Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:20PM
(#11929555)
The state provides health care, yet there are still disparities between rich and poor. This confirms my second and third studies which show health care doesn't help.
This study also shows that (as postulated by folks down thread) that money doesn't change health behaviors.
That's the point - health disparities are mostly not caused by either health care or wealth. They are caused by something else (e.g.diet, exercise, genetics).
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by facetube on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:40PM
(#11929690)
Here, I'll give you another comment to downvote: your original claim that was supposedly backed by the Swedish RCT was "giving poor people money does not improve health". You've now reversed the direction of causation. Money could easily improve health outcomes without completely eliminating disparities between rich and poor. Your conclusion does not logically follow from your claims.
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by facetube on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:28PM
(#11929601)
The US absolutely does not have a universal health care system; roughly 33 million remain uninsured, and a large number of those who are insured do not have adequate savings to pay their high deductible (which can be as high as $6,000 per person per year in-network, and twice that out of network).
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:55PM
(#11929782)
Read all three studies. Rand and Oregon show more health care doesn't improve health. Sweden shows more money doesn't.
What, exactly, are you disputing here?
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by facetube on Saturday June 18, 2016 @02:18PM
(#11929879)
The Sweden study absolutely does not show that, and I've explained why elsewhere in the thread. The mere fact that something is an RCT does not make it instantly generalizable to all populations, no matter how many times you repeat the claim. You'd need to at least control for pre-intervention access to care and study a US population to even get close to what you're claiming.
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by yummyfajitas on Sunday June 19, 2016 @06:15AM
(#11932447)
What's the mechanism by which you think wealth increases health? It's not getting more healthcare, since if it were Oregon should have increased health.
If it's buying non-medical things, what is the relevance of Sweden's UHC?
Re:American society increasingly mistakes intelligence for h...
by facetube on Sunday June 19, 2016 @12:06PM
(#11933411)
You've made numerous unacknowledged factual and logical errors already, and appear to not understand the limits of the RCTs you're citing. I don't see any value in continuing this discussion. Have a great day.
Re: Medicaid, it's difficult to find high-quality health care in the US as a Medicaid patient, mostly because practices are free to turn you away simply because you're a Medicaid patient. "We don't take Medicaid". That's it. One of the major academic health systems here (in Oregon) systematically directed all Medicaid and Medicare patients to a single low-resource clinic across town by policy, citing inadequate reimbursement rates. The result is long wait times and inadequate care.
[1] Glenngard, A., Hjalte, F., Svennson, M., Anell, A., & Bankauskaite, V. (2005). Health Systems in Transition: Sweden. WHO Regional Office for Europe, 2005