News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by iLoch on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @03:22PM (#11956312)
I was shocked to learn water used in fracking is permanently "gone". Seems like an absolutely atrocious abuse of a resource we have a fundamental dependence on.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by jerf on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @03:58PM (#11956547)
Fresh water represents an energy issue, not a materials issue. There's no shortage of H2O molecules, it's the fact that isolating them requires energy that is the issue. If you use some fresh water to get a net gain of energy, you aren't really "spending" the water.

The natural next response is to move the goal posts and start talking about carbon dioxide or something, but I suggest resisting that and actually thinking about the real issues for a moment. True as that may be, it's a separate issue.

Contrast this with helium, which we really are running out of in a way that, if not necessarily "irrevocable", is certainly going to be much harder to get around if we use it all up.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by nickik on Thursday June 23, 2016 @03:15PM (#11963642)
Usually prices increase and we dont use it all up because you can find cheaper alternatives. For the critical stuff you would still have some left.

Interestingly, some renewable resources like whales are far easier to "finish" then the traditional onse.

Or is their some specific thing about helium that im not seeing? We should really have some helium left for space flight.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by firlefans on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @03:35PM (#11956396)
Can you clarify what you mean? It gets subducted by plate tectonics and becomes steam when heated, presumably it's still there..
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by rosser on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @11:53PM (#11958738)
Oh, so we'll be able to access that water again over geological time? That changes everything.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by contravariant on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @04:22PM (#11956678)
It's not gone it just becomes groundwater. Sure we won't see it back in any of our life times, but it's not as if we're going to run out any time soon.

In that respect fusion would be far more permanent.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by opendomain on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @05:39PM (#11957232)
No, I do not think this becomes 'groundwater'

Fracking is below the water table and and water used will be effectively lost to the water cycle. If it does leak back up, it will be polluted.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by contravariant on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @08:59PM (#11958215)
Effectively lost mean different things on a human and a geological timescale.

It could take millennia (or longer) for the water to slowly push through various kinds of bedrock, to finally get above ground again. By that time whatever contaminants were in it will have been filtered away.

It's an incredibly slow process, but it's not as if we could somehow drain the oceans by fracking at full speed for several millennia.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by DasIch on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @04:48PM (#11956889)
Isn't the very reason fracking is claimed to be safe, that the water is pumped significantly below groundwater level? If that's the case how does it turn into groundwater, is it rising upwards?
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by clock_tower on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @07:01PM (#11957733)
I think we found what to do with the water from melting glaciers. /s (?)

(I can't say if I should put a /s on the end or not. If the alternative is drowning Venice, is it a good idea to throw water out of the hydrosphere entirely? ... But if nothing else, look at the scale differences; there's no way that hydraulic fracturing uses as much water as snowpack melting generates...)

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by jessriedel on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @05:37PM (#11957222)
Fresh water isn't a closed system such that sullying water ruins it for next year. Limitations on fresh water come from the amount of rainfall, which is a conversion process being sourced from the essentially infinite ocean. If you waste some of this year's water, this year's crops might suffer but nothing permanent has happened.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by delazeur on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @05:48PM (#11957292)
This isn't about polluting water, it's about injecting waste water into deep reservoirs from which it will not return to the surface in the meaningfully near future.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by jessriedel on Thursday June 23, 2016 @10:53AM (#11961343)
I understood iLoch's comment to be about "losing" the water ('I was shocked to learn water used in fracking is permanently "gone"'), and I was explaining why one-time loss of water is unimportant, because the oceans are limitless and our fresh water supply is a rate that is sourced by the ocean. It doesn't matter if the water is polluted, injected deep underground, or fired into space. If you want, you can replace "sullying" with "burying".
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by delazeur on Thursday June 23, 2016 @11:08AM (#11961513)
I suggest you read up on North American hydrology. Fresh water is being depleted at a rate significantly greater than it is being replenished. It's also a stretch to call wastewater injection a "one-time loss of water" when we can expect to be doing it for 30-50 years.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by nickik on Thursday June 23, 2016 @03:23PM (#11963691)
While that is true, thats a purly poitical problem. If their were a prober market solution that priced according to sound resource managment priniples it would not be a problem.

The price of water woild still be very low and it would not impact standards of living in any siginificant way.

Their are tons of easy ways to save water, pertocularly in farming but that will not happen.

Its a classical tragety of the commens. They had to solve the same problem when tjey were moving west, frontier society had very soffisticated systems of water managment.

Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by jessriedel on Thursday June 23, 2016 @01:06PM (#11962598)
You misunderstand. It seems clear that iLoch views this as a fundamentally different use of water than, say, watering your lawn, since he emphasizes the gone-ness but doesn't mention the magnitude of the usage. The point is that this use of water is no different than any other one-time use of fresh water. (We'll be farming for 30-50 years too, thereby depleting the ground water.)
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by delazeur on Thursday June 23, 2016 @05:57PM (#11964596)
It is a fundamentally different usage of water. A significant percentage of the water you put on your lawn will return directly to the aquifer.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by tremon on Thursday June 23, 2016 @12:08PM (#11962073)
Assuming the wastewater injected into the ground is ocean water (I don't know if it is), it has zero effect on either the fresh water supply or its replenishment rate.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by delazeur on Thursday June 23, 2016 @05:58PM (#11964601)
Well, it's not ocean water. Not sure what your point is.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by fleitz on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @04:27PM (#11956727)
Unless you separate it into hydrogen and let the hydrogen escape into the atmosphere, it's hardly 'gone'.
Re:German government agrees to ban fracking indefinitely by m3rc on Wednesday June 22, 2016 @03:35PM (#11956395)
Not to mention the incredible amount of nearby water that is poisoned