News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexi... by pdonis on Thursday June 16, 2016 @09:40AM (#11915990)
> the theory shows that the decay have to be polynomial

I thought this was the other way around: the theory predicts exact exponential decay, but experiments aren't entirely clear that that is always the case. Depending on which textbook or paper you read, some say the deviations from exact exponential decay are just experimental error, while others say they are evidence of additional effects that the exponential decay law does not account for.

Re:Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexi... by stared on Thursday June 16, 2016 @10:06AM (#11916174)
It's clearly not that way you say.

From quantum field theory, you get polynomial decay and it's quite fundamental (related to causality, holomorphic functions (Kramers–Kronig relations)) and if it were not working, a lot of physics would need rewriting.

EDIT:

I remember it from a lecture, many years ago. Some googling brings me to this thread with links to papers:

http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/7008/long-time-de...

Re:Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexi... by pdonis on Friday June 17, 2016 @02:19PM (#11924461)
> From quantum field theory, you get polynomial decay

I think you're oversimplifying, although I agree that I was also oversimplifying when I said that the theory predicts exact exponential decay.

What I get from that stack exchange thread and the linked papers is this: in an idealized (and not physically possible for a real system) model in which every individual decay is statistically independent from every other and in which all of the quantum states that are possible end points of the decay are unoccupied, the theory predicts exact exponential decay. But in real physical systems, neither of those conditions is exactly true. Individual members of an ensemble of decaying quantum systems (such as radioactive atoms in a sample) interact with each other (either directly or indirectly via states in the environment), so their decays are not completely independent; and any real decaying system has an external environment which includes some occupied "target" quantum states. When these effects are taken into account, the theory predicts a decay law which is often called "power law" but which I would describe as more of a "truncated exponential": it replaces an infinite series of power law terms (the exact exponential) with a finite number of them. The actual measured decay law in a given experiment will depend on how much the experiment probes the portion of the state space where the above effects are significant (for example, a decay law measured over a very long time can deviate measurably from exponential where a measurement over a shorter time would not).

Re:Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexi... by stared on Friday June 17, 2016 @03:47PM (#11925120)
AFAIR if you have a single excited particle, you still get this polynomial decay. (It was more about every distribution and Fourier transform properties - as mentioned in the post.)

Yes, in these subtle effects backaction may be important. (The whole non-exponential decay is because the "emitted" EM field acts back on the particle.)

Re:Why Philosophers Should Care About Computational Complexi... by pdonis on Friday June 17, 2016 @09:06PM (#11926502)
> AFAIR if you have a single excited particle, you still get this polynomial decay.

I'm not seeing that in the linked papers. I'm seeing descriptions of exponential decay under certain conditions, and deviations from that under other conditions.