News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by stcredzero on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:18PM (#11925632)
I think it's ridiculous for us to look for alien civilizations. Why would any intelligent person think that civilizations are stable? I mean, would you really think such a system is stable: Billions of independent sentient planet-polluting evolving biological machines with their own goals continually rewriting their own software (culture) and exponentially increasing their capabilities and rates of change? That has Chaos written all over it.

Whatever prospers and lasts in the universe as we know it isn't going to be anything like a civilization. It's certainly going to be nothing like our civilization. In fact, if there is a galactic meta-"society" of some sort, then one should think they'd disdain a chaotic exponentially-expanding civilization in much the same was as we'd individually view an incontinent, incoherent, and violent member of our own species.

The fact that we'd expect other civilizations out there is just evidence of our own parochial bias. The stark truth of the Fermi Paradox is that civilizations as we conceive of them simply don't last very long -- which also matches everything we as a civilization have come to know about systems that resemble our civilization. If "we" are going to last, "we" will have become something hard to comprehend and hard to accept by our present day selves.

https://xkcd.com/638/

https://xkcd.com/1377/

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by erikpukinskis on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:47AM (#11927269)
I suspect you come from a culture that portrays itself as disconnected from nature. You think of civilization as a kind of nihilistic growth machine that is totally devoid of meaning. That makes sense. I see a lot of that when I look at the world too.

But not every civilization is like that. There is a form of civilization which exists in deference to nature. There is a form of enlightenment which doesn't worship blind reproduction, but instead worships harmony with nature. It sees our role as humans not as an all-conquering virus, but as gardeners, shepherds of life. Not über-wolves, but über-trees. Some people call this "permaculture" but it has lots of other names, and has existed for millennia.

I think the culmination of human civilization is to reach a kind of pinnacle of progressive efficiency, combined with an almost regressive reverence for the past and our bodies and the ecologies which sustain them. I suspect other alien life may also be similarly inclined.

And this notion you have that planet pollution is the only way to exist is very sad. It's no better than climate denial. It's arguably more destructive, because you are suckering in smart people who would otherwise balk at denialists. I would urge you to spend some time learning about ways of living which nurture ecologies. There many such traditions, spanning every biome.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by stcredzero on Saturday June 18, 2016 @03:17AM (#11927448)
You think of civilization as a kind of nihilistic growth machine that is totally devoid of meaning.

Oh, ho! Look who's showing up, projecting some biases! Excuse me, but would you please point out where I said that we were nihilistic or devoid of meaning? Please provide a quote. Well, you can't, because I didn't. I was implying that our current civilization is obnoxious, not nihilist. There are many children who are obnoxious, but I wouldn't say they are without meaning, beauty or potential. A child can have all of those and still be annoying as frack.

progressive efficiency, combined with an almost regressive reverence for the past

You can eliminate the "almost" from that.

And this notion you have that planet pollution is the only way to exist is very sad.

I never said it was the only way. More projection? Again, my point is that in a galactic context, there are good arguments for why 21st century human civilization might come across as a chav.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by erikpukinskis on Monday June 20, 2016 @11:59PM (#11943410)
I said "I suspect" to leave open the possibility I was wrong, which appears to be the case. I could've been clearer about that (my punctuation is ambiguous, and "suspect" was not ambivalent enough). I regret not phrasing it as a straight question.

I would still be interested to know how your position differs from mine and from my (poor) characterization of you, if you have the time.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by WJW on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:02PM (#11924831)
I'm always amazed by people thinking it is possible for distant civilizations to pick up random radio signals (typically television broadcasts) that were transmitted on earth.

Any signals spreading out in space already has to deal with an inverse square law due to the wavefront being spread out. However, the amount of noise stays roughly the same all over the universe (as near as we can tell). This means that "pretty soon" (depending on the original broadcast power) the signal will be orders of magnitude weaker the the noise level in any receiver.

There are some techniques to pull up a signal from under the noise floor, eg using matched filters and the like. This is how GPS works. However, can only be done if you already know the signal that you are looking for. For GPS, this is not really a problem since it is well known what signal any given satellite will transmit at any given time. However, with TV shows (or any similarly information dense signal), the signal content is by definition not known already to another civilization.

This is not even going into the fact that high-information signals can be pretty indistinguishable from noise anyway if you don't know the exact modulation type and parameters used.

Pretty much the only way aliens will be able to enjoy our television broadcasts is if they come close enough to visit the solar system anyway, and by then they might as well land and look at cable TV...

(For more information, take a look at http://www.bidstrup.com/seti.htm or similar)

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by knodi123 on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:11PM (#11924902)
Can we rough out a modified fermi paradox equation that substitutes values for as many constants as possible, and takes into account the issue with the inverse square law vs background noise?

Also, can't you distinguish a lot of signal away from noise using parallax and paired telescopes?

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by jerf on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:36PM (#11924141)
"Combining the equations for the Fermi paradox and the mediocrity principle, the authors suggests Earth might hear from an alien civilization when approximately half of the Milky Way Galaxy has been signaled in about 1,500 years."

Not sure where the paper is, but the Milky Way galaxy is much bigger than that. The Milky Way is expected to be from 100,000 to 120,000 light years in diameter. A ~3200ly diameter sphere isn't "half" that.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by TallGuyShort on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:07PM (#11924382)
It also assumes that aliens could respond at the speed of light. Now in Star Trek, they could, but it wasn't our signaling that caught their attention.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by drjesusphd on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:58PM (#11924317)
Yeah, the timescale for the Fermi Paradox is millions of years; it'd be a hard sell that 1500 years can make a dent in it.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by pmiller2 on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:12PM (#11924409)
Wikipedia claims that the entire galaxy can be traversed in ~1M years. Life on earth has been around for ~3.8G years. If life started somewhere in the galaxy a few million years earlier than that, and evolved into a spacefaring civilization, it's not too far fetched that they could either have already been here, or, if they are close enough, they could pick up our signals and come for a look-see.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by jerf on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:34PM (#11925034)
A while back on HN there was a discussion about whether shooting radio waves into space was a good idea, because the game theoretic solution to "why are we alone" might be that extraterrestrial civilizations pre-emptively destroy any other competition they can identify.

What finally made me reject this hypothesis is that A: you shouldn't actually wait for intelligent life to develop, because even if humans are somehow progressing at the fastest possible rate and nothing could be faster, a claim I would seriously doubt, we're still developing at this rate dangerously quickly and B: Earth has been broadcasting "I very likely have life!" for not a century since the invention of radio, but approximately 2.3 billion years, since the invention of atmospheric oxygen, which is something that should be possible to determine from great distances by looking at the spectra lines when Earth occludes the Sun. We're already doing that a bit ourselves, and our telescopes are tiny compared to what a full Kardashev-1 civilization could put together, or even what we could put together if this was our top priority.

Even on the cosmic scale, 2.3 billion years is a Real Amount of Time.

Unless nearly every solar system has life of a similar degree of obviousness from light-years away, making Earth's signal just noise, we've been broadcasting that we're at least worth a probe for a long time. I doubt every solar system has free-oxygen-generating life or any equivalent; you don't have to believe the "Rare Earth" arguments prove that Earth is alone for it to show that even with our current understanding of physics, chemistry, etc. it is very unlikely that every, or even a majority, of systems have advanced life in them. Given that the limits of technology that we now believe in strongly suggest that an unopposed "probe" is probably on its own sufficient to colonize a planet (and thus render it no longer a threat), it remains very strange that we're here at all, not long since displaced by an aliens.

In a weird way, it would almost make more sense from the Fermi paradox point of view if we obviously hadn't developed here and if humans were obviously aliens-to-Earth, but humans have an immaculate pedigree for being 100% all-natural Earth-sourced ingredients.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:33PM (#11924574)
Right, the Fermi Paradox isn't asking why aliens haven't come to visit us now that they've surely heard our radio signals. It's about why we're even here at all, given that it seems like aliens should have come and colonized the place ages ago, or at least why there are no signs of past exploratory visits.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:44PM (#11924210)
I'm guessing they assume aliens to be scattered homogeneously around the galaxy at some probable density?
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by jerf on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:20PM (#11924942)
I'm assuming "journalist misheard something and isn't intimately familiar enough with space scales to know it". I don't really mean the latter as a criticism... however much fun it may be, there isn't much practical value to knowing the Milky Way is ~100,000lys in diameter.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by chmike on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:47PM (#11924233)
It's apparently easy to get an article published that say that aliens are all dead, minuscule or not close to reach earth. No one managed to get an article published that say that aliens have been visiting earth for many years with UFOs. There seam to be a very strong bias in peer review on this topic.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by drjesusphd on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:51PM (#11924259)
Yes, because scientists tend to be fond of evidence.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by dleslie on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:22PM (#11924480)
As it goes, absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.

I have never in my life seen a mountain gorilla. I am aware of evidence that shows that they exist, but at my age my grand parents did not have access to that same evidence; does that mean that mountain gorillas came into existence when the evidence was found? Almost certainly not, heh, but they would have been valid in disbelieving in the existence of such beasts.

There could be a person behind me with a knife, poised to slay me; but I am fairly confident that this is not the case due to a number of factors. On a population scale, such incidents are vanishingly few, and I took precautions earlier today to ensure that my home was locked and secured; but that does not guarantee certainty of my safety. It would be a fallacy, perhaps post hoc ergo propter hoc, for me to believe in the certainty that there is no such individual behind me. Until I turn around and observe the empty space, I cannot lay claim to the existence or non-existence of that individual.

We cannot observe all of Earth all of the time, and we cannot do so for the Solar system, or lay claim to having done so throughout history. This does not mean that aliens have visited us, or that they even exist; it means that we cannot be certain that they don't exist and that they haven't visited.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:39PM (#11924632)
That saying is nonsense. Absence of evidence is evidence of absence, with a strength that's determined by how likely it is that you should find evidence given what you've looked for.

Taking your mountain gorilla example, do you have any in your house? I'm guessing you'll say "no." Well, how do you know that? Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence, after all. Yet if you look all over your house and don't see any, I'd guess you would accept that as sufficient reason to say that there aren't any in your house. But how can you say that if it's not evidence of absence?

Now, finding no mountain gorillas in your house is very poor evidence for the absence of mountain gorillas on Earth, because you'd expect the same results whether or not they existed on Earth in general. On the other hand, if you've performed a thorough survey of their actual supposed habitat and didn't find any (maybe because they were driven to extinction) then you'd have pretty good (but not perfect!) evidence that they aren't there anymore.

There's essentially no evidence for the absence of aliens in the universe. You'll see this reflected in the opinion of the experts; many, perhaps most, say that it's likely aliens are out there somewhere. There's decent evidence for the absence of aliens around Earth, since we see nothing and we'd expect to see something, but it's possible they're undetectable. There's great evidence for the absence of classical UFOs, since they're clearly things we'd expect to see if they were real (people keep saying they saw them!) but out of all these sightings, none of them have turned out to be anything remarkable at all.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by ewzimm on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:42PM (#11925087)
Most of what you're saying is right, but the saying isn't nonsense. It's just describing the problem that comes up when you can't find evidence of something. If its presence would necessarily present evidence, as with the gorilla (unless it's a mutant ninja gorilla), then it's evidence of absence. If its presence would not necessarily present any detectable evidence, then it's absence of evidence, meaning that you haven't really learned anything. With something like aliens, we don't actually know what evidence to look for, so as you're saying, there's no evidence of absence yet, only absence of evidence.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:59PM (#11925188)
It is nonsense, because the saying is absolute. It doesn't say "absence of evidence is not necessarily evidence of absence." In reality, evidence of absence sometimes is and sometimes isn't evidence of absence, it depends on the specifics. The fact that the saying is correct for some cases doesn't make it sensible, any more than saying "birds don't fly" is sensible because of penguins and ostriches.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by ewzimm on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:02PM (#11925534)
It's just a cute aphorism that describes one of the main challenges in science. The "is not" is meant to convey that there are two distinct conclusions that we can make from seeing a lack of something and that it's important not to make the wrong choice while evaluating the situation. We can't automatically say "absence of evidence" or "evidence of absence" as it suits our preconceptions but need to look deeper into why something is missing.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:15PM (#11925606)
Well, every single time I've seen someone use that phrase, it hasn't been to point out that they're not equivalent, it's been to argue for the potential existence of something where there's zero evidence for it and lots of searching you'd expect to turn up evidence.

Case in point here, we are not discussing aliens in general, where that phrase might be sensible, but rather aliens frequently visiting Earth over a period of years in the form of UFOs.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by ewzimm on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:28PM (#11925674)
It can absolutely be abused, but that really just proves the point of the statement, that people tend to make biased and wrong decisions when they don't apply thorough logic. For clarity, it could have been "absence of evidence is not sufficient evidence of absence," but it just doesn't sound as nice. But it in that form and how it's intended by logicians, it's perfectly valid.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by mikeash on Friday June 17, 2016 @08:14PM (#11926328)
My point is that it is never anything but abused. Does a statement really have a point that's independent from how people use it? Especially when that use agrees with the statement's literal meaning?
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by ewzimm on Saturday June 18, 2016 @01:30AM (#11927234)
This seems like a case where something completely legitimate got so abused that it lost its meaning to many people. It does have a point. It's a classic phrase used in teaching logic to rebut the logical fallacy of an argument from ignorance. I think what you've seen is a lot of people using the authority of something from formal logic to back up their own fallacious arguments.

"The phrase "the absence of evidence is not the evidence of absence" can be used as a shorthand rebuttal to the second form of the ignorance fallacy (i.e. P has never been absolutely proven and is therefore certainly false). Most often it is directed at any conclusion derived from null results in an experiment or from the non-detection of something. In other words, where one researcher may say their experiment suggests evidence of absence, another researcher might argue that the experiment failed to detect a phenomenon for other reasons."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_ignorance

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by dleslie on Saturday June 18, 2016 @11:50AM (#11929096)
I think you vastly over-estimate our ability to have monitored the earth throughout its entire history.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 17, 2016 @04:02PM (#11925214)
There are at least a few cases of hard evidence of UFOs, as in, "unidentified flying object" with no plausible physical explanation and observed by many trustworthy witnesses. They could of course be explained by many other causes than little green men, and I personally don't think there are little green men, but we don't know what these were.

In particular, these ones I find very interesting:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japan_Air_Lines_flight_1628_...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2006_O%27Hare_International_...

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cash-Landrum_incident

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manises_UFO_incident

So I don't think lack of evidence is the reason for no scientific effort, but rather, how would you conduct science based on that evidence?

And actually, some "UFO-type" phenomena are under scientific investigation, such as the Hessdalen Lights:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hessdalen_lights

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by NetStrikeForce on Friday June 17, 2016 @05:35PM (#11925711)
What's the relation between UFOs and aliens? If you have evidence of one or more UFOs how are you relating them to aliens? Why not just magic or secret super heroes?
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by semi-extrinsic on Friday June 17, 2016 @06:46PM (#11926004)
GP post was talking about aliens and UFOs, and parent post claimed there is no evidence (thus no science).

I was pointing out that we do have relatively credible evidence for UFOs (but not aliens), i.e. lack of evidence is not why there is no scientific papers on the topic of UFOs.

I think the most likely explanation of most of these are classified aircraft of some sort.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by chmike on Saturday June 18, 2016 @02:19AM (#11927329)
There are plenty of evidence provided you don't reject them a priori.

1. there are plenty witness accounts reporting non human beings seen in proximity of UFOs.

2. Betty Hill map (abduction case) matches our solar system and shows a ring around jupiter witch was only discovered many years after the drawing was made by voyager.

3. Behavior and flying capabilities of UFOs far beyond human technology capability.

4. Inductive research on possible propulsion principle made by Prof. Meessen led to a theory where Pulsed Electro Magnetic Propulsion would be used. The author derived an innovative mechanism to produce very intense oscillating EM fields using only supra conducting surface on the object. This supraconductivity must work at high temperature which humans don't master yet. This supraconductive shell is also protecting living bodies and devices on bord from the intense external EM field.

5. Some photos of UFOs show black rings around the object which might result from polarization of light resulting from the very high EM field which humans can't produce. This data allows to infer properties of the EM field.

6. Compass rotation reported on military ships while a UFO was seen. A study by Prof. Meessen explained that this is produced by oscillating EM fields in low frequency range. Considering the estimated UFO distance the magnetic field must have been of many Tesla. Humans can't produce such oscillating magnetic intensities. A referree rejected the submited article presenting this study result partly because this EM was too strong in his opinion and not feasible.

Etc. Etc.

Of course there is no proof. But there is plenty evidence and now we have at least one theory that can be tested in a lab. The described propulsion method is still unreachable to humans because we don't master supraconductivity at high temperature, but we can now test experimentally the validity of the theory.

Ufology has been censored for many years as research topic with the consequence that very few people are correctly informed on it. They claim there is no evidence but objectively they should say they don't know about the evidences and scientific research on this topic. Skeptics do a lot of noise to hide the facts and work.

My knowledge of the UFO phenomenon is different as I'm very close to Prof. Auguste Meessen. Here are the articles presenting his theory on the PEMP [1](http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/Propulsion.pdf) [2](http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/Evidence.pdf) [3](http://www.meessen.net/AMeessen/Production.pdf).

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by effingwewt on Saturday June 18, 2016 @08:25AM (#11928237)
For the record, anything can be "evidence". Eyewitness, secondhand etc are all circumstantial anway. Ufology could easily be considered akin to bigfootology.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by chmike on Sunday June 19, 2016 @04:41AM (#11932286)
That is not correct. There is a huge difference in the data set size and as a cinsequence bigfootology doesn't provide as many grips for scientific research.

In ufology there is enough data to find testable information allowing to deduce/induce insight on the phenomenon.

The Betty Hill map is one such example. The testimony of Betty and Barney Hill is not testable and could be fully imaginary. But the map is data that can be tested. And many scientists did test it. Many scientists searched a correspondance with a set of stars. Many where found but the one of Zeta Reticuli got the most instense PR. It must be noted that there is a circle in the center of the BH map which hasn't any matching star. Some reproductions of the map have removed the circle to "solve" the problem. Karl Sagan said that would found many many matching set of stars because the number of stars is so high. He is right.

The discovery of Koch and Kyborg, is that the map shows our own solar system. Their reasonning is that the the two big circles crossed with a curved line could be rings. The other argument is the circonstance in whitch the map was shown. Betty just asked to the leader where they came from. The leader asked back, "what do you know of space?". She said she now the 9 planets of our solar system that she learned in school. The leader than show the map and asked where is earth. She said she didn't know. The leader than said "so what is the point to tel you where we come from?". Koch and Kyborg deduced that this map could correspond to our solar system. They check this is and fiund the match. The two big circles correspond to saturn and jupiter. The cent circle not connected with a line is the sun. Make sens that there is no connection to it. The small circle below tje sun is mars. The configuration of the planets correspond to the month Betty and Barned were abducted. Well not exactly, mercure which is rotation very fast around the sun was 120° of position. But Koch and Kyborg suspected that there could have been more than one abduction. The testimony is not incompatible with that.

What I found with a colleague is that no human new at the time the map was drawn that Jupiter had a ring. This is for me a strong evidence that the story could be true.

Then there are the rotating compass. There are also many instrumental recordîgs.

And from all this data, it was possible to elaborate a theory explaining a possible propulsion mechanism. This is inductive research methodology and how science made the most breaking through discoveries. This theory implies that ufos are using high temperature supraconductivity. Then there is the energy source which is also something that we don't master. The energy they spend that could be deduced from some testimonies is huge. Humans don't master a method allowing them to produce such amount of energy.

Peolpe who say there is no evidence or there is not more evidence than with bigfoot are ignorent or suspectfully dishonnest. The taboo in the media and scientific journals induce a reenforcing ignorence of this research subject.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by drjesusphd on Friday June 17, 2016 @07:04PM (#11926072)
Talking about UFOs strictly as such is besides the point and dodging the audacity of the claim.

This conversation is about aliens. Until evidence arises of aliens, not "unidentified flying objects", it has no business making it through peer review as a resolution of the Fermi paradox.

Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by voidz on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:56PM (#11924302)
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by splawn on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:01PM (#11924344)
The fact that there are retractions shows that evidence matters... so "Yeah."
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by drjesusphd on Friday June 17, 2016 @01:59PM (#11924324)
Not saying it's a universal trait.
Re:Relax, it'll be 1,500 years before aliens contact us by libeclipse on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:11PM (#11924407)
"We are on the third planet around a tediously boring star surrounded by other completely normal stars about two-thirds of the way along one of several arms of a remarkably average spiral galaxy."