save for regular expenses, let alone retirement, then what are you going to do when you turn 65? Turn over and die immediately?

Also, the reason you assure pension to government employees is because they tend to be stable and dependable workers over the long term.

I bet you would lose your shit if government employees in your town had the turnover of a McDonald's. Higher turnover costs mean higher taxes and much worse/less dependable service.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by jazzyk on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:32PM (#11963331)
This is like the "Java is slow" myth that will never go away :-)

In 2014 federal civilian workers had an average wage of $84,153, according the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis [1].5 By comparison, the average wage for the nation's 111 million private-sector workers was $56,350.

In Las Vegas, the average salary and benefits package for firefighter union employees was $199,678 (in 2009, I think) [2]. The average salary alone was $128,026.

Please also note that federal government pensions are in a league of its own - 80% of your last year salary - and there are stories in newspapers every year about, for example, street cops working overtime and making $120K+ in their last year.

[1] http://www.bea.gov/iTable/iTable.cfm?ReqID=9&step=1#reqid=9&...

[2] http://lasvegassun.com/news/2009/dec/30/cost-cutting-ideas-c...

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by dragonwriter on Thursday June 23, 2016 @06:41PM (#11964824)
If you compare like jobs rather than workforce averages without regard to distribution of kinds, you'll find different results.

You are also wrong about federal pensions, they aren't as a rule 80% of your final year salary. The normal FERS formula is 0.01 * high-3 * years of service (full months of service less than a year count as fractional years). The "high-3" is the highest annual pay of any 3 consecutive years of service. To get 80% of the high-3 (which, with increasing salary, is still less than 80% of last service year) you'd have to have 80 years of service.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by omilu on Thursday June 23, 2016 @07:08PM (#11964978)
>>80% of your last year salary

This was under the old retirement system called CSRS. If you entered service after 1987 you are under FERS where 20 years of service gets you 20% pension, and you get additional 1% for every additional year. So 40 years you get 40% pension, not great.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by JoeAltmaier on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:21PM (#11963230)
Sounds like a thousand other jobs. Any company would benefit from stable and dependable workers. Nobody else gets this special treatment.

I'm unconvinced. I believe they get special treatment only because they are a large lobby group.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by iofj on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:17PM (#11962157)
Given that interest rates are 0.25% and inflation (non-core, the one you'll be paying) is >3% ... what is your alternative ?

A pension is the only chance you have of a decent life when you get old. There is nothing else.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by sbardle on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:57PM (#11962511)
I'm hoping Basic Income will be up and running by the time I hit my late 60s.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by iofj on Saturday June 25, 2016 @12:44AM (#11975266)
But the "basic income" proposals are completely unrealistic. The real proposals, generally referred to as "helicopter money" are about just forgiving central-bank owned government debt, then using the free cash to embark on large infrastructure projects.

You won't see any of that cash unless you're involved in the building industry.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by TDL on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:15AM (#11961586)
There are other accounts/instruments that can replace public pensions. The reality is that politicians over promise on pensions and create unsustainable obligations for future generations.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:01PM (#11962546)
They could just use defined contribution then there's no future liability.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by HillaryBriss on Thursday June 23, 2016 @02:31PM (#11963318)
Yes. But try getting that enacted into law in California.

Public sector unions are strongly against that sort of arrangement. They prefer that the taxpayer guarantee them a defined level of pension benefit (no matter what the investment markets do).

In other words, it seems that public sector unions want the taxpayer to insulate them from the real world shocks which the other 80% of people have to endure. It's a very valuable benefit and it's understandable that they fight for it. But it is super expensive for the cities and states.

In LA there was an attempt about 5 years ago to gather signatures just to put a measure on the ballot to transition city workers from defined benefit to a 401K style defined contribution pension plan.

But certain public sector unions made it known that they planned to send their people out to sign those petitions with unverifiable, fake names and addresses. This would increase the likelihood of a failed signature verification process, meaning that the petition would probably not succeed at getting the measure on the ballot. So they dropped the whole effort.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by TDL on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:45PM (#11962956)
Agreed
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by cylinder on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:02PM (#11962559)
They would save money themselves? I thought America is all about personal responsibility and independence and such? They can use 401k just like the private sector.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by chrisseaton on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:06PM (#11962586)
But a private 401k is just another type of pension. The people I was replying to were saying that pensions, in general, so of all types, were a bad idea.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by cylinder on Thursday June 23, 2016 @06:12PM (#11964675)
Many pensions in the US promised guaranteed payments in retirement that they cannot now meet in low interest rate environments. This is one of the core issues with pensions in the US.

Also, pensions are not controlled by the individual. The money is pooled and managed by the pension fund. This is of course subject to corruption and bloated fees as we have seen. The 401k program is not perfect, and in fact needs to be totally reformed, but they at least offer more choice and competition and do not promise guaranteed returns.

Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by dragonwriter on Thursday June 23, 2016 @06:18PM (#11964708)
Pensions are defined benefit, 401k is defined contribution. They are both retirement vehicles, but distinctly different, particularly in terms of risk.
Re:California's skyrocketing housing costs, taxes prompt exo... by sphinx65 on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:59AM (#11961418)
Pensions aren't the mistake, low interest rates are the mistake.