I agree with everything you said. But it doesn't address why you think secrecy is always necessary.
Re:Buffer Layoffs
by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 16, 2016 @05:13PM
(#11918907)
If you work because you need a job, and your company is transparent, and its in a financially precarious state, why would you stay?
In this case though, the graph shows that the layoffs are bringing Buffer to profitability. If they kept that secret and just told the employees not to worry, they would be just as likely to assume that management was merely decreasing the burn, in which case their assumption would be worse than reality. Secrecy cuts both ways.
Anecdotal of course! I'd love to have more data on this to find out what that tipping point is.