News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by Hondor on Sunday June 19, 2016 @07:25AM (#11932605)
It's sad that this is a service instead of just free software. Did that never evolve to be user friendly enough? Do ISPs not let you run your own web server anymore? Maybe it's because of changing IP addresses and domain names? The cost of this service seems to be slightly more than the cost of maintaining your own domain name.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by hackuser on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:32AM (#11933088)
> It's sad that this is a service instead of just free software. Did that never evolve to be user friendly enough? Do ISPs not let you run your own web server anymore?

Very few users can run their own web servers. We used to deploy GoToMyPC for users; it was reliable, performed well, platform independent (including mobile), and secure. I expect it still is.

When the new OS or other new tech came out, GoToMyPC handled any compatibility issues; we didn't have to worry. No matter what the user's remote computer was, it worked (as long as there was an Internet connection). The security was good too: End-to-end encryption, optional one time pads, and even details like blanking the screen of the host machine so that someone in the room with the host couldn't monitor what the user was doing.

We stopped using it because we didn't need it any more, but we were happy customers for many years until that point.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by _asummers on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:51AM (#11933150)
> optional one time pads

Any good reason why this wouldn't be the default? Speed + key exchange transmissions, maybe?

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by mcpherrinm on Sunday June 19, 2016 @11:27AM (#11933265)
One time pads are rarely useful: The key is as big as the data, so you need a secure channel to transmit the key. If you had that channel, why not just transmit the data over it?
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by xoa on Sunday June 19, 2016 @01:33PM (#11933768)
Your mistake here is failing to consider that sharing an entropy pool does not (and in fact should not, it must be shared out-of-band anyway) need to be real time. Fundamentally, OTPs involve leveraging physical security and fleeting points of physical contact to create a pre-shared perfectly secure future communication channel. Ie., two people meet up an exchange a USB stick (or HDD), then consume the entropy pool over time. These days that could mean trivially having a pool of hundreds of gigabytes to terabytes, which equates to tens of thousands of hours of high quality voice communications, ludicrous amounts of plain text, etc, and that's assuming direct consumption. If instead it's used just for symmetrical session keys then from a human perspective it'll last forever (can burn through thousands of 512-bit keys an hour for an entire lifetime and still be fine).

The issues with OTP include that it doesn't provide authentication, it doesn't scale, pure point-to-point, etc., and that in the end the benefits it offers just don't matter in general right now vs the costs and disadvantages. There's no reason in general not just use a decent pre-shared self-gen cert, PKI or WoT key system instead. OTP applies best to any organization that can already handle physical security. Basically, if an organization moves weapons, money, or drugs around securely then it could move entropy too, so governments, militaries, banks, organized crime and the like. But for anyone to bother all existing crypto would have to be utterly broken, otherwise it's superior to just use standard crypto.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by EdHominem on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:18PM (#11935423)
> The issues with OTP [...]

The primary issue is that through misuse it degrades almost instantly from unbreakable to "little better than ROT13". And, it still appears secure to the hapless user.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by xoa on Monday June 20, 2016 @05:53PM (#11941889)
>The primary issue is that through misuse it degrades almost instantly from unbreakable to "little better than ROT13". And, it still appears secure to the hapless user.

Please explain how this does not apply identically to every form of encryption, particularly as we have directly seen vulnerability after vulnerability. That implementation matters goes without saying in these discussions, but if you want to go there then in that respect OTP is fundamentally much simpler and easier to get right then public-key crypto. Generating decent random noise, storing it in an ordered way, then deleting it automatically after use are comparatively straight forward operations to automate. Using each bit is just a matter of an XOR operation and that's it.

So I disagree with you that technical challenges are in any way even remotely the "primary issue" when it comes to OTP. If there was a need for it it'd be rapidly adopted. But outside of certain very niche scenarios, maybe, there simply isn't any need for it, nor will there be in the foreseeable future.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by EdHominem on Saturday June 25, 2016 @12:35AM (#11975242)
If I use the same AES key to encrypt two messages my communications are still mostly secure. Specifically, there's no known way to recover the key and attack all my other messages.

Versus if I use the same OTP twice my security is automatically shot and any other communication with the OTP is now also as good as leaked. Worse, context can then let much more of the key material be leaked than just the shared portion.

Even if used correctly, you've first got to create the OTP. Any mistake in generating your OTP means you can have a predictable pad and not know it. If you're trying to gather strong entropy you can know your lava lamps (/ geiger counter / etc) sources are random and be brought down by a bad camera driver.

Also, any methods to strengthen your OTP (ie, hash multiple streams together) are the very tools that you're avoiding by using an OTP. If you trust them you should just use them.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by hackuser on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:26PM (#11933485)
> Any good reason why this wouldn't be the default?

It costs time and effort for the users, not only to execute it but to learn it, troubleshoot problems, etc. It would drive many users away; in a business environment especially, that time and effort are rare and precious.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by walrus01 on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:13AM (#11933019)
In the example of wanting to access a computer in your home, you can implement this fairly easily using entirely free software with VNC-over-SSH, but it's depending on having a public IP address and open port on your home NAT/router.

One of the main reasons that things like gotomypc and teamviewer have been successful in the market is the huge number of people who don't know how to/don't care to take the time to set up an SSH tunneled setup, and want something to "just work" through NAT.

My setup looks something like this, with public/private key SSH auth. Copied and pasted from my notes, hostnames and IP addresses redacted:

-------

I have a static /30 and forward port 445 on the external side of my home router, through the NAT to port 22 on the workstation PC in my rfc1918 IP space.

workstationhostname.domainname.org normally has vnc session listening on port 5901 localhost only, spawned with:

vnc4server -geometry 1920x1200 -localhost

This is for use with an SSH tunnel coming from hostname.ofmy.static.slash30.org:445 through NAT to workstationname.rfc1918.ip.address port 22

To access from the outside world, on the client, do the following:

    ssh -v -L 5901:localhost:5901 -N -f -l myusername -p 445 hostname.ofmy.static.slash30.org

    use client system's vnc client software to connect to 127.0.0.1:5901
To access from inside the LAN, on the client, do the following:

    ssh -v -L 5901:localhost:5901 -N -f -l myusername -p 22 workstationname.rfc1918.ip.address 

    use client system's vnc client software to connect to 127.0.0.1:5901
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by zeta0134 on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:27AM (#11933063)
If you're on a Windows system this is even easier.

Go to System -> Remote Desktop Connections and check the box to enable incoming connections.

On your router, forward port 3389 to the machine you want to access.

On any client device running Windows (linux/mac can use FreeRDP, for which there are numerous wrappers) connect to your home's Public IP, and log in with your computer's usual username and password.

For the average home user this is all the setup that's needed, and it doesn't involve handing over your computer's security to a third-party company that is now a giant target for these sorts of attacks. :)

I think the big advantage that LogMeIn and GoToMyPC have in the casual realm though is their simplicity. In particular, they entirely dodge the need for the user to know anything technical at all, including port forwarding on the router, which is the bigger technical hurdle here. You just install their program and it does the rest for you. Port forwarding seems like child's play to you or me, but they have a huge market in folks who didn't even know you could log into your router and change settings. Or that even know what a router is, despite owning one.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by zschallz on Sunday June 19, 2016 @11:49AM (#11933354)
Ransomware have spread via exploitable, unupdated versions of RDP, which is worrying. Better to listen on another port of RDP must be exposed to the Internet.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by Hondor on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:02PM (#11935377)
Thanks. So it sounds like port forwarding is the major barrier. That and having to remember your IP address and update it every time it changes.

I wonder if IPVv6 would help here? Would we expect to get a static IP address for a device that can stay the same even when we're connected to different networks or via mobile data and wifi? That would mean even different network interfaces in the device would need to share the same address so I guess it still won't happen.

Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by walrus01 on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:31PM (#11933506)
which leaves your computer open to the internet by a simple login and password on the default rdp port 3389. Not nearly as good as SSH public/private key auth where the SSH private key also has its own passphrase on it.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by reallydontask on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:47AM (#11933137)
they also dodge the need to set up port forwarding, which is why we use it on our kiosks when the customers don't want to set up port forwarding.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by swiley on Sunday June 19, 2016 @07:48AM (#11932650)
I run my own web server with a residential ISP and they don't seem to mind. But in places like an office or with really crappy ISPs you just don't have a public IP. I've searched for services that just let you forward out a few ports over SSH but these don't seem to exist. Right now, to get to my laptop I have a raspberry pi "jump box" that sits on the book shelf and my laptop connects to it over SSH and forwards out port 80 and 22 so I can get to it from pretty much any network.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by mikenon on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:03AM (#11932683)
You could use https://ngrok.com to expose the ports.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by gkop on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:53PM (#11933599)
In addition to the services mentioned in sibling comments, it's not difficult to outfit a VPS for this purpose. This is a pretty helpful starting point: https://gist.github.com/gdamjan/4586758
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by ams6110 on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:27PM (#11933490)
Is it still the case that for most ISPs the uplink is much slower than the downlink speed? That was one reason running anything other than limited-use servers from your home wasn't feasible.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by gkop on Sunday June 19, 2016 @01:01PM (#11933638)
With the advent of streaming TV and movies, for many of us now the reverse is true.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by chc on Sunday June 19, 2016 @04:46PM (#11934596)
How do streaming movies make your uplink faster than your downlink?
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by gkop on Sunday June 19, 2016 @05:35PM (#11934801)
Other subscribers in the cell consume more downlink than uplink, in a steep ratio.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by mpnordland on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:03AM (#11932995)
pagekite.net is another great option for ssh and http tunneling.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by robogrowth on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:18AM (#11932725)
Ngrok.com for ssh tunneling.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by tmat on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:20AM (#11932729)
Can't recommend Ngrok enough... saved my bacon and makes testing on devices so easy and painless.
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by chmars on Sunday June 19, 2016 @08:55AM (#11932806)
Hasn't Ngrok the same security risks as GoToMyPC?
Re:GoToMyPC has been hacked, all customer passwords reset by lukasm on Sunday June 19, 2016 @10:11AM (#11933014)
Nope. With Ngrok you don't type password on the website. No xss, csrf etc