Education has been going to hell for the past 30 years (or longer) so please don't delude yourself into thinking anything is going to magically change. The only change will be new legislation that restricts self-funded alternative education. (Maybe you've already noticed governments trying to shutdown food co-ops under the guise of "public health")
Yes, there are a ton of failing school districts, but it's not as if kids are clamoring to learn all they can and being told no. Kids aren't really motivated to learn the stuff (not that they ever have been in the history of education), and those schools aren't doing any motivating. It requires both parties to try.
I think the idea of fixing schools has, and will continue to be, examined to death. What no one seems to examine is the other half of it. How can we as a society stop perpetuating the "learning is uncool" myth? Maybe it's because a math competition will never be as exciting as a football game, maybe it's just part of human nature to be skeptical of intellectualism as a defense mechanism for the ego... I don't really know. But I don't think you can "solve education" without paying attention to that part as well.
The motivational factors that make sense to adults don't necessarily work on kids. Thinking back to when I was 13-14, being kicked out of school would have been a good thing to most of my peers. It would mean no more school, and school was a total hassle at that age.
I think the answer lies partly in finding ways to motivate students to learn, and I think the root solution to that is going to lie somewhere with teachers that can sell what they are teaching. I had history teachers that were so into their material it was almost infectious. I had an Algebra teacher that taught everything as if it were the coolest thing in the world. It's hard to not care about something when someone else is visibly excited about it.
And I think that has to be coupled with real expectations. People generally rise to the expectations that are set, and kids are no exception. The worst teachers I ever had were the ones that tried to pretend they were on the kid's side. The ones that would admit that what they were teaching was "pointless" but were "just trying to help us get through it because it is required". That is not inspiring.
Not only is it uninspiring, but it creates a responsibility vacuum. If things are pointless, and everyone knows it, and there is no real responsibility to take it seriously, then why take it seriously?
And finally, I think the biggest fix to the cultural problem has to come from our parents. Most parents are really just older kids, and deep down they have the same outlook on school as those teachers that admit it's "pointless". They talk a big game about education being important, but they don't back it up by actually considering it to be important. I don't think this has to come at the expense of other activities, but getting an A on a test should be at least as important and noteworthy to parents as winning a little league game or Prom night.
So yeah, part of it is structural, but it's by no means all structural. The education of people does not occur entirely between 8am and 3pm. Much of what we learn is from our peers and our parents and really anyone else we are exposed to socially. And crucially, the attitude we learn to adopt towards school comes almost entirely from these people who are not part of the school system, and that attitude is crucial in determining how much we get out of that 8am to 3pm period.
In this situation, doing well academically actually is looked upon favorably, more so in the single gender schools than in co-ed.
See how I turned that around on you? Simple answers are not to be found when talking about education.
You are falling into the conspiracy theory side of an education discussion almost immediately. You blame unions, then the government ("new legislation that restricts....").
It's frustrating really. I've rewritten the last part of this comment half a dozen times now. It's not worth arguing.
Blaming the government also makes sense. The government runs most schools.
Has been happening for literally hundreds of years.
Also, your forecasts are way out of line, the current admin big thing is teacher merit pay which is opposed by the unions. I'll personally send you a bottle of the liquor of choice if this administration or any of the next 3 attempt to outlaw private education.
His author description mentions that he blogs at National Review and works for e21. I know one of the founding members of e21 actually, she used to be my buddy's neighbor. It's definitely not a "non-partisan" economics think tank, just a run-of-the-mill conservative outfit. I thought Reihan was at The New America Foundation, which actually is a non-partisan think tank known for being more sexy/interesting than your mainstream institutions. Maybe he's moved on.
Anyway, I agree, it's an odd piece.
I've been considering a lot how to adjust use of words to make it clearer when I'm talking about ideas, since after all it's the ideas that matter if ideas are what we're discussing in the moment. Party alignments in non-election debate just muddy whatever the individual ideas are representing with preconceptions and even unrelated concepts, and it's harder to see where individuals cross-align, making negotiations and debates even harder than they already would be.
Libertarians, entirely different set of motives.
Disclaimer, I am not a libertarian, I align most closely with progressives, who don't have a viable party in the United States today, but I appreciate a lot of the work and ideas of conservatism, libertarianism, left-wing labor, and social democrat.
Isn't it far more interesting and valuable to talk about the world of ideas: libertarian, progressive, fiscal conservative, social conservative, fiscal liberal, social liberal, social democrat, socialist, lassez faire capitalist, and so on, than about specific parties, or to haggle over whether a person's party affiliation is the Republican Party when in fact it is a libertarian idea that is expressed. Isn't that just letting a party set the boundaries of the debate?
The ideas need to be the focus of the debate if we're to accurately discuss the work of an individual, regardless of their nominal party affiliation.
But that's not really any different from liberalism. Most youth on the left identify themselves as 'progressives' and part of the 'progressive movement' rather than identifying themselves with the Democratic party apparatus.
The article starts with a standard argument that schools suck, then launches into a libertarian utopia forecast. I'm not sure how you can have both a information economy AND people who can't put in the time at a school to learn.
Schools aren't some evil conspiracy to teach conformance, they're the only way to teach basic info to lots of kids. And if kids can't sit through it long enough to learn, the majority won't self teach either, no matter how much you want them to. So what do those people do?
There are other models for schooling, but covering classic reading/writing/math/history is still pretty important, and modern schools do a reasonable job of providing that the majority of kids.